Andy Mohr Buick GMC
Today 8:30 AM - 8:00 PM
Customer Reviews of Andy Mohr Buick GMC
Review type:
Write a review: Sales
32 sales reviews
Sort by:
Great Experience
by Michael C on 07/03/2025The team at Andy Mohr is great to work with. My salesman Carlos Pena answered all my questions and was very responsive to messages and calls. In the end, he got me the deal I wanted and we found the perfect vehicle.Great Experience !!!
by CHAWILLI75 on 04/15/2024I had gone a week or so prior had an awful experience at another dealership, took a chance going to another one for the shop for the same vehicle. I did my credit app online and Yogi called me and set up an appt for the next day. HE IS AN… AWESOME SALESMAN! We laughed and talked about all kinds of things while getting the numbers right! Such a stress free experience! Thanks again Yogi!Thank you for taking the time to share your feedback regarding your experience at Andy Mohr Buick GMC and congratulations on your new vehicle! Buying a new car is a huge step and we’re honored that we got to be a part of it. Please feel free to reach out if you need anything!
My first car purchase
by Iryna M on 12/27/2023Thank you so much, Rob Evans! That was such an amazing experience to buy my very first car in the USA! Thank you so very much! Rob was very nice and friendly. And he did his job well for 100%. Would definitely recommend him for my friends… and family! Thank you again! Everything was great from the beginning when we just came in the dealership and to the very last minute when I left it on my brand new car! Thanks 😊Good news at Andy Mohr Buick GMC
by Pharmr84 on 06/23/2022Andy Mohr came through two times this year for us. In April and again in June. James was our sales consultant and was able to secure vehicles for my wife and I. He worked hard to secure a GMC Terrain for me equipped they way I wanted. He… kept in contact with me and updated me weekly until it arrived. Once it was here their finance department moved through the process efficiently, no hard selling. I recommend James and Andy Mohr Buicj-GMC.Stay away from this place
by Taylor on 04/06/2022Screwed us over on a down payment and now haven’t had the car 3 weeks and it needs engine serviced. It’s a 2022 Acadia. Stay awayWorst purchase experience - empty promises
by Brittani D on 02/19/2021This was by far the worst experience I’ve ever had when purchasing a car. They would tell me something on the phone (it has 2 keys, we will sell it to you at X price, we will provide a gas card,etc) and act like they had no idea what I was… talking about when I would come into the dealership. The dealership is about 30mi from my house & they have wasted my time & gas with false promises. When you think of “Slimy Sales” this is the epitome of the staff up to and including management. If any other surrounding dealership had this vehicle, I would have paid more for it to not have to deal with this team. I’m absolutely repulsed as they claim they want you to buy more cars from them & have repeat business, yet have zero customer service skills. Do not purchase from them if you like working with people who have integrity. I would go so far as to say this was actually a traumatic experience because I had no idea people still operated in such shady fashion.Hidden fees
by Andy Mohr on 02/04/2021Dealer fees are over and beyond acceptable. Follow up also unacceptable for services promised.Now was great
by Sally on 01/15/2021updated 01/22/2021Moe was very helpful and I would come back againOut Of Towner
by Out of Towner on 01/07/2021updated 01/14/2021Jorge Guaman helped expedite the buying process 3/4 of the work was able to be done before I walked in the door to include a phone call with finance so I knew where everything would land when all was said and done. Pricing online was… non-negotiable but fair market value. I appreciate all the paperwork and exchange of information being so quick. Via text and email, Jorge was on it to help with my buying experience.Worst Dealership around Indianapolis
by JD on 12/29/2020I’ve hesitated writing this review but after three awful experiences here over a year’s time in between I feel it’s time to. First off the buying experience here was horrible. The salesman and manager were rude, lied multiple times, and… disrespectful to my pregnant wife. Against our better judgement we bought our car here because it was exact car we wanted. The finance person we dealt with was nice and helpful. The manager agreed to fix one thing if we bought it (got it in writing). After we purchased the car we had to wait weeks for them to finally fix it. After we picked the car up it broke down a few days later and had to be towed in. They eventually fixed the issue. A few months go by and something else minor went wrong with the car, we brought it in and when I came to pick it up they pulled up the wrong car. They could not find our car or our keys. I waited over 30mins and eventually the service person pulled it up. The car smelled like cigarette smoke and so did he. I let it go again and shouldn’t have. Now yesterday we received a letter in the mail saying they’re in desperate need of (fill in the car type) we’re paying between $1,000-$4,000 over NADA trade in value. Now with any good car dealership “deal” I know there’s fine print but this one seemed genuine and I figured it’s worth a shot to see what they would offer. I show up talk to the guy they flew in saying he’s going to get us a great deal, etc. I waited over an hour and they come back and offer me $5,000 UNDER NADA “average” trade in price. I laughed and the salesman said yeah this is all I can get. I went and talked to the promo guy and he didn’t even defend it. Long story short this place is awful. Do yourself a favor and drive far away or anywhere else to buy a car. I held my tongue and gave them multiple chances but do not waste your time here and spread the word, I will.Andy Mohr Buick GMC
by Andy Mohr on 12/18/2020Worked with Andy Q, he was very helpful no pushing just helped me through the process. Financing was smooth and presented in a professional manner (Leroy).Purchase
by Annie K on 11/25/2020We purchased a Buick Regal today from Moe Taha at Andy Mohr Buick in Fishers and the experience was great. We arrived 30 minutes before closing , but this had no impact on the attentiveness of Moe. We are very pleased with the cool car that… was actually suggested by Moe. I really didn’t think we would like the color, but loved it. All is well and we drove home with the car the next day . Thanks Kevin & AnnieGreat Service
by Great Service on 10/26/2020Tried our local GMC dealer an couldn’t get the deal done,went to Andy Mohrs in Indy an Jeff Jackson was more than willing to make a deal.Thank You Jeff2020 AT4
by R Heath on 10/08/2020My salesman Marcus was informative and very helpful. I would suggest contacting him next time you need a ride. The whole dealership earned my business and I was very pleased working with them.We're glad to hear that Marcus was so helpful! Thank you!
2020 Sierra
by Rich T on 10/07/2020By far the most pleasant buying experience I’ve ever hadThat's wonderful to hear, Rich! Thank you!
Very good sales experience.
by Kim on 10/06/2020I have to say I hate buying vehicles. I would rather have all my teeth pulled knowing I have to deal with a car salesperson. That is the main reason I drive my vehicles into the ground. My experience with Andy Mohr was quite pleasant while… getting to know Jeff Jackson, our salesman. We bought a new Envision and so far no buyers remorse. All the staff was great and we will return in the future.We're glad to hear that Jeff was so helpful, Kim! We really appreciate you taking the time to share, and we hope you're loving your new Envision!
Awesome Andy
by AlexisC2013 on 10/06/2020Andy was amazing! I got the car I wanted, service was wonderful and the payments are good! Best customer service ever and the whole staff was kind and accommodating! You guys rock!!That's so great to hear, Alexis! Thanks so much!
Bought a used vehicle.
by Bought a used vehicle on 09/14/2020We are very pleased with our purchase and service we received. Our sales person,Shannayle went out of her way to answer the many questions we had. Tami,was very helpful and caring. We were from out of town,and Tami made sure she gave us… helpful advice on where to stay and restraunts in the area.She even gave us her cell phone number in case we got lost or needed anything. Everyone involved was great.That's so great to hear! Thanks so much for sharing your experience!
Inaccurate Pricing
by Erin D on 09/09/2020Andy Mohr Buick GMC listed a Toyota Prius for $15,350 on an affiliate website. I contacted a representative and asked for the final price of the car and he quoted me $16,987.36 to drive it off the lot. later he contacted me and said that… the listed price on the affiliate website was wrong and the car is $18,900 and over $20,000 to drive it off the lot. The manager knew the vehicle was listed incorrectly on other sites but didn’t care. I’ve been watching the car for two weeks and they have fluctuated the price of the car to get leads to contact them. While there are no rules that companies have to honor advertised prices, it’s unethical for Andy Mohr Buick GMC to mark the price of the car thousands below the actual price.We appreciate your feedback here, Erin. Unfortunately, the affiliate website that you are referring to is Edmunds.com, which Andy Mohr Buick GMC does not support or pay to advertise on. That means the information contained in their listings is not always accurate. The affiliate sites that we do support and pay to advertise on, such as cars.com, autotrader.com, and cargurus.com, all have the price listed correctly. Please refer to those sites, or our actual dealership website, for clear and accurate pricing.
[non-permissible content removed]
by Geanene on 05/04/2020I received an email list a vehicle for a different price automatically the salesman had a student problem. Told me I had to pay a different price. Hung up on me! The used car salesman told me he dose not have to sell a car at a price listed… their his cars he can do what he wants. Well nasty attitude and nasty service. Do not waste your time with a company that dose false advertising and has I don’t care attitude. There are plenty of dealerships that care and don’t scam people.Great Sales Experience
by Scott_Z on 03/01/2018I recently purchased a vehicle from Andy Mohr Buick GMC & Tami Worley. Tami was extremely knowledgeable and exceptional at what she does! I was very pleased with my sales experience with Andy Mohr and Tami; and I would highly recommend… them to my family and friends!
About our dealership
Thank you, Michael! We’re thrilled to hear about your positive experience with Carlos at Andy Mohr Buick GMC. It's fantastic that he was able to address all your questions and help you find the perfect vehicle at a great deal. We appreciate your feedback and look forward to welcoming you back for any future needs!
by Andy Mohr Buick GMC on 07/07/2025