2024 BMW X3 M40i

The Audi Q5 checks all the right boxes in the small luxury SUV category, but sadly there isn't anything that it does particularly better than its competitors. Unlike the X3, which sets itself apart with exceptional driving dynamics, the Q5 is merely OK in the fun-to-drive department. Still, if you're looking for something comfortable and well made that comes with an impressive complement of tech features, the Q5 is a worthy choice. And to start, it's priced slightly lower than the X3.

There's a lot to like about the Mercedes-Benz GLC. It offers powerful and efficient engines, excellent ride quality, and a stylish interior brimming with tech and convenience features. It's even more exciting to drive than the X3. But the BMW has it beat when it comes to cargo capacity and fuel economy for the four-cylinder. You'll also pay less to get in an X3 than a comparably equipped GLC.

The Genesis GV70 is our current favorite in the small luxury SUV class. It might not be quite as luxurious as the GLC, but it's a fantastic all-arounder that should not be overlooked. Its 14.5-inch touchscreen infotainment system features sharp graphics and responsive touch controls, but unfortunately only supports wired Apple CarPlay and Android Auto smartphone integration, unlike the X3 which is wireless. The GV70 is also reasonably fun to drive, especially with the turbocharged V6 upgrade engine, and supremely comfortable when equipped with the available adaptive air suspension. To top it all off, the GV70 is an incredible value with its relatively low starting price and unrivaled warranty coverage.