Skip to main content
Today 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM

Customer Reviews of Carver Toyota of Columbus

Review type:

32 reviews
Sort by:

  • Service Dept did not perform work paid to do

    1 out of 5 starsby Sarah47201 on 06/28/2016

    Received a quote from the service department to replace 2 gaskets. Dropped the car off and requested used parts be saved for me. Returned to pick up the car and only one gasket had been replaced. Technician included an o-ring in with the one used gasket. My car has a timing chain tensioner gasket and does not have an o-ring. Invoice included charges for the timing chain tensioner gasket but narrative stated they replaced o-ring. Called and spoke with Service Manager who investigated complaint. He determined the technician did not replace the timing chain tensioner gasket and stated the technician told him he took the o-ring out of his toolbox. Arranged a time to return to the dealership to have the second gasket replaced. Service Manager seemed to sincerely want to rectify the situation, however, it should not have been necessary to return a second time to have the work performed.
  • Absolutely Awesome Experience!

    5 out of 5 starsby theduck60 on 05/27/2016

    "This is the way to buy a car!" Thank you Brian, for a wonderful buying experience from beginning to end! Thank you Tim for a pleasant experience signing all those papers too. We are extremely happy with the car, and the total experience. We will most certainly refer any of our friends and relatives down your way!
  • Tundra Purchase

    5 out of 5 starsby dmr63ii on 03/20/2016

    Very pleasant experience with Scott Babb and the team at Carver Toyota. Toyota has a strong reputation for high quality so my comments are more about the Carver team here in Columbus Indiana. The Carver dealership is a no pressure atmosphere, helpful, courteous, provided comments to help me learn about the product and Toyota support and service offerings. The Carver facility was clean and a warm, welcome atmosphere. Clearly they pay attention to the details to make sure you feel comfortable, safe, and at home. Also a very pleasant experience with the Carver finance leader, Tim. Tim was efficient, helpful, and made sure I understood all the details as we wrapped up the new purchase. I recommend Scott and Tim to anyone and you will be treated with respect and courtesy. I wanted to keep my business local and also wanted to buy a US made product. I'm only a few hours into my Tundra ownership experience, but I have confidence in my fellow citizens in San Antonio, TX and I suspect they did a best-in-class job assembling this Tundra. If you are in the market for a truck, do not buy before you have a chance to drive and sit in the Tundra Crewman.
  • Great Experience

    5 out of 5 starsby Amitnrai on 08/24/2015

    I recently bought my new corolla le. The experience at Carver was unmatched. The flow of activities, information was impeccable. I liked the staff, particularly Paul Dyer who made the overall buying experience stress free, came across as quite well informed and professionally excellent. I would recommend them to prospective fellow car buyers
    • That's what we like to hear! Customer satisfaction is the number one goal here at Carver Toyota and we'll always do our best to make sure you have an awesome experience with us. Please let us know if there's anything else you need. Thank you!

      by cwylonis on 08/25/2015

  • Awesome Experience!

    5 out of 5 starsby RetiredUSAF on 07/28/2015

    Without a doubt, the quickest and easiest car buying experience ever. The salesman was friendly, knowledeable and efficient. The finance manager got us in and out in no-time. I will definitely return for future purchases!
  • Excellent Experience

    5 out of 5 starsby mbckl7303 on 05/18/2015

    I had an excellent experience at Carver. It was the most painless car buying experience I have had. The car was ready for me to test drive and there was no pressure. They met my offer and did not try to push anything else on me. Nick Dougherty was wonderful and made my experience enjoyable. He removed an old license plate for me without any issues. I would recommend them to anyone.
  • Very happy customer!

    5 out of 5 starsby karleagleman on 04/08/2015

    Top notch service! I worked with Tim Mellinger who genuinely cared for my best interest, and was always upfront about all details in leasing my 2015 Toyota Tacoma. I'm so happy with the deal that I got and how I was treated as a customer. I highly recommend Carver to anyone looking for a vehicle.
  • Great for purchasing and service

    5 out of 5 starsby gf1955 on 03/18/2015

    I have had nothing but great service at Carver Toyota in sales and service. I inquired online for a new vehicle and within minutes had a response with my questions answered. When I went in to test drive, I was greeted and had the car I was interested in pulled up and ready to take for a drive. Sales associates were friendly and the purchase process was the easiest one I have had to date. Finance was promote and painless. I have had my new car in once for service and had a great experience as well. Amanda helped me in the service area and greeted me with a smile and was treated with respect. I would recommend Carver to anyone purchasing a vehicle in the Indianapolis area.
  • Awesome!

    4 out of 5 starsby Toyotaproud on 01/08/2015

    Had a great service experience here! My service person even washed my car for me! It was finished quickly and they listed exactly what they did to my Rav.
  • Complete Lies

    1 out of 5 starsby chillman1 on 09/16/2014

    Buyer Beware Very poor business practice here. False information given by the various departments involved. Deal that was promised suddenly could not be made. Classic bait and switch. Huge waste of time.
  • Great Service

    5 out of 5 starsby elle_37408 on 05/16/2014
    updated 08/01/2025

    The service here is amazing: so helpful and honest. I don't feel swindled. They are also great with kids, very accommodating so I could focus on what I came for. A car!

About our dealership