Used Subaru Forester for Sale in Bay Shore, NY
Buy a versatile Subaru Forester in the city where LL Cool J was born
Skip to Filters
1,397 listings
- $25,795great price$3,736 below market
- 27,907 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 33 Hwy MPG
- Pristine Mitsubishi (15 mi away)
Close
Located in Commack, NY / 15 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
ABS brakes, Brake assist. Priced below KBB Fair Purchase Price! Clean CARFAX. CARFAX One-Owner. 26/33 City/Highway MPG2022 Subaru Forester Touring Gra...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (26 City/33 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SKARC0NH475437
Stock: 54147
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 03-11-2025 - New Listing$28,475great price$2,565 below market
- 16,301 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use
- 5 Seats, 25 City / 28 Hwy MPG
- Empire Mazda of Huntington (17 mi away)
Close
Located in Huntington Station, NY / 17 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
Clean CARFAX. Recent Arrival! 2023 Subaru Forester WildernessFinance for price is reflective after $1995 down. Subject to primary lenders approval. Al...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
26 Combined MPG (25 City/28 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SKAMC5PH491658
Stock: 1363UT
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 07-26-2025 - Price Drop$16,868good price$2,111 below market
- 89,488 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 32 Hwy MPG
- Empire Chrysler Dodge Jeep Ram of West Islip (8 mi away)
Close
Located in West Islip, NY / 8 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAWC1JH478302
Stock: U15468T
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 05-26-2025 - $11,195good price$2,458 below market
- 78,980 miles
- 1 accident, 1 owner, personal use
- 5 Seats, 24 City / 32 Hwy MPG
- Autoland USA (18 mi away)
Close
Located in Selden, NY / 18 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
This vehicle is a 2016 Subaru Forester 2.5I Crossover all wheel drive with low mileage of 78,980 miles. It has a sequential port fuel injection 2.5 li...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: No
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
27 Combined MPG (24 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJABC8GH560249
Stock: 9256F
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-29-2025 - $9,995fair price$218 below market
- 101,332 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use only
- 5 Seats, 21 City / 27 Hwy MPG
- Autoland USA (18 mi away)
Close
Located in Selden, NY / 18 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
This vehicle is a 2013 Subaru Forester 2.5X LIMITED with all wheel drive and a 2.5 liter 4 cylinder engine. It has a sequential port fuel injection sy...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
23 Combined MPG (21 City/27 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SHAEC5DH405502
Stock: 9364F
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 06-07-2025 - Price Drop$30,107good price$1,519 below market
- 15,094 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, rental vehicle
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 33 Hwy MPG
- Hertz Car Sales Smithtown (15 mi away)
Close
Located in Smithtown, NY / 15 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
*All prices plus government fees and taxes, any finance charges, any electronic filing charge, and any emission testing charge. The price includes a d...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: No
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (26 City/33 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SKAGC2RH514490
Stock: 55970
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 05-13-2025 - New Listing$27,293good price$1,437 below market
- 22,335 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 33 Hwy MPG
- Empire Lincoln of Huntington (18 mi away)
Close
Located in Huntington, NY / 18 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
Crystal White 2022 Subaru Forester Sport AWD Lineartronic CVT 2.5L 4-Cylinder DOHC 16VRecent Arrival! 26/33 City/Highway MPG2022 Subaru Forester Sport...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (26 City/33 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SKAJC7NH517856
Stock: U6388T
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 07-22-2025 - $35,998fair price$788 below market
- 10,048 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 33 Hwy MPG
- CarMax East Meadow (20 mi away)
Close
Located in East Meadow, NY / 20 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
CarMax values transparency and wants you to love your next car, not settle on it. Certain vehicles may have unrepaired safety recalls. Check nhtsa.gov...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (26 City/33 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SLDRC0SH419850
Stock: 27170539
Certified Pre-Owned: No - Price Drop$27,794good price$1,392 below market
- 29,803 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 33 Hwy MPG
- Empire Mazda of Huntington (17 mi away)
Close
Located in Huntington Station, NY / 17 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
Clean CARFAX. 2022 Subaru Forester Touring CARFAX One-Owner.Finance for price is reflective after $1995 down. Subject to primary lenders approval. All...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (26 City/33 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SKARC4NH443798
Stock: 1244UI
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 06-23-2025 - Price Drop$23,441good price$1,791 below market
- 38,366 miles
- 1 accident, 2 owners, personal use only
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 33 Hwy MPG
- Bright Bay Mazda (7 mi away)
Close
Located in Bay Shore, NY / 7 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
2019 Subaru Forester Touring a rugged yet refined ride that'll turn heads and conquer any road! Wrapped in striking Jasper Green Metallic, this SUV bl...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: No
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (26 City/33 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SKAWC5KH481377
Stock: 7UT7278
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 07-02-2025 - $15,490fair price$88 below market
- 104,675 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 32 Hwy MPG
- JTL Auto Sales (18 mi away)
Close
Located in Selden, NY / 18 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
You'll be completely happy with this 2018 Subaru Forester. Curious about how far this Forester has been driven? The odometer reads 104675 miles. It l...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAEC0JH515356
Stock: 25-0030
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 02-21-2025 - $25,085good price$828 below market
- 19,898 miles
- 1 accident, 1 owner, personal use
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 33 Hwy MPG
- Generation Buick GMC (10 mi away)
Close
Located in Bohemia, NY / 10 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
Thank you for choosing Generation Buick GMC, Long Island's Newest Buick GMC dealer!2022 Subaru Forester Premium Brilliant Bronze Metallic LOW MILES!!...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: No
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (26 City/33 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SKAEC3NH414296
Stock: U1214
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-30-2025 - Price Drop$26,650fair price$217 below market
- 18,372 miles
- 1 accident, 1 owner, personal use
- 5 Seats, 25 City / 28 Hwy MPG
- Generation Kia (10 mi away)
Close
Located in Bohemia, NY / 10 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
25/28 City/Highway MPG New Price! Priced below KBB Fair Purchase Price! CARFAX One-Owner. Odometer is 8191 miles below market average! 4-Wheel Disc Br...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: No
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
26 Combined MPG (25 City/28 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SKAMC2NH479464
Stock: M00098
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 04-22-2025 - $18,762good price$1,133 below market
- 46,764 miles
- 1 accident, 1 owner, personal use only
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 32 Hwy MPG
- Mazda 112 (16 mi away)
Close
Located in Medford, NY / 16 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
Contact Mazda Chevrolet Hyundai 112 today for information on dozens of vehicles like this 2018 Subaru Forester Premium. Want more room? Want more styl...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: No
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAGC5JH476793
Stock: U44306
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 05-30-2025 - $30,095fair price$625 above market
- 24,271 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 33 Hwy MPG
- Generation Kia (10 mi away)
Close
Located in Bohemia, NY / 10 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
26/33 City/Highway MPG Recent Arrival! Clean CARFAX. CARFAX One-Owner. Odometer is 2616 miles below market average! 3.70 Axle Ratio, 4-Wheel Disc Brak...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (26 City/33 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SKAJC5PH419640
Stock: M00391L
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 07-21-2025 - $11,990fair price$910 above market
- 100,125 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 5 Seats, 21 City / 27 Hwy MPG
- JTL Auto Sales (18 mi away)
Close
Located in Selden, NY / 18 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
Designed with a spacious interior, this 2012 Subaru Forester is filled with smart features to make your everyday ride more comfortable and convenient...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
23 Combined MPG (21 City/27 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SHAGCXCH427183
Stock: 25-0096
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 06-24-2025 - New Listing$17,998fair price$302 above market
- 80,040 miles
- No accidents, 2 owners, personal use
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 32 Hwy MPG
- CarMax Smithtown (15 mi away)
Close
Located in Smithtown, NY / 15 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
CarMax values transparency and wants you to love your next car, not settle on it. Certain vehicles may have unrepaired safety recalls. Check nhtsa.gov...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJARC7HH545555
Stock: 27573447
Certified Pre-Owned: No - New Listing$16,998fair price$1,057 above market
- 100,517 miles
- No accidents, 4 owners, rental vehicle
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 32 Hwy MPG
- CarMax East Meadow (20 mi away)
Close
Located in East Meadow, NY / 20 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
CarMax values transparency and wants you to love your next car, not settle on it. Certain vehicles may have unrepaired safety recalls. Check nhtsa.gov...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: No
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
28 Combined MPG (26 City/32 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SJAGC8JH577004
Stock: 27239532
Certified Pre-Owned: No - $24,985fair price$722 above market
- 37,470 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 33 Hwy MPG
- Paul Conte Cadillac (21 mi away)
- Home delivery*
Close
Located in Freeport, NY / 21 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
Recent Arrival! 2020 Subaru Forester Limited 4D Sport Utility Ice Silver Metallic Clean CARFAX. CARFAX One-Owner. Odometer is 18381 miles below market...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (26 City/33 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SKAUC6LH448750
Stock: U10098
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 05-30-2025 - $24,943fair price$159 above market
- 23,340 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 33 Hwy MPG
- BMW of Freeport (21 mi away)
- Home delivery*
Close
Located in Freeport, NY / 21 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
Heated Leather Seats, NAV, Sunroof, All Wheel Drive, Panoramic Roof, Power Liftgate, NAV SYSTEM & harman/kardon & REVERSE AUTO BRAKING, NAV SYSTEM & h...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (26 City/33 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SKAUC0KH420313
Stock: KH420313T
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 07-16-2025 - 18,482 miles
- No accidents, 1 owner, personal use
- 5 Seats, 26 City / 33 Hwy MPG
- Stream Auto Outlet Islip (7 mi away)
Close
Located in Islip, NY / 7 miles away from Bay Shore, NY
2022 Subaru Forester Premium Crystal White Pearl Lineartronic CVT Clean CARFAX. CARFAX One-Owner. Odometer is 9704 miles below market average! 26/33 C...
AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary
Accident Free Vehicle: Yes
Personal Use Only: Yes
History Provider: AutoCheck
Title Details: Clean Title
Salvage Vehicle: No
Frame Damage: No
Theft History: No
Lemon Status: No
Free History Report: No
Features and Specs:
29 Combined MPG (26 City/33 Highway)
Listing Information:
VIN: JF2SKAEC9NH422094
Stock: W935
Certified Pre-Owned: No
Listed since: 05-31-2025
Showing 1 - 21 out of 1,397 listings
Filters
Skip to ResultsApplied Filters4Active
Make & Model
Year
New / Used
Price & Payments
Price Rating
Body Type
Trim
Mileage
Accidents & History
Engine & Drivetrain
Exterior Color
Interior Color
Total Seating
Edmunds Review
Features
Options & Packages
MPG
* Delivery of any kind does not apply to Alaska and Hawaii. Contact the dealer for delivery details, restrictions and costs.