1999 BMW 3 Series Consumer Discussions

BMW 3-Series Maintenance and Repair

• Re: Fuel Additives [runningdoc]

  Written by: shipo on Oct 20, 2011 12:20:45 PM

  Unless I'm missing something, BMW actually recommends AGAINST any fuel system additives (Techron or otherwise) for pretty much every car sold in the U.S. and Canada since about 1999 or 2000.

Buying a Used 3-Series

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [shipo]

  Written by: fedlawman on Oct 3, 2011 9:12:05 PM

  That makes sense.

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [fedlawman]

  Written by: shipo on Oct 3, 2011 6:34:37 PM

  I'm thinking plenty of oil can make its way through the system before everything gets all hotted up; I checked maybe ten minutes into the drive, long enough to allow anything heading downstream to make it to the end, but not long enough for everything in the system to burn off.

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [shipo]

  Written by: fedlawman on Oct 3, 2011 5:14:40 PM

  I'm actually surprised you found any. I wouldn't think any oil could make it that far back through the chain. Whatever the headers don't crisp, I would think the heat all the way down the chain (and the cats and muffler) would catch/vaporize anything left.

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [shipo]

  Written by: ivan_99 on Oct 3, 2011 11:10:32 AM

  heh...I would have thought you'd start a fire ;)

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [fedlawman]

  Written by: shipo on Oct 3, 2011 10:58:11 AM

  Funny thing, in all of the years I've been looking at old cars for friends and such, this is the first time I've ever actually seen a tail pipe with any significant oil in it.

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [shipo]

  Written by: fedlawman on Oct 3, 2011 10:32:17 AM

  The old napkin in the tailpipe trick!

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [Mr_Shiftright]

  Written by: shipo on Oct 3, 2011 9:46:32 AM

  To underscore your point... My son has been looking for a used car and had settled on a mid to late 1990s Audi 90/A4 2.8 Quattro 5-Speed; the first car we drove was a late production Audi 90 with only 90,000 miles on it and in very nice shape. A few dogs with fleas later we drove a nearly cherry looking A4 a year or three newer than the 90 and ... Read More

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [airshowshelly]

  Written by: Mr_Shiftright on Oct 3, 2011 9:08:20 AM

  "all new cars are the same, but each used car is different".....so the value is very much pinned to the condition, service records and owner history. Once you know THOSE things, then the question of value is easier to research. That's why getting a pre-sale inspection is important. But at least drive the car first. Even if you aren't a mechanic, you can often tell if some very important components aren't ... Read More

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [airshowshelly]

  Written by: roadburner on Oct 2, 2011 5:18:08 PM

  it appears to be in good shape As always, I strongly recommend a pre-purchase inspection performed by a good BMW tech. Once you know the true condition of the car you can begin to discuss price.

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [fdg07]

  Written by: airshowshelly on Oct 1, 2011 1:56:39 PM

  Am looking at a 2001 330i convertible with just under 50k on it....it appears to be in good shape - just under $16K price tag....is it a keeper?

Entry Level Luxury Performance Sedans

• demand & wants

  Written by: nyccarguy on Sep 22, 2011 11:21:03 AM

  The goal of every single car manufacturer in the entire world is to SELL CARS! If we all "did the smart thing" by paying cash for our Camcord & driving them for 10 - 15 years until the wheels fell off, then luxury cars wouldn't exist. Performance cars wouldn't exist. People have the mindset of: "I'm paying $40,000 ($50,000) for a car and it better have..." Car companies make a lot ... Read More

• Re: In the market... [plekto]

  Written by: shipo on Sep 22, 2011 3:16:50 AM

  "3600lbs for a 3 series is criminal." The 2011 BMW 328i tips the scales at 3,362 pounds which is about 165 pounds heavier than my 1999 328i. Not exactly a lightweight, but not 3,600 pounds either.

BMW 3-Series 2005 and earlier

• Flatness of Torque Curve

  Written by: riez on Feb 21, 2003 6:51:04 PM

  fjk... Is likely beyond me. Physics, chemistry, and mathematics are not my fortes. Thought we were talking about the absolute flatness of an engine's torque curve. I wasn't talking about differences in output. Differing engines have differing torque curves. BMW's 4.4L V-8 has a different torque curve than its 2.5L I-6 or its 5.0L V-12. Even within a given type of engine (e.g., the universe of all I-4s regardless of manufacturer) ... Read More

Buying a Used 3-Series

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [nyccarguy]

  Written by: fedlawman on Apr 22, 2011 2:13:56 PM

  Hey NYC, nice to hear from you. Thanks for asking! I've been lurking...not much to contribute to the forums I guess. These threads all seem to be going in circles lately, just new people jumping in and asking the same old questions. Everything's great though. My M is still going strong. BMW really needs to introduce the FWD 1-Series so we can get some lively discussions going again!

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [fedlawman]

  Written by: nyccarguy on Apr 21, 2011 7:13:39 PM

  hey fedlawman! Where have you been? Everything OK?

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [yelnats25]

  Written by: fedlawman on Apr 21, 2011 7:03:33 PM

  I don't think 0.9% financing makes up for the $30,000+ difference in price between a new 328i and a 10 year-old 330i. And to answer the original question, I'd personally choose the E46 over the E36.

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [fdg07]

  Written by: yelnats25 on Apr 21, 2011 9:52:58 AM

  with the current intrest rates. Why don't you just step un and get a new 3 series. i got 0.9% financing. New 3 is much nice in general and much prettier.

BMW 3-Series Maintenance and Repair

• Re: info on reliability 323i 1999 Coupe [yellowz51]

  Written by: roadburner on Jan 16, 2011 5:12:22 PM

  The powertrain should be good for at least 250,000 miles. It's the ancillaries that could prove troublesome- radiator, HVAC fan, suspension bits, window regulators, etc. If you can't handle minor repairs and maintenance yourself I'd set aside @$100/month for repairs and maintenance. A BMW must be maintained by the book- to fail to do so will prove very costly. Finally, don't have it checked out by just "a mechanic"; find someone ... Read More

• Is it the EWS?

  Written by: phil2400 on Oct 17, 2010 5:24:53 AM

  I have a friend with a 1999 328i that refuses to start. I'm not familiar enough with BMWs to offer her good advise, so I'm hoping someone here can help. I looked the car over, and everything seems in order. I was reading the owner's manual about the security system in the car, and that it will prevent power to the ignition system, fuel pump and starter if it cannot read ... Read More

Entry Level Luxury Performance Sedans

• Re: spy shots of 2012 TL [plekto]

  Written by: shipo on Sep 29, 2010 3:23:50 AM

  The problem is that, in this era of airbags, anti-crush passenger zones, and gizmo packed cars, I seriously doubt any company could build your "real sport sedan" for an affordable price. FWIW #1, the 2011 328i weighs in at 3,362 pounds, only 165 pounds more than my 1999 328i. Not too shabby. FWIW #2, the last time a 3-Series sedan with an I6 engine weighed 3,000 or less was 1991 (although ... Read More

BMW 3-Series 2005 and earlier

• no title

  Written by: fjk57702 on Feb 21, 2003 9:23:56 AM

  Looking at the bmw web site one can find for the 2.5 liter 6: 1995 - 189 hp@5900 -> 168 ft-lbs @5900 1998 - 168 hp@5500 -> 160 ft-lbs @5500 1999 - 170 hp@5500 -> 162 ft-lbs @5000 2001 - 184 hp@6000 -> 161 ft-lbs @6000 We can furthur compute that at 6000 RPMs the torque is less than: 1995 - 165 ft-lbs 1998 - 147 ft-lbs 1999 - 149 ft-lbs ... Read More

• fjk57702

  Written by: shipo on Feb 20, 2003 7:07:05 PM

  I am reasonably certain that the 1999 and 2000 323i engines DID in fact have the Double VANOS system. FWIW, I did a little checking, and the results, 100% agreement, Double VANOS for 1999 for both the 2.5 Liter I6 (which was in the 323i and the Z3 2.3) and the 2.8 Liter I6. Links supplied: http://www.theautochannel.com/content/vehicles/new/reviews/1999/l- hill_bmw_z3.html http://www.epinions.com/auto-review-5557-754300C-38692122-prod1 http://www.bentleypublishers.com/product.htm?code=b301&subjec- t=4 I could go on, but you get the point. ;-) ... Read More

• fjk57702

  Written by: shipo on Feb 20, 2003 1:14:28 PM

  Click on the link to the left under "Helpful Links" titled "Long-Term Road Test: 1999 BMW 328i". Best Regards, Shipo

BMW 3-Series Maintenance and Repair

• Re: Life time maintenance cost? [ginrita]

  Written by: srs_49 on Jun 27, 2010 2:13:46 PM

  BMW's can go well past the 100K mark (I have ~195,000 miles on an '87 325). But, you have to stay on top of the maintenance items. Around the 80K-100K mile mark, a 3-series should have the timing belt changed and while the engine is apart, the water pump replaced. Control arm bushings also may need to be replaced at that mileage mark. As to how much you can expect to ... Read More

• Re: Compressor [mooveoover]

  Written by: Firebird_EOU on Jun 3, 2010 8:52:20 PM

  http://consumerguideauto.howstuffworks.com/1999-to-2005-bmw-3-series-2.htm $770 is the estimated cost for compressor based on $50 per hour.

Entry Level Luxury Performance Sedans

• Re: Repair Costs of Japanese vs German? [bastuk]

  Written by: roadburner on Jan 31, 2010 11:11:52 AM

  A couple of questions - + Are the repair costs significantly higher with a German car vs Japanese? I have no baseline on my Accord since I have not had to do any repairs. + Is the reliability that much worse for the German cars than an Acura/Honda? Over the past 27 years I have owned nine BMWs. In my experience a 3 Series won't be all that expensive to run, ... Read More

BMW History and Engine Technology

• Re: Going in Reverse [bmwannabe1]

  Written by: phylp on Dec 10, 2009 1:52:54 PM

  You have very good taste. FYI - Car and Driver magazine ran a feature recently re: the best used cars under $20,000. The original 1999 M coupe was dubbed "a prime example of nerd chic: incredibly cool to those in the know." This car is supposedly fun to drive, with plenty of storage space, unlike most two-seaters. I have only seen a couple of these M coupes. Rare is always good. ... Read More

• Re: Going in Reverse [bmwannabe1]

  Written by: phylp on Dec 9, 2009 11:52:23 AM

  People buy cars for many reasons . . . My 2008 BMW 535i is my first BMW. A new convert, the car is my "ultimate driving machine." That takes the car's utlility off the charts because the drive was my top priority. I once purchased a 1999 Volvo S80, for the safety features, knowing that the transmission was a Chevy that Volvo used because it was the only one that would ... Read More

• Re: Going in Reverse [bmwannabe1]

  Written by: shipo on Dec 4, 2009 12:16:37 PM

  Specific to the comments that I was responding to last year, BMW had a problem with the 1999 and 2000 vintage 323i (GM produced) automatic transmissions not going into reverse after roughly 50,000 miles. Honda on the other hand has had an ongoing problem with the automatic transmissions used with their V6 engines, especially those on the Odyssey and larger Acura models. There are (or were) four Honda vehicles in our ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Maintenance and Repair

• German Filter

  Written by: joann3 on Jun 11, 2009 9:59:58 AM

  I rencently bought a 1999 BMW 328 I and I have to do my first oil change. I called 2 people to inquire on price and 1 told me that the price includes a German Filter, the other one didn't mention anything about a German Filter. Is it necessary to use a German Filter? If so, why?

2009 BMW 3-Series

• Re: When is the next update for the BMW 3 series sedan 328i? [MikeCRG]

  Written by: pylt1 on Mar 22, 2009 7:59:22 AM

  It's about every 7 years between major model changes. In the interim there's a mid-cyle appearance update on the 4th Model Year--that's almost always just minor light and trim changes. For the E46, this update occurred in the 2002 MY. For the E90 it was this year, the 2009 MY. Here's the recent "major change" schedule for the sedan: From E36 to E46: 1999 MY From E46 to E90: 2006 MY ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Maintenance and Repair

• Re: Where to get quotes for extended warranty and maintenance plan [jscholder]

  Written by: shipo on Feb 27, 2009 9:24:33 AM

  "O.K., normally you would be correct...however I recently found an oil change special from advance auto with 5 quarts of synthetic oil at 24.99 and an oil filter included, and they let me change out a filter that would fit the BMW. It was a great deal." I'm thinking you missed the point (a couple of points actually): 1) As far a I know, every BMW sold in the United States ... Read More

Buying a Used 3-Series

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [platinummotors]

  Written by: backy on Feb 22, 2009 1:15:26 PM

  I think posting URLs to dealerships is against the membership rules?? Anyway, with a handle like that, you should WORK for this outfit. Or maybe... you already do!!! ;)

BMW 3-Series Maintenance and Repair

• Re: Buying Tips for BMW 3 Series (1998) [realpunksgt]

  Written by: srs_49 on Feb 13, 2009 3:07:53 AM

  I would not buy a 10-11 year old BMW if 1) I didn't know how to turn a wrench and so 2) was dependent on a BMW dealer or private mechanic for all the repairs and maintenance. I bought my 87 '325 when it was 12 years old (back in 1999), so a little older than what you're looking for. In the past 9 years, I've spent around $4500 on maintenance ... Read More

Buying a Used 3-Series

• Re: '07 BMW328i vs 06 Acura TL [backy]

  Written by: srs_49 on Jan 14, 2009 12:38:34 PM

  No, I don't (remember the Acura tranny problems). Not owning one myself, I probably didn't pay any attention to it. On my '87 BMW that I bought used back in 1999, I've spent $~5,400 in repairs and maintenance (tires included). That's $45/month, with me doing a lot of the work myself. I look at insurance (which is what an extended warranty is) to protect me against a catastrophic financial loss - ... Read More

BMW 3-Series 2005 and earlier

• Hmmm, winter tires, again...

  Written by: shipo on Feb 13, 2003 6:04:50 AM

  Now that I have experience driving on snow with two BMWs and three types of tires, I will offer my "Subjective" analysis on how well they work on snow, on a scale of 1 to 10. 2002 530i - Michelin Pilot Primacy - 2 (Summer Tires) 1999 328i - Michelin MXV4 Energy Plus - 5 (All-Season Tires) 2002 530i - Michelin Arctic-Alpin - 10 (Winter Tires) So, will all season tires ... Read More

Buying a Used 3-Series

• Re: '07 BMW328i vs 06 Acura TL [lemmer]

  Written by: srs_49 on Jan 16, 2009 7:20:03 AM

  I could buy a clutch for $250, but then I would just sit there and look at it much like a caveman would look at a microwave. The BMW places around here won't install parts that you bring it, so what's next? $1400 does seem a little high, but not idiot high. Agreed. When I bought my '87 back in 1999, the clutch was the one big ticket item I was ... Read More

• Re: used 325xi deal? [jdickson]

  Written by: roadburner on Nov 30, 2008 8:38:00 PM

  assuming it checks out would it be a good deal or something to stay away from due to the mileage? First off, if you haven't purchased the car yet, I would strongly advise you to have it inspected by a qualified BMW tech. Not much goes wrong on the newer 3 Series, but you still want to buy a good one. The mileage wouldn't worry me one bit- assuming that the ... Read More

2009 BMW 3-Series

• Re: Rats! [fedlawman]

  Written by: circlew on Nov 28, 2008 1:16:41 PM

  The engine change aside, shorter term concerns exist. They might need to do another movie quick... CEO says BMW in “biggest crisis in its history;” rivals have similar concerns BMW, which has seen it sales double since 1999, is now in the “biggest crisis in its history,” CEO Norbert Reithofer told Germany’s Spiegel. Like all automakers, BMW’s sales have been hit hard by the financial crisis, but the company’s reliance on ... Read More

BMW 3-Series 2005 and earlier

• abcnyc

  Written by: shipo on Feb 6, 2003 7:20:54 AM

  I am not sure about 2000 and later cars, however, the "Free Maintenance" program for my former 1999 328i did NOT include brakes. I have heard that BMW enhanced the program in either 2000 or 2001, however, I am unsure about whether the brakes are covered under the newer program. Best Regards, Shipo

• Brave1heart, Kominsky, SnyderW & Everybody else...

  Written by: shipo on Feb 5, 2003 1:21:20 AM

  Brave & Kominsky, Hmmm, Boston this Spring… Mind if I crash the party in my Dodge Caravan? ;-) SnyderW, As I have a fair amount of experience with a 1999 328i, I can offer you some advice regarding your post. First, the “Rocker Arms” are probably “Control Arms”, which, based upon my understanding, BMW has decided to replace (free of charge) for all 1999 E46 models. Mine were replaced during my ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Maintenance and Repair

• Advice for buying used 99 - 01 BMW 3 series

  Written by: kapitanraider on Oct 10, 2008 5:42:43 PM

  Im looking to buy a used BMW(first car) but i have concerns about the reliability, life and cost of maintanence and repairs. Im looking at the following(all have clean autocheck): 2000 BMW 328i - 95k miles 2001 BMW 325i - 134k miles 1999 BMW 328i - 140k miles looking at between 7k to 9.5k for these.im a college student in Orlando, Fl. and i will atleast on a vehicle another 3 ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Run Flat Tires

• Re: Tire Rotation [jaxs1]

  Written by: shipo on Sep 9, 2008 6:38:14 AM

  I didn't rotate the tires on my first BMW (a 1999 328i), and while I had no noise or other unusual wear patterns on my tires, I will say that the rears did wear a bit faster than the fronts. When I traded it in on my 530i SP, the tires on the 328i had almost bang on 49,000 miles on them (yes, this was a non-SP car with all-season tires), ... Read More

BMW 3-Series 2005 and earlier

• Winter Tires, again... (Reposted from the 5-Series board)

  Written by: shipo on Feb 3, 2003 1:01:51 PM

  Hey Gang! This (long) post is sort of a catch-up post, prompted in no small part by our 5-Series friend and compatriot DaBimmer, who just sent me an E-Mail suggesting (very tactfully I might add) that I get off my butt and rejoin the discussions here in the TownHall. Thanks Tony for the kick in the hind quarters. ;-) For starters, I am NOT currently driving a BMW, I have instead ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Maintenance and Repair

• Re: bmw 325i [gurmehar]

  Written by: gurmehar on May 13, 2008 7:18:04 AM

  1999....i asked another person and he revealed it was because there was no water in the car, after checking it appeared so.

BMW 3-Series Tires and Wheels

• Re: Summer Tire Size for 330 coupe [ronaries10]

  Written by: fedlawman on Apr 1, 2008 9:42:39 PM

  Tire Rack is a great place to start. If you want to find 16" wheels for the E46, just plug in a 1999 323i - 16's were standard for it. Tire Rack will also tell you the bolt pattern and offset needed for your car. As long as the bolt pattern (5-120) and offset (42mm) match, then the wheels will work. Wheels - 16" Kosei K1Racing (affordable and lightweight) http://www.tirerack.com/wheels/WheelCloseUpServlet?target=runWheelSearch&initial- - ... Read More

BMW European Delivery

• Re: 535i ED Quote - Dallas [tx_bmw]

  Written by: shipo on Mar 25, 2008 9:58:30 AM

  I've been following the BMW related discussions here on Edmunds since I started researching my 1999 328i back in the summer of 1998. Through that entire time one thing has remained true, the Dallas area dealers will not negotiate an ED deal below MSRP (and very little off of MSRP for domestically sourced cars). The common consensus is to either allow them to screw you, or patronize the BMW dealers in ... Read More

Buying a Used 3-Series

• Re: BMW 2004 328 4DR Seden Maintainese Cost [windforceus]

  Written by: roadburner on Dec 10, 2007 9:24:09 AM

  I want to know BMW 2004 328 4DR Sedan, 60000 miles Maintainese Cost If i bring the car to BMW dealer or Private body shop. First off, if you haven't purchased the car yet, I would strongly advise you to have it inspected by a qualified BMW tech. Not much goes wrong on the newer 3 Series, but you still want to buy a good one. Now for your questions regarding ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Real World MPG

• Re: The gas gauge drops to 0 suddenly, but I really have gas! [absolutic]

  Written by: roadburner on Dec 4, 2007 11:27:02 AM

  What could be the problem? The E36(1992-1999) 3 Series cars had a similar issue. In that case the problem was caused by corrosion deposits on the fuel sending unit contacts within the gas tank. BMW cured the problem by introducing a replacement unit fitted with gold contacts that do not corrode. I solved the problem on my 1995 and 1998 3ers by using only Top Tier gasolines- which contain detergent properties ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Tires and Wheels

• Re: 325i tires [thomatl]

  Written by: fedlawman on Aug 30, 2007 8:42:09 PM

  You could always buy a compact spare and keep it in the trunk. The tire you're looking for is going to be either a "premium passenger tire" (ultimate comfort) or a "all-season high performance tire" (good mix of comfort and sport). On the comfort side, I can personally recommend the Goodyear Assurance ComforTred as a very smooth riding and quiet tire. I put a set on my 2004 Volvo V70 and ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Transmission Questions

• Re: Transmission type in 1999 328ic [fixitrod]

  Written by: roadburner on Nov 29, 2007 10:42:53 AM

  hIt does not occur when braking but it is just riding at low speed as we are leaving the neighborhood. Wheel bearing, perhaps. The driveshaft fas a rubber coupling at the transmission as well as a center bearing.They should still be good on your car, but it is something else to check. I am familiar with visual and checking for play at the bushing; are there other indicators? Nope, that's pretty ... Read More

• Re: Transmission type in 1999 328ic [roadburner]

  Written by: fixitrod on Nov 29, 2007 9:33:06 AM

  Thanks for the speedy reply. Good question about the vibration. It does not occur when braking but it is just riding at low speed as we are leaving the neighborhood. Its not my daily driver so I'll check further on this. I'll inspect the bushings as well. I am familiar with visual and checking for play at the bushing; are there other indicators? I may have misspelled this name for the ... Read More

• Re: Transmission type in 1999 328ic [fixitrod]

  Written by: roadburner on Nov 29, 2007 8:49:02 AM

  1. Don't know if I got a bad set of front rotors or is something amiss in the front end. Any thoughts appreciated. What's the problem? A vibration when braking? If so, it could be lower control arm bushings. 2. Is this transmission a GM Getrag or GM GM because I want to service it. Well, there's no such thing as a GM Getrag; Modern BMW slushboxes are either built by ... Read More

BMW 318ti

• Re: Just bought [flygirlnz]

  Written by: roadburner on Nov 28, 2007 5:38:46 PM

  I have just purchased a yr 2000 BMW 318ti. The last model year for the US 318ti was 1999. Where are you located?

BMW 3-Series Maintenance and Repair

• Re: Keeping a BMW 3 past 100k, or for over 10 years [sunilb]

  Written by: roadburner on Nov 24, 2007 9:14:38 PM

  roadburner-- great notes! Thanks! just curious... where do you account for changes to the cooling system, suspension, etc.? Do you consider these "scheduled" or "non-scheduled"? On a E36 or E46 # Series I would definitely replace the water pump and radiator prior to their normal failure point. For some reason, the cooling systems of 1994-1999 four cylinders are remarkably robust. As I mentioned above, I've only replaced the thermostat. In my ... Read More

BMW 3-Series - AWD or RWD?

• Re: Disappointing mileage in 335xi [habitat1]

  Written by: shipo on Oct 6, 2007 6:06:52 AM

  "I think many/most 6-speed manual transmissions are geared for peak efficiency in the 70-75 mph range, not 55." Both of my 5-Speed manual equipped BMWs had their sweet spot for mileage somewhere north of 70 as well. My 2002 530i would do about 31 mpg at 75 while my 1999 328i would get more like 34-35 mpg at those same speeds. ;-) Best Regards, Shipo

Entry Level Luxury Performance Sedans

• Buyer Beware Part 2

  Written by: louiswei on Sep 26, 2007 12:21:10 PM

  1999-2005 BMW 3-Series Reliability Trouble Spots Consumer Guide's® Auto Editors have scoured repair bulletins and questioned mechanics to search for commonly occurring problems for a particular vehicle. In some cases we also give possible manufacturer-suggested solutions. In many instances these trouble spots are Technical Service Bulletins posted by the manufacturer, however, we have our own expert looking at additional vehicle problems. Engine knock: The 3.2-L (S54) engine reportedly suffers connecting-rod-bearing failures ... Read More

BMW 3-Series 2005 and earlier

• Re: Hello and... [L8_Apex]

  Written by: yme2 on Sep 1, 2007 10:08:06 AM

  A WARNING FOR ANYONE OWNING OR THINKING ABOUT BUYING A 1999 -2001 BMW 323I (E46). GO TO CONSUMERAFFARIS.COM AND TYPE IN BMW TRANSMISSION PROBLEMS.THERE ARE OVER 350 AND GROWING EACH DAY OF THE ONGOING PROBLEM BMW IS HAVING WITH THERE LIFETIME TRANSMISSION WHICH THEY PURCHASED FROM GM THESE SO CALLED LIFETIME TRANSMISSIONS IN WHICH GM HAS ALREADY RECALLED ARE MADE IN MEXICO AND LIKE MINE WITH NO WARNING ALL OF A ... Read More

BMW 3-Series 2006

• I'm Not a Mecahnic so...

  Written by: circlew on Aug 16, 2007 7:33:30 AM

  I'll pay for the insurance if I buy a BMW. Take a look. http://consumerguideauto.howstuffworks.com/1999-to-2005-bmw-3-series-2.htm Regards, OW

Entry Level Luxury Performance Sedans

• Re: BMW 3xi vs. Lexus IS 250 & Audi A4 - my two cents [das107]

  Written by: snakesndafield on Jul 26, 2007 10:25:38 AM

  I've driven them all recently; 1st the BMW - everyone claims it is unequaled in handling. Who am I to argue. The steering is very weighty, possibly too much at low speeds for some. It does manage to feel very tight and extremely smooth all at once. Definitely the driver's car but if you're on city streets the whole time you might never notice. Lousy cupholders & average interior layout, but ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Prices Paid and Buying Experience

• Re: BMW's in winter [letstalk]

  Written by: stevecebu on Jul 11, 2007 3:29:25 PM

  I'm a few days away from buying a 2004 BMW325ci. I know it's going to be a great car, but I do live in Massachusetts. It is said to have traction control and dual stability, all nice words, but what should I do about driving in winter? Or maybe it's ok. Perhaps given what the car is, it'll just be about getting good tires. Any advice for those NE winters which ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Maintenance and Repair

• Re: BMW 3 transmission problems [socalsabo]

  Written by: ftroha on Jul 2, 2007 1:10:30 PM

  All I know is what someone who calls himself "kevdaug" -- Message 3352 -- wrote on this forum. I've cut and pasted it below. Suggest you contact him by going to message 3352 and replying to his message. Message 3352 posted by kevdaug: If your 3 series from 1999 or 2000 suddenly loses reverse, contact consumer affairs (just Google BMW transmission problem), but don't get it fixed by BMW. Your car ... Read More

• Re: BMW problems [joyrider147]

  Written by: shipo on Jun 30, 2007 9:05:17 AM

  None of the Manual Transmission equipped cars have these problems. Period, full stop, the end. Regarding the Automatic equipped cars, while I have heard about a few of the 1999-2000 vintage 328i models with the problem, fully 95% of what I've read indicates that it's the 323i that is fully affected. Said another way, if you have a 1999-2000 vintage 323i with the original Automatic transmission, it's not a matter of ... Read More

• BMW 3 transmission problems

  Written by: kevdaug on Jun 27, 2007 9:59:23 PM

  If your 3 series from 1999 or 2000 suddenly loses reverse, contact consumer affairs (just Google BMW transmission problem), but don't get it fixed by BMW. Your car and the tranmission may be very valuable as evidence in the class action suit being drawn up just now by the consumer affair attorneys. They certainly would like to disect your transmission (built by General Motors) to show how the defective part was ... Read More

• Re: Oil change for 325 [shipo]

  Written by: roadburner on May 17, 2007 3:33:03 PM

  I agree, the only time I would use a higher viscosity oil in a post-1999 BMW would be in the case of Motorsport engines which call for Castrol 10W-60

• Re: Oil change for 325 [abfisch]

  Written by: shipo on May 17, 2007 1:13:38 PM

  I'm afraid that I don't understand where you're going with your comments, so I'll just say this; 0W-40 should easily out perform 15W-40 in all driving environments and in all weather conditions. Said another way, for all BMWs built since at least the 1999 model year, the Bently Service Manual has it wrong, WAY wrong. Best Regards, Shipo

BMW 3-series vs Lexus IS

• Re: IF ONLY THE IS350 COULD [circlew]

  Written by: jimbres on May 4, 2007 12:50:16 PM

  My crystal ball is broken, so it's hard for me to say today what will move me 2 years from now. Given that the 3-series has been the top dog in the handling department for what seems like forever, it's reasonable to assume that not much will happen during the next 2 years to change that. But the E90's styling does not move me at all. It's certainly not a bad ... Read More

BMW 335i 2007+

• Re: 335i\G37 Re: Slightly off-topic but advice wanted anyway [dougsilver]

  Written by: habitat1 on Apr 28, 2007 12:39:58 PM

  Doug, You clearly have some serious misunderstandings about the European Delivery program. I won't give you a full tutorial, but you need to do some more research. What I will give you is a real world example of a friend of mine who is getting a 335i convertible to repalce his 1999 328i convertible. The 335ic he has ordered has an MSRP of $56,000+. The best price his dealer would give ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Prices Paid and Buying Experience

• Re: Question on a 2000 328ci [kyfdx]

  Written by: stevehecht on Apr 9, 2007 8:01:47 AM

  FYI, the car was sold Easter weekend for the asking price. That's OK, I've got my eye on a 1999 328 coupe for $12,900 with 83K miles in North Carolina on the BMWCCA website (I just joined). But I'll be renting a new 325i coupe for the day on Wednesday to see if I can satisfy my BMW craving for $100 one day per month instead of buying the thing.

• 328i sedan on order

  Written by: sactokenn on Apr 1, 2007 1:09:05 AM

  I just ordered a 328i sedan, and wanted to share my experience. First off, thanks to all of you participating on this forum. I can’t imagine I would have done as well as (I think) I did without all the knowledge I’ve gotten from reading this and other forums, like Bimmerfest and e90post. This will be my fourth BMW, starting with a 1999 323i, then a 2003 325iT, and currently a ... Read More

Entry Level Luxury Performance Sedans

• Re: Question for Habitat and Blueguy [billyperks1]

  Written by: habitat1 on Mar 19, 2007 3:26:36 PM

  Billy, Good to hear from you. Unfortunately, I can't offer much of an opinion since I have not driven the new GS. Friend of mine is seriously considering one (GS450h, I think), but he and his wife are far more interested in luxury than a sporty drive. He currently has a 1999 +/- GS300 that, although pretty slow and soft by current standards, has been absolutely bulletproof and still looks nice. ... Read More

• Re: All those names... [hauss]

  Written by: shipo on Mar 11, 2007 7:31:00 PM

  hauss, blueguydotcom is referring to the nomenclature for the specific BMW models. A quick cheat sheet (off the top of my head so may be off by a year here and there) is as follows: 3-Series: E30 -- 1983-1991 E36 -- 1991-1998 E46 -- 1999-2005 E90 -- 2006- (Coupe version called E92) 5-Series: E28 -- 1982-1988 E34 -- 1988-1996 E39 -- 1997-2003 E60 -- 2004- Options: ZPP -- Premium Package ZSP ... Read More

BMW 335i 2007+

• Re: Is Sports Package Really Necessary? [sanfrannewbie]

  Written by: shipo on Mar 11, 2007 8:13:09 AM

  Short answer, if you liked the way the car felt without the SP, then you don't need it. That said, I did the same thing for my first BMW. I drove a 1999 328i sans-SP, liked it, and ordered it. For the first 34 months of my 39 month lease, I loved the car and its handling. Then I swapped my car with another member here at Edmunds for a day ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Transmission Questions

• Transmission Failure...OMG is it true?

  Written by: trist4good7 on Feb 22, 2007 8:24:29 PM

  In october I bought a 1999 323i with um 138,000 miles on it. It was only 8,000 dollars and having a fat down payment i couldnt resist. for the past 4 months it has served me so well with no trouble or anything. Last week I drop my friend off, go to back out of her level driveway and the car will not go into reverse. acts as if its in ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Oil Questions

• Re: Oil Change? [circlew]

  Written by: shipo on Jan 30, 2007 4:56:36 AM

  "Even Shipo changes way more frequently than BMW recommends." Well, I think that needs to be qualified. My first BMW (a 1999 328i) was one of the first 15,000 mile OCI BMWs to hit our shores. For the forty some thousand miles that I had that car I relied on the dealer to do the ~15,000 mile oil changes as requested by the car itself. When I turned the car in ... Read More

'06 330 vs '07 328 or 335

• Re: '06 330 vs '07 328 or 335 [jobie]

  Written by: shipo on Feb 12, 2007 6:43:08 AM

  "I also had a '99 (323i 5sp) and an '02 530i 5sp - both great cars..." Great choices, I couldn't agree more. ;-) "The problem with testing a SP-equipped BMW, especially the 5, is that dealers rarely have any 6-sp versions - it seems you have to order one to drive one (which I did with my '02). I'm wondering how fun the paddles would be on the sp trannies." I ... Read More

• Re: '06 330 vs '07 328 or 335 [habitat1]

  Written by: shipo on Feb 12, 2007 5:21:44 AM

  "If you really are a "driving enthusiast", the manual transmission is the only way to go with the 3 or even the 5. If you don't find the automatic transmission offensive to your driving preferences, that you really shouldn't find the non-sport package suspension and standard wheels and tires offensive either. It's still better than 90% of the other vehicles out there in terms of handling and it will save you ... Read More

BMW 3-series vs Lexus IS

• Re: A sad BMW story [bmw55]

  Written by: shipo on Feb 6, 2007 8:33:30 AM

  I find myself wondering how difficult it is to retrofit early E46 323i models with a manual transmission. Nah, probably not worth it. I also find myself wondering who is really to blame for these failures (yeah, yeah, yeah. I know BMW put the transmission in their car so the buck should ultimately stop with them). Why would I wonder such a thing? If I recall correctly, either ZF or a ... Read More

BMW 3-Series Maintenance and Repair

• A couple of points...

  Written by: shipo on Jan 17, 2007 12:02:36 PM

  Given the sheer number of "Can't go into reverse" complaints from 323i owners, it seems rather obvious that there is indeed a problem and BMW should step up to the plate and offer some form of relief. FWIW, I don't believe that BMW built the automatic transmissions affected (designed by ZF and built by GM if memory serves), however, they put it in their car and they should be the folks ... Read More

• Re: BMW problems [ftroha]

  Written by: txbmwfan on Jan 14, 2007 8:04:46 PM

  I am sorry to hear about these failed transmissions. I would be similarly outraged. Hard to believe that BMW would abide by an "Unsatisfactory" rating from the BBB. To legally prove your cases, you would have to show transmission problems are prevalent, and also well-known to BMW, for certain model years, and that BMW has not otherwise adequately addressed. I reviewed the Consumer Reports website for the reliability history of the ... Read More

2007 3-Series

• Re: All restaurants are Taco Bell. . . [fedlawman]

  Written by: cdnpinhead on Dec 21, 2006 2:00:51 PM

  Nicely put. My present vehicle is one that was put forward (in 1999) as a legitimate competitor to the BMW. The vehicle was, but the company wasn't. It's no longer produced (Lincoln LS), & Lincoln is searching . . . for something, anything. Next time I'm going for the real thing. Your post described part of why. Well done.

BMW 3-Series Run Flat Tires

• Rotation

  Written by: paflyer on Dec 9, 2006 8:15:07 AM

  OK lets make sure I understand what you guys are saying. You are getting cupping and lots of noise when you don't rotate and you want to keep doing this so you can complain some more. And also that you want to ingnore the mmanufacturers who have a lot of good engineers who know more than you do about tires and tire wear who say to rotate. I am no expert ... Read More

• Re: bmw run flat tires [blueguydotcom]

  Written by: shipo on Dec 5, 2006 9:56:48 AM

  "You bought a sport sedan and expected to get 50-60k miles out the tires? 30k miles is a crazy amount for a BMW." Oddly enough, before brave1heart and I swapped cars (for a couple of days) and I had a chance to truly experience and appreciate the capabilities of BMWs Sport Package, I ordered a 1999 328i non-SP. When I turned that car in at lease end with 45,000 miles on ... Read More

Article Comments - 2007 BMW 335i Coupe Full Test

• Re: BMW slipped Edmunds a ringer! [circlew]

  Written by: threxx on Nov 28, 2006 7:29:04 PM

  Right, but the manufacturer can rate cars any way they want to really unless they want to be SAE v2 certified or something. Even then - BMW rated the 335i at 300 flywheel horsepower which is not a lie. We know by now that the 335i is at LEAST 300 flywheel horsepower because almost every independent dyno test has showed RWD power figures would be equal to 300+hp even if the ... Read More

Entry Level Luxury Performance Sedans

• Slow?

  Written by: plekto on Nov 28, 2006 4:39:08 PM

  1987 Porsche 928 S4 5.5 1992 Porsche 968 5.9 2001 Porsche Boxster S 5.6 1994 Toyota Supra Turbo 5.3 2004 Mazda RX-8 5.8 1982 Lamborghini Countach S 5.7 2000 Jaguar XKR 5.6 2006 Honda S2000 5.5 1986 Ferrari Testarossa 5.3 1970 Ferrari 330 GTS 6.9 1990 Chevrolet Corvette 5.7 1990 Chevrolet Camaro IROC-Z 5.8 1987 Buick Regal GNX 4.7(just to prove old doesn't mean slow) 1995 BMW M3 6.2 1998 BMW ... Read More

• BMW 335I

  Written by: billyperks1 on Nov 7, 2006 8:42:41 AM

  Finally saw the coupe this morning on the I95, it looks like my 1999 Mazda Millenia from behind, which is a good thing.I have not seen the sedan as of yet but I have to say I like the Coupe.But then again, neither are on my short list for my next purchase.

BMW 318ti

• Re: Advice... [jurrr]

  Written by: 2xright on Oct 4, 2006 7:16:10 PM

  HI, I recently found a 1999 318ti Sport(10/98 manuf.date)for about 11k on cars.com - it was, in MY opinion, a decent deal, it only had 30k miles. My last BMW (several yrs and vehicles ago) was a 2001 325ci (new, Made to order) Had to sell :-( but then HAD to get another BMW after a string of unsatisfying vehicles. I have found this car quite a surprise (I did have ... Read More

BMW 335i 2007+

• Re: Ray, Movin' Fast [carjim]

  Written by: rayainsw on Oct 2, 2006 4:21:04 AM

  carjim – HA! I showed up on the Lincoln LS board in late 1999! I see the C6, as of MY 2006 ( with the addition of the A6 trans. ) as a world class GT car and a world class bargain. Not cheap, mind you. The MSRP of the one I ordered is over $10,000 more than my 2003 LS. And the actual transaction price is higher by even more ... Read More

BMW Center Console Switch

• BMW Center Console Switch

  Written by: bfenelon on Sep 15, 2006 6:30:13 PM

  Thanks so much for the links to the 3 Series manual by Robert Bentley. I had seen the 1998 verstion, but not the 1999 - 2005. I have just ordered it from Amazon.com. Just today I was talking to a BMW enthusiast and he told me how to change the center console switch: It is very simple really, you just carefully pry it out of its socket with a fine pointed ... Read More

• Re: BMW Center Console Switch [bfenelon]

  Written by: kominsky on Sep 15, 2006 7:17:39 AM

  http://www.amazon.com/BMW-E46-Service-Manual-1999-2005/dp/0837612772/sr=8-1/qid=- 1158329682/ref=pd_bbs_1/002-6403456-3536000?ie=UTF8&s=books http://www.turnermotorsport.com/html/detail.asp?PRODUCT_ID=B301/B305

Acura TSX vs. BMW 328i

• Re: Honda/Acura Value [bora1]

  Written by: potemkin on Aug 21, 2006 12:24:18 PM

  What's a ti? Sorry, I wasn't real clear their... In this instance, a "ti" is a 1995 BMW 318ti. A hatchback that was introduced (to the US) in 1995 and discontinued in 1999.

BMW 3-Series 2006

• Re: 06 325xi vs 05 325xi low gear torque [mathew1]

  Written by: shipo on Aug 19, 2006 8:47:51 AM

  Are you comparing an E46 325xi 5-Speed Manual with an E90 325xi 6-Speed Automatic? If so you've got your answer. If not and both cars are Automatics, then my guess is that the E46 feels different due to either shorter gearing and/or a different operation of the automatic. Maybe I'm getting the 325xi confused with another car with an automatic, however, is it not true that the Automatic in the E90 ... Read More

Buying a Used 3-Series

• 330ci vs e36 m3 Review

  Written by: quattroporte12 on Aug 18, 2006 9:54:55 PM

  Was just reading a review of a 2001 m3 and saw this quote comparing the old one (e36)and 330ci. Thought i should post it...from edmunds.com reviews. "When the last BMW M3 was sold in North America (from 1995 to 1999), it was an emasculated version of the car available across the Atlantic. While Europeans were ripping about in 321-horsepower M3s, we made do with choked 240-horse variants. Sure, they were great-handling ... Read More

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [da

  Written by: dsurti on Aug 16, 2006 8:11:20 AM

  I had a 325ci that i traded for a s2000.. i really wanted the M Roaster/Coupe but i coudln't afford to make the jump... i picked up a used s2k for a few grand less than what i sold my 325ci for the s2k, m roaddsters/coupes, m3.. real sport/performance cars imo

• Re: ///M vs. 330ci [fdg07]

  Written by: dave330i on Aug 15, 2006 9:24:29 PM

  Um is the "CDV" a bad thing? is it really a pain? Yes. It's in all modern BMW with manual transmission. It makes it easier for novice to shift, but makes "spirited" shifting more difficult. It's a pretty easy thing to eliminate though. Does anyone here know if maintaining and repairing a E36 M3(1999) is more expensive than a 330Ci They are going to be about the same. If things break, ... Read More

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [fdg07]

  Written by: dave330i on Aug 14, 2006 7:20:18 PM

  I used to own a 2001 330i, 5 sp, with sport & premium package (basically 330ci with 2 extra doors). At the end of 2004, I traded it for 1999 E36/8 M Coupe (basically, M36 M3 in a modified Z3 Coupe body). If you're looking for performace, go with M3. If you're looking for more luxury, go with 330ci.

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [quattroporte12]

  Written by: fdg07 on Aug 11, 2006 11:59:25 AM

  Hey guys thanks alot for your comments and support!It really does help me :) Well here are my priorities: performance!!! But my problem is that will i have to sacrifice performance for reliability and maintanance? I mean the m3 is a performance car and Im wondering which car will be cheaper for repairs? Lets say i get both cars with 50,000 miles, which will be more expensive to repair? is it ... Read More

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [div2]

  Written by: quattroporte12 on Aug 10, 2006 8:20:08 PM

  A newer generation or a car = newer technology and engineering. Period. Why would BMW redesign a car and put the same old technology and engineering into it??? The m3 MAY be harder to repair, because it is MORE likley to be driven hard then the 330ci, and ordering parts involves WAITING, which can be an inconvenience. 330ci is a newer, all around better car. ;) ;) ;)

• Re: What is a better buy: 1999 BMW M3 or 2001 330ci (same mileage each) [quattroporte12]

  Written by: div2 on Aug 10, 2006 7:10:14 PM

  the parts in the new one were much better than the old generation's parts, which means the parts in the 330 are probably as good or better than the ones in the old generation m3 because of the new technology Interesting. Which E46 parts are better? And in what way? What "new technology" are you referring to? Double VANOS? i would say that the m3 is going to be more expensive ... Read More