Stop-Start Feature - 2014 BMW 328i xDrive Gran Turismo Long-Term Road Test
ADVERTISEMENT

2014 BMW 328i xDrive Gran Turismo Long-Term Road Test

2014 BMW 328i xDrive Gran Turismo: Stop-Start Feature

March 6, 2014

2014 BMW 328i xDrive Gran Turismo

Our 2014 BMW 328i xDrive Gran Turismo has a Start-Stop feature on three of its four drive settings. I always find this feature disruptive so I usually turn it off.

I guess I'm going to have to get used to it eventually because Dan tells me this will be a feature in all new cars.

In our long-term Porsche 911, you could press a button to turn this feature off and it stayed off. But in our new BMW you have to switch it off every time you start the car. You do this by choosing Sport mode. All three of the other driving modes put Stop-Start back into play.

2014 BMW 328i xDrive Gran Turismo

How do you feel about Stop-Start? I know its purpose is to save fuel. But do you find it annoying?

Donna DeRosa, Managing Editor @ 3,392 miles


Comments

  • skibird skibird Posts:

    There should also be a button to turn it off to the right of the steering wheel.

  • nomercy346 nomercy346 Posts:

    my folks just got a regular 328i sedan and you can definitely turn stop start off with the dedicated switch even in comfort mode. they also complained about it defaulting back to on every time and I read that you can have it programmed at the dealer to store your preference in the key, so it'll stay off for as long as you want.

  • fordracefan fordracefan Posts:

    I have this feature on my 2012 C350. It defaults on and I will normally leave it on unless I get stuck in stop and go traffic as I worry the wear on the starter/engine if it is constantly starting. But I barely even notice it during normal stops at a stop light or stop sign.

  • miata52 miata52 Posts:

    My parents X3 has it. I don't usually notice it, but there have been a couple of times where I've come to a stop and decided to go RIGHT NOW to fit into traffic and I've caught the engine and steering with their pants down. There's a moments hesitation with the gas pedal down and I'm turning the wheel and nothing is happening. It's distressing when it happens and I hate it.

  • laurasdada laurasdada Posts:

    My '13 Jag XF has the feature, but it doesn't seem to engage below 40 degrees. Owners manual notes 32. So, with this cold New England winter, not much experience yet. But the few times it's engaged, once I got (get?!) used to it, it didn't seem overly obtrusive. I agree, though, in stop/go traffic I'll probably disengage. But, I have a couple of lenghty stoplights along my commute, will probably enjoy seeing the mpg-o-meter not plunging while idling!

  • I am more concern down the road when motor mounts begin to wear. At some point you will have a pronounced vibration every time the engine turns off/on.

  • sharp_cai sharp_cai Posts:

    I own a 2013 335i M sport with this [non-permissible content removed] (Auto Start- Stop) feature, and I leave it on at most of time. It doesn't bother me at all. Save fuel?? That's a big question mark. How much fuel we can save by having this feature? and why Japanese cars don't have it on their cars? People on the Bimmerpost.com are saying BMW dealership is able to default the feature, but not sure if it's true.

  • darthbimmer darthbimmer Posts:

    My family and I find automatic start-stop disruptive, too. We turn it off.

  • hybris hybris Posts:

    I would have this programed off before I left the dealership. I alone control when the motor shuts off.

  • legacygt legacygt Posts:

    The only car I've driven with this feature was my in-laws' civic hybrid. I found everything about driving that car incredibly annoying but the start/stop wasn't one of them. Sure I noticed it every time. But the reason you notice it is because the car gets so quiet and peaceful when you're stopped. And that's fine with me. It's just a change of expectations and I think it's an easy one when you consider that there's no reason to have NVH intruding in the cabin while you're stopped. Then it actually becomes a luxury.

  • bmwfan11 bmwfan11 Posts:

    Incorrect, Donna. To turn off start/stop you press the button devoted solely to that feature which is located directly above the ignition button. Look for the button with an A with a circular arrow above it. You can then drive in any of the modes (including Eco and Comfort) with the start/stop system deactivated, not just sport.

  • vvk vvk Posts:

    It is easy to change that setting if you have an Android phone/tablet and a $15 bluetooth OBD-II adapter. Download BMWhat app for $58 and you are all set. I really like the auto start stop feature in combination with auto-hold. When you drive in stop and go traffic, you can relax and enjoy the silence at the same time. Without auto-hold, it is not as good.

  • If it works well then it's not a problem. From most reports I've read GM and Ford have really good systems that restart without vibrations. The Germans, not so much.

  • I don't know if this has it but my 535i has a button below the ignition button that says A off. That turns off auto start stop. I think on a 3 series the button is above the ignition button, also you should be able to take it to a dealership and have them force it to remain off if you turn it off.

  • donnaderosa donnaderosa Posts:

    There is a button near the ignation. But it does not remain off. You have to press it every time you start the car. -- Donna

  • joner800 joner800 Posts:

    i drive a 300 w/a hemi and i get about 14mpg. when i know i'm going to be stopped at a light or a drawbridge for a while, i physically turn the car off myself, so...

  • My wife had a 328 with this feature as a loaner car. Once. After that, she asked that I drive the loaner when we had one. She was similarly unhappy with a rental Prius she had on the road. That's one reason why she now drives a Passat diesel.

  • x_lover x_lover Posts:

    There isn't an "A Off" button under the engine start/stop button? I know the 3 sedan has one. I thought they all have it. It shows it in a picture on their website where it explains the feature on the GT.

  • arirochmann arirochmann Posts:

    Stop-Start can be configured by the dealer to go into "Last Selected Mode". This means that if it is turned off it will remain off, even through multiple restarts, until otherwise selected by the driver. What's strange is I heard this was now the default mode for 2014s due to customer complaints, but your model obviously does not seems to be configured as such.

Leave a Comment
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Past Long-Term Road Tests

ADVERTISEMENT
Have a question? We're here to help!
Chat*
Chat online with us
Email
Email us at help@edmunds.com
*Available daily 8AM-5PM Pacific
Phone*
Call us at 855-782-4711
SMS*
Text us at ED411