Tesla Motors Claims Victory in Dismissed Lawsuit Against Top Gear


  • Tesla Roadster Picture

    Tesla Roadster Picture

    Tesla Motors went down to defeat in a U.K. appeals court in a libel suit it filed against Top Gear — or did it? | March 06, 2013

Just the Facts:
  • Tesla Motors is claiming victory even though a United Kingdom appeals court dismissed a libel lawsuit from the automaker against the BBC show Top Gear.
  • "Although the outcome is not one that we were hoping to receive, by filing the case we actually won...by fighting we forced them to a defense and to admit that they were untruthful," wrote Shanna Hendriks, a Tesla Motors spokesperson in response to a query from Edmunds.
  • Tesla Motors said Top Gear faked a scene that appeared to show a Tesla Roadster running out of power.

PALO ALTO, California — Tesla Motors is claiming victory even though a United Kingdom appeals court dismissed a libel lawsuit from the automaker against the BBC show Top Gear.

"Although the outcome is not one that we were hoping to receive, by filing the case we actually won...by fighting we forced them to a defense and to admit that they were untruthful," wrote Shanna Hendriks, a Tesla Motors spokesperson in response to a query from Edmunds.

Tesla Motors said Top Gear faked a scene that appeared to show a Tesla Roadster running out of power.

"I am pleased that the Appeal Court has upheld the previous ruling and the case has been struck out," said Andy Wilman, executive producer of Top Gear, according to media reports from the United Kingdom. "I'd also like to apologize to the judges for making them have to watch so much Top Gear."

Top Gear tested the Tesla Roadster in 2008, claiming the car ran out of power after 55 miles and disputing the company's estimated range on the car. Tesla Motors said it missed out on $171,000 in lost sales as a result of the negative review.

The ruling comes on the heels of a dispute last month between Tesla Motors and The New York Times. Tesla CEO Elon Musk said the Times review of the Model S was a "fake." The review said the Model S fell short of its estimated range. The newspaper backpedaled on its earlier defense of the review.

The newspaper's public editor said the review had problems with "precision and judgment but not integrity."

Edmunds says: Tesla Motors puts an interesting spin on defeat.

Comments

  • ejsimon ejsimon Posts:

    Although I wasn't in the market for a Tesla, I walked away from that episode thinking Tesla was a piece of garbage. I actually think Tesla should have won the case vs Top Gear. They most definitely affected public opinion in a very negative way towards Tesla and I'm sure chased potential customers away.

  • atenza94546 atenza94546 Posts:

    Tesla is rght. The company and all Tesla's models are perfect. No need to test anymore. Why bother, this company don't need anymore improvement. Thye rae PREFCTE !!!

  • stovt001_ stovt001_ Posts:

    Man these guys are paranoid. Top Gear criticizes everybody, but only Tesla takes it seriously. They have a major persecution complex.

Leave a Comment
ADVERTISEMENT

Featured Video

ADVERTISEMENT

Marketplace

up2drive

Get Pre-Approved for a Loan


Car.com

Credit Problems?
We can help you get Financing!

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Have a question? We're here to help!
Chat*
Chat online with us
Email
Email us at help@edmunds.com
*Available daily 8AM-5PM Pacific