Skip to main content
Skip to Filters
3,070 listings
  • New Listing
    • 191,785 miles
    • No accidents, 3 owners, rental vehicle
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • P J McCafferty (53 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Auto Climate Control
    • Alarm
    • Rear Bench Seats
    • Aux Audio Inputs
    Close

    Located in Langhorne, PA / 53 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: No

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF1SG66668H729996
    Stock: 19528
    Certified Pre-Owned: No

  • $6,244
    great price
    $3,278 below market
    • 107,211 miles
    • No accidents, 2 owners, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 27 Hwy MPG, Manual
    • Maserati of Bergen County (20 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    • Alarm
    • Trip Computer
    Close

    Located in Upper Saddle River, NJ / 20 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    2009SubaruForester (NY/NJ) Enhanced performance, a refined interior and exceptional fuel economy are just a few of the things you'll enjoy about this ...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/27 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH63699G749955
    Stock: BCM2102A
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 03-12-2025

    • 161,797 miles
    • No accidents, 3 owners, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • Motion Auto Sales (76 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Alarm
    • Rear Bench Seats
    • Fold Flat Rear Seats
    • 2500lb Towing Capaci...
    Close

    Located in West Collingswood Heights, NJ / 76 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF1SG636X8H731741
    Stock: 731741
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 12-09-2024

  • Price Drop
    $6,407
    great price
    $1,862 below market
    • 111,892 miles
    • No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 21 City / 27 Hwy MPG
    • AW Auto and Truck Wholesalers (11 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Bluetooth
    • Leather Seats
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Power Driver Seat
    Close

    Located in Hasbrouck Heights, NJ / 11 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    ,APPOINTMENT STRONGLY RECOMMENDED, 60 PLUS VEHICLES IN STORAGE!! 2011 SUBARU FORESTER 2.5X LIMITED!! 4 DOOR WAGON/SPORT UTILITY 2.5L H4 F SOHC 16V!! A...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    23 Combined MPG (21 City/27 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SHAEC5BH701939
    Stock: 88903N
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 04-09-2025

  • New Listing
    $5,495
    great price
    $1,451 below market
    • 117,250 miles
    • No accidents, 2 owners, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • B&B Auto (6 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    • Alarm
    • Trip Computer
    • Rear Bench Seats
    Close

    Located in Union, NJ / 6 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    VERY GOOD CONDITION!!! RUNS GREAT!!! AWD!!! WARRANTY!!! FINANCING IS AVAILABLE!!! Very clean in and out. Reliable. Well maintained. Great car for a gr...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH61659H722832
    Stock: 722832
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 10-11-2024

  • New Listing
    • 222,153 miles
    • 2 accidents, 4 owners, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • Salvage Reseller North (59 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Power Driver Seat
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    • Alarm
    Close

    Located in Marlboro, NY / 59 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    This vehicle is located at Windham, ME Copart yard. Join our online auctions to see its final price. All purchases must take place online at www.salva...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: No

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH6CC2AH785099
    Stock: 62752075
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 06-28-2025

  • New Listing
    • 219,750 miles
    • 2 accidents, 2 owners, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • Salvage Reseller North (59 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Power Driver Seat
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    • Alarm
    Close

    Located in Marlboro, NY / 59 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    This vehicle is located at Hillsborough, NJ Copart yard. All purchases must take place online at www.salvagereseller.com. Visit our website to learn m...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: No

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH6CC7AH747318
    Stock: 61832835
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 07-01-2025

    • 104,760 miles
    • 1 accident, 4 owners, personal use
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • Salvage Reseller North (59 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Power Driver Seat
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    • Alarm
    Close

    Located in Marlboro, NY / 59 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    This vehicle is located at Fredericksburg, VA Copart yard. Join our online auctions to see its final price. All purchases must take place online at ww...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: No

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH6CC4AH716382
    Stock: 61395995
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 06-24-2025

  • Price Drop
    $3,200
    great price
    $1,921 below market
    • 142,636 miles
    • 2 accidents, 5 owners, personal use
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • Autos Under 5000 jrtransporting (34 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    • Alarm
    • Trip Computer
    • Rear Bench Seats
    Close

    Located in Island Park, NY / 34 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    2009 Subaru Forester 2.5 X AWD 4dr Wagon 4A 2.5L H4 Runs and drives well Clean transferable present title Fully licensed by NYS DMV- papers and pla...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: No

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH61679H719981
    Stock: 719981
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 12-06-2024

  • $6,995
    good price
    $1,088 below market
    • 89,815 miles
    • No accidents, 4 owners, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • EM Motorcars Metuchen (18 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    • Alarm
    • Trip Computer
    • Rear Bench Seats
    Close

    Located in Metuchen, NJ / 18 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    Visit EM Motorcars online at emmotorcars.com to see more pictures of this vehicle or call us at 9**-3**-8*** today to schedule your test drive.

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH61629H735750
    Stock: 735751
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 03-22-2025

  • $6,300
    fair price
    $245 below market
    • 148,781 miles
    • No accidents, 1 owner, personal use
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • Smart Auto Sales (10 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Leather Seats
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Power Driver Seat
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    Close

    Located in Paterson, NJ / 10 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    1 OWNERCLEAN TITLECLEAN CARFAXAWDEXCELLENT SERVICE HISTORYECO MODEBLUETOOTHEXCELLENT CONDITIONENGINE AND TRANSMISSION 100% RUN AND DRIVES LIKE NEWWE F...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH64629H782403
    Stock: 782403
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 05-31-2024

    • 150,284 miles
    • 2 accidents, 2 owners, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • Jan Auto Sales LLC (7 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    • Alarm
    • Trip Computer
    Close

    Located in Parsippany, NJ / 7 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    Looks runs great. Clean title. 3 months warranty with the asking price

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: No

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH63689H752713
    Stock: 63310042
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 06-11-2025

  • Price Drop
    $5,566
    fair price
    $79 below market
    • 175,724 miles
    • No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • Hitchcock Motor Cars (86 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Leather Seats
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Power Driver Seat
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    Close

    Located in Wolcott, CT / 86 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    New Price! Newport Blue Pearl 2009 Subaru Forester 2.5X Limited AWD 4-Speed Automatic 2.5L SOHC i-Active Valve Lift System ABSOLUTELY MINT 1 OWNER SUB...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH64639H775640
    Stock: HM2882
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 05-29-2025

  • $8,995
    fair price
    $110 below market
    • 88,025 miles
    • No accidents, 2 owners, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • Schaffer Automotive (43 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Leather Seats
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Power Driver Seat
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    Close

    Located in Slate Hill, NY / 43 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    2009 Forester Limited all options Automatic, Extra Clean, CARFAX, Low Mileage only 88,025 miles, Must see and Drive, Free 3 Months 5,000 mile War...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH64689H763032
    Stock: 1276
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 06-12-2024

  • $9,999
    fair price
    $178 above market
    • 83,627 miles
    • No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 21 City / 27 Hwy MPG
    • Faulkner Subaru Bethlehem (60 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Bluetooth
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Power Driver Seat
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    Close

    Located in Bethlehem, PA / 60 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    23 Combined MPG (21 City/27 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SHADC1BH728413
    Stock: BH728413
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 06-13-2025

  • $7,500
    fair price
    $398 above market
    • 113,334 miles
    • No accidents, 3 owners, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • Alpine Auto Sales (25 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    • Alarm
    • Trip Computer
    • Rear Bench Seats
    Close

    Located in Stockholm, NJ / 25 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    This vehicle has new front brakes & rotors, new rear brakes & rotors, a new timing belt, new serpentine belt and a new water pump & thermostat. It has...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH61689H768980
    Stock: 3093
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 02-14-2025

  • $9,200
    good price
    $518 below market
    • 83,357 miles
    • 1 accident, 2 owners, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 21 City / 27 Hwy MPG
    • Good Value Cars (74 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Bluetooth
    • Leather Seats
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Power Driver Seat
    Close

    Located in Norristown, PA / 74 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    3 MONTHS/ 4500 MILES WARRANTY *** AUTOMATIC *** CARFAX CERTIFIED *** LOW MILEAGE!! *** ALL WHEEL DRIVE *** BRAND NEW PA INSPECTION *** FULLY LOADED LI...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: No

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    23 Combined MPG (21 City/27 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SHAEC1BH778100
    Stock: GVC2598
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 06-12-2025

  • $7,999
    fair price
    $733 above market
    • 109,273 miles
    • No accidents, 3 owners, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • Trend Auto Motors (83 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    • Alarm
    • Trip Computer
    • Rear Bench Seats
    Close

    Located in Malvern, PA / 83 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    VERY CLEAN VEHICLE...We are a Carfax Authorized Dealership and every car we sell comes with a free Carfax History Report. We Receive fresh inventory d...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH61619H756931
    Stock: 756931
    Certified Pre-Owned: No

  • $6,995
    fair price
    $6 above market
    • 141,291 miles
    • 1 accident, 4 owners, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 20 City / 26 Hwy MPG
    • Coast to Coast Auto (PA) (91 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Leather Seats
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Power Driver Seat
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    Close

    Located in West Chester, PA / 91 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    SERVICED and PA Inspected**EXCELLENT Condition 2009 Forester 2.5 X Limited AWD 2.5L H4 170 HP 170lbs-ft of Torque 4-Speed Automatic. Features include ...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: No

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    22 Combined MPG (20 City/26 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH64689H704224
    Stock: R704224
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 06-20-2025

    • 108,135 miles
    • No accidents, 2 owners, personal use only
    • M2 Auto Group (27 mi away)
    Close

    Located in East Brunswick, NJ / 27 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    SUBARU FORESTER CLEAN CARFAX ALL WHEEL DRIVE AUTOMATIC ALLOY WHEELS LEATHER SUV crv rav4 outback escape santa fe PLEASE CONTACT US AT 7**-3**-5*** ...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH64659H786977
    Stock: 786977
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 06-19-2025

    • 123,197 miles
    • No accidents, 1 owner, personal use only
    • 5 Seats, 19 City / 24 Hwy MPG
    • Moffett Motors (49 mi away)
    • AWD/4WD
    • Leather Seats
    • Sunroof/Moonroof
    • Power Driver Seat
    • Tire Pressure Warnin...
    Close

    Located in Lakewood, NJ / 49 miles away from West Orange, NJ

    You are looking at a 2009 Subaru Forester XT that is a great compact crossover SUV with a lot of room for the family and equipment for a weekend getaw...

    AutoCheck Vehicle History Summary

    Accident Free Vehicle: Yes

    Personal Use Only: Yes

    History Provider: AutoCheck

    Title Details: Clean Title

    Salvage Vehicle: No

    Frame Damage: No

    Theft History: No

    Lemon Status: No

    Free History Report: No

    Features and Specs:

    21 Combined MPG (19 City/24 Highway)

    Listing Information:

    VIN: JF2SH66639H704905
    Stock: 10165
    Certified Pre-Owned: No
    Listed since: 04-05-2025

Showing 43 - 63 out of 3,070 listings

Consumer Reviews for the Subaru Forester

Read recent reviews for the Subaru Forester
Overall Consumer Rating
4.5 out of 5 stars256 Reviews
Write a vehicle reviewSee all 256 reviews
  • 5 star
    (71%)
  • 4 star
    (23%)
  • 3 star
    (3%)
  • 2 star
    (2%)
  • 1 star
    (1%)
4.25 out of 5 stars

A niche car, but fits perfectly in it.

speedysteve, 02/08/2012
2004 Subaru Forester XT AWD 4dr Wagon (2.5L 4cyl Turbo 5M)
I've owned my Forester XT for 6 years now, and it has been a very fun car. The only repair I've had is the alternator. It's far faster than it looks and I love being able to floor it on the highway in 5th and it just goes. It looks good, carries a fair amount of stuff when I go camping, and is great in the snow.
Report abuse
Filters
Skip to Results

Applied Filters4Active

Location

Search radius100 miles
Search radius

Make & Model

Year

New / Used

Price & Payments

Price Rating

Body Type

Trim

Mileage

Accidents & History

Engine & Drivetrain

Exterior Color

Interior Color

Total Seating

Edmunds Review

Features

Options & Packages

MPG

Listing Details