Used 2004 Porsche 911 Consumer Reviews - 66 Car Reviews | Edmunds

2004 Porsche 911 Consumer Reviews

View reviews for a specific 911 model:

sort by

Most Recent|
Most Recent Most Helpful Highest Rating Lowest Rating
911 C4S is all that and more
Performance
Comfort
Fuel Economy
Fun To Drive
Interior Design
Exterior Design
Build Quality
Reliability
By John L Yacina
on

Vehicle

2004 Porsche 911 Carrera 4S AWD 2dr Coupe (3.6L 6cyl 6M)


Review

If you have always wanted a Porsche 911, drive a vintage 2000 to 2004 C4S and you will buy one. Any air cooled fan will be converted. More horsepower, greater comfort, A/C - cooling and heating - that actually works, PSM to keep non-race car drivers off of the guard rails, front and side air bags too. And the C4S has the wide body, stiff chassis, and big red brake calipers that come with the turbo. And like the turbo, the C4S is 10mm lower to the ground than the base 911. A few recommended mods that are typically already done on these cars are aftermarket exhaust (Fabspeed on mine) and a LN Engineering IMS replacement. I also installed an Evolution Motorsports air intake. It sounds AWESOME when accelerating! Just a pure pleasure to drive. And the faster the better. I have owned one since 2015 and every time I drive it I am reminded why I love the car. And you can get one for less than $40K!


Was this review helpful? Yes | No

Overlooked Gem
Performance
Comfort
Fuel Economy
Fun To Drive
Interior Design
Exterior Design
Build Quality
Reliability
By John Nothelfer
on

Vehicle

2004 Porsche 911 Carrera Rwd 2dr Coupe (3.6L 6cyl 6M)


Review

Unfortunately, the 2004 Porsche has taken the same bad rap as all the other years of the 996 Porsche's. I feel my 996 is definitely superior to the 993 Porsche I owned previously but its value is about half. Comparing my 993 with my 996 is like comparing a high school baseball player with a MLB player. I feel the 996 is superior in every aspect- comfort, performance, reliability, etc. I've had the IMS bearing upgraded so I have no worries about the car's reliability. I intend to keep it serviced and enjoy it for many years to come. Perhaps the same story will be written in years to come like the sudden increase in prices of turbos over the last few years. The second generation 996's certainly deserve more respect. During the last year, I've replaced some normally serviced components (spark plugs, ignition coils, oil, coolant) but other than that, just gas. I found the more I drive it, the better it looks. Just my opinion.


Was this review helpful? Yes | No

Super reliable, not for everyone or occasion
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
Performance
Comfort
Fuel Economy
Fun To Drive
Interior Design
Exterior Design
Build Quality
Reliability
By SJFlyer
on

Vehicle

2004 Porsche 911 Carrera 4 AWD 2dr Cabriolet (3.6L 6cyl 6M)


Review

This car is surprisingly reliable. Porsche has really worked out every bug since the introduction of 996. Get a manual trans if you can and stay with a coupe. Convertible can get very noisy on highway. It was my daily driver for 5 years. Stopped driving it when my commute became too long. Traded it in for a new Range Rover for comfort.


Was this review helpful? Yes | No

3 in 1:Turbo
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
Performance
Comfort
Fuel Economy
Fun To Drive
Interior Design
Exterior Design
Build Quality
Reliability
By Dave
on

Vehicle

2004 Porsche 911 Turbo AWD 2dr Cabriolet (3.6L 6cyl Turbo 6M)


Review

Hardtop on, soft top down or convertible top up!!! Regardless, the performance, traction and handling are flawless! Gergeous wide hips, sleek lines with Tech Art front nose and bright yellow brakes boosts its all 911 business. Yet, the "whoa" appearance is as close to the sensual need to unleash its twin turbo furry! ... Total SoCal performance sports car!


Was this review helpful? Yes | No

Best Porsche despite what "purists" say
15 of 15 people found this review helpful
Performance
Comfort
Fuel Economy
Fun To Drive
Interior Design
Exterior Design
Build Quality
Reliability
By Jeff w.
on

Vehicle

2004 Porsche 911 Carrera 4S AWD 2dr Coupe (3.6L 6cyl 6M)


Review

Internet says these cars blow up but it's just not the issue the purists would have you believe. Stories stem from early IMS history, but failure rate is really much lower than Toyota and other "reliable" manufacturers. This is the car that saved Porsche in 1999. I've owned 2 other Toyotas and have never really had a sports car- Im 60 years old now, not a wealthy person, but mostly been on the conservative side of family car type ownership.
I love this car because it is an icon, beautiful, comfortable and untouchable from a performance and racing legacy point of view. I would buy another.
Buyer beware however, these cars are often abused, but they can take it like no other make.

Personally I think the 996s are one of the best 911 designs, because it was the first thoughtful departure from the old VW bug aesthetic...from the 1998 models forward, the Porsche became a modern car. Porsche sold more of this 996 series than all other series prior, so they did something very right. Just look at the brand new ones 991 model, they are very similar to the innovative design of Pinky Lai and that design language is carried on today. The 996 headlights were a style complaint from many of the owners of the 1999 model - but Porsche fixed that the following year of the new 911- the design is not ugly (subjective), but again innovative for the time. In fact, the lights came directly from the GT1 high performance exotic Porsche. Then the lights were moved to the Boxster - which preceded the new 996 911 and was considered a good thing. Owners of the pricier 911 didn't want their ride to look like the cheaper Boxster from a distance. Water cooled is a more reliable than the air cooled and interior comfort is on par with modern vehicles. The interior is very comfortable. I drove from Boston to Hershey Pennsylvania - 7 hours and didn't feel stiff or achy at all. Very surprised, but pleased. Only real complaint is that cabin noise had a lot of engine and wheel/ tire noise and can be tiresome after many miles of highway driving. On the flip side it's sound is intoxicating when accelerating and cornering, giving occupants the visceral feeling of driving in a true race car legend.

I now have 94,000 miles on this car and this is my daily driver- 90 miles per day all year round. We live in New England where snow and ice is a regular occurrence. Super stable in the snow and wet for such a light car.
After all these years, I still get thumbs up from all age drivers and pedestrians.
The 4S model (mine) is the Turbo look style so it has all of the great wide body wheel wells, has Turbo (large) brake discs, Turbo clutch, sits very low and was like that stock in 2004. All the rage these days , racer boys slam their rides to the ground for the right stance. Porsche figured that out ages ago and the car still looks and performs better than any modern car today.
I've had two main problems though: a torn CV boot on the front wheel viscous drive transmission, caused a bearing to fail and killed my FWD. I replaced that with a used unit for $3K. A recurring thing has been the power steering fluid seems to get low every few months. There are no leaks, but the fluid is cheap enough to replace at every oil change.
I love this car. After changing away from the summer sticky tires to all weather radials, the noise in the car is now very tolerable by -10dB from before and the tire wear is superb. Finding replacement parts has been easy for plastic, light bulbs and small parts. Transmissions, glass and remarkably, carpet is hard to impossible to find. Gas mileage is very good at 31 mpg with Premium, and about 23 with middle grade unleaded (89 octane).
I frequent PCA club events and car shows as a spectator, but people ALWAYS say you should be showing that car, because it is extraordinary in its lines, color (Midnight blue metallic-special order color and Natural All leather interior) and sound.

If you can get one, do it. The 996 is an incredible deal right now because the purists are poo-pooing the water cooled machines driving the price down. Btw: air cooled may be interesting from a design point of view but the reason Porsche is still in business and still the king of racing is because the water cooling allowed more horsepower in a smaller engine size which translates to a better power to weight ratio. Interestingly, new 911's have a smaller block, with turbo and automatic transmissions - because they are faster and again lower power to weight ratio. Still water cooled, just like all other cars on the planet. Whats the point in having a great car and keeping it in the garage? I say get one of these, get a boost to your street cred, have FUN driving EVERY day and enjoy that rush acceleration and flat hard cornering gives you. No one drives this car without finishing the ride with a big grin on their face. I think that if a car makes you smile after every drive, many years of ownership, many miles, it is a very good value indeed.


Was this review helpful? Yes | No

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT