2004 BMW 5 Series 4.4L V8 6-speed Manual Consumer Review - Worst car I've ever owned.

2004 BMW 5 Series - Consumer Review

Average Consumer Rating

340 Total Reviews

545i Sedan (4.4L V8 6-speed Manual)

Select a different vehicle  
Recently Viewed
There are no recently viewed vehicles to display
Interior Design
Exterior Design
Build Quality
7 of 10 people found this review helpful
Worst car I've ever owned. Beautiful looking but leaves you stranded.
By nickafan on


2004 BMW 5 Series 545i 4dr Sedan (4.4L 8cyl 6M)


The only thing this car has going for it is looks. The car is a worthless piece of crap in my opinion. I bought it with 70,000 miles and a month later, the car died. It needed a new battery and had $3,000 worth of oil leaks. My mechanic told me the oil leaks are standard maintenance on this BMW. A week later the car wouldn't start again & threw a check engine light. It needed a new thermostat, coolant, and MAF sensor. Two weeks later I discovered another oil leak at the oil pressure sensor! This is ridiculous. I've owned a 2006 Toyota from 0 miles all the way to 140,000+ miles and it never needed a new battery, never had oil leaks, never a check engine light, and it never left me stranded.

Favorite Features

The exterior design is great, the leather and interior looks nice making you want to buy the car, and the iDrive is very cool. The car is quick and drives nicely when it's actually running.

Suggested Improvements

A car that doesn't break down every week before it reaches 100,000 miles. If you're buying a "nice expensive car" shouldn't it last up to 200,000 miles like "cheap" Toyota's and Honda's do?
Recommend (7) (3)
Report it
Comments (1) Post a Comment
By chriskhoury
on 09/17/12 04:00 AM (PDT)

So what you're saying is that, this car didn't last a few months with you. You bought it with 70,000 miles. Ever wondered why the seller wanted to sell it? I have a 1997 BMW 5 series. My family has had it for the past 6 years, which means it has been on the road for the past 15 years approx. Never have we once put it in the shop for anything other than changing its tires. Except for last month, my radiator needed some maintenance. And THAT was it. Now why did your car end up like that? 3 case scenarios. 1- You're not so good at maintaining a car, although I doubt it since your 2006 Toyota lasted so long. 2- The guy who owned that car before you is a sob, I mean come on. at 70,000 miles it starts doing this? and 3- your mechanic is ripping you off. Fixing something and breaking something else just to rip you off my friend. All in all, this is a BMW. It's not a Kia Motors car, it's not a Honda, it's not a Renault. This is a BMW, it's tough, it's strong, and believe me it's like a lady. Treat her well with care and tender, she'll give you her everything. Get rough with her, and neglect her needs she'll just screw you over. Again, we have a 1997 BMW 5 Series, and a 2003 Mercedes Benz CLK. Without a doubt, I would drive the BMW instead of the Benz. Check your facts, your reviews about all BMWs are wrong. Maybe that one you own. Just not all of them.

Report it
Post a Comment

You must be signed in to post a comment.


Nearby Inventory Zip Code UPDATE
Have a question? We're here to help!
Chat online with us
Email us at help@edmunds.com
*Available daily 8AM-5PM Pacific
Call us at 855-782-4711
Text us at ED411