Skip to main content

Andy Mohr Buick GMC


9295 E 131st St, Fishers, IN 46038 (map)
Today 8:30 AM - 8:00 PM
Sales Rating
Recommend:
Yes (3) No (0)
Service Rating
Recommend:
Yes (4) No (0)
Back to Sales Reviews

Dealership Sales Review

1.5 out of 5 starssales Rating
Andy Mohr does not deliver on their promise.
Written by charlie81 on 09/20/2009

I recently visited Andy Mohr in Fishers to lease a new vehicle. After test driving the vehicle and offering to do something that day if the payments were made right, the sales person introduced me to the sales manager, John. John made me an offer - a four year lease, nothing down, waived the security fee and got the payments to $379 per month. I agreed, and we proceeded to return my current lease in a month early and make the deal that day. I cleaned my vehicle out and turned in the keys. Afterwards, the sales person introduced me to the finance manager to sign all of the paperwork. I went into his office, and he procedeed to tell me that I had two options: first, I could put $2200 down today and owe that plus the first payment, security and taxes on the rebate, or secondly, I could purchase the car over a 72 month period. Wait, didn't the sales manager already arrange the deal and payment plan? I explained the deal to the finance manager, and he said that the bank would only let them borrow so much and that I would need to owe the rest. He assured me it had nothing to do with my credit, which it shouldn't because I work hard to keep a solid credit rating. After two and a half hours of making all these arrangements, I went out to the sales manager and told him this wasn't right. He shouldn't make a promise he can't deliver, and he absolutely should have worked out the deal with the finance manager to begin with. I also demanded my vehicle keys back and that the paperwork for the lease return be tore up. I have never been treated this way at a dealership. I have had four GM vehicles and have been a loyal customer always happy with the service from the GM dealers. Andy Mohr disgraced that reputation. The sales person was extremely high pressured. The sales manager lacked integrity and thoroughness. Overall, horrible experience, and I would not recommend this dealer to anyone.

  • Recommend this dealer? No
  • Purchased a vehicle from this dealer? No

Add a Comment

Only letters, numbers, and spaces will be accepted.

Character limit: 30
Character limit: 7500
Please review your comments carefully before submitting. Once submitted, they cannot be deleted or changed. All reviews and comments to Edmunds are subject to the terms of our Visitor Agreement.

Showing 2 comments
Sort by:
bsucards on 12/06/2010
I completley agree with your opinion of Andy Mohr Buick Pontiac GMC and have heard the same types of comments from many people. I would recommend Ed Martin on Michigan Road 1,000 times over Andy Mohr. The sales people at Andy Mohr are very high pressure and make promises they can not keep. We live 5 minutes from Andy Mohr, but I made the 30 minute drive to Ed Martin for our last vehicle and couldn't be happier. I was left with such a bad taste in my mouth that I will drive the extra 25 minutes to Ed Martin for a simple service appointment.
Report
zyvxn on 12/06/2010
Funny - the last vehicle I bought was from Ed Martin as well. I also live less than 3 miles from Andy Mohr. I had a lemon Lincoln Navigator that Roush had sold me (technically, I think it needed to break down one more time to be an official lemon). I stated I was going to get rid of it within 24 hours and have a new vehicle. I told the sales person this and I meant it. I actually found the vehicle I wanted at Andy Mohr. The sales person was clueless that I dealt with. I ended up teaching them the features of the vehicle and how they worked. In the end she offered me a deal within the range I wanted. I commented that I was going to drive over to look at another vehicle from a different dealer on 96th Street. I stated I'd come back in a couple of hours. She said 'ok'. Any real sales person would have put on the high pressure to close the deal, she let me walk out. I did go to the dealer on 96th street (Toyota). There was an SUV there that was my other option. The SUV was locked on the lot, and dealer there told me I didn't want that SUV. Yes, I again said I was buying a truck today and would like to see the vehicle. He didn't want to walk into the building so he told me I didn't want the vehicle. I was shocked. First I was allowed to walk out of a dealer, and now a sales person told me I didn't want a vehicle. I got back in my vehicle and went to Ed Martin on Michigan to look at their GMCs (same as I was seeing at Andy Mohr). Found several there. Found one I liked, but not quite as well as the one at Andy Mohr. Ed Martin gave me an offer much better than Andy Mohr. Simply put, I was happy with the offer, but wanted to buy closer to home since that is where I'd get service done. I called the sales person at Andy Mohr, said if you can beat this by $100, I'll come buy the vehicle from you right now. She put the sales manager on who rudely said that it seemed Ed Martin wanted to sell a car to me more than they did, then he hung up. Crazy stuff. Makes you wonder how Ed Martin in Fishers is still in business.
Report