Skip to main content

Germain Nissan of Columbus


4300 Morse Rd, Columbus, OH 43230 (map)
Today 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sales Rating

Be the first to write a review.

Service Rating
Recommend:
Yes (2) No (1)
Back to Service Reviews

Dealership Service Review

1 out of 5 starsservice Rating
When in doubt…suggest a new TRANSMISSION 🤣
Written by Mr Calm Cool Collected on 07/12/2025

I brought my 2017 Nissan Maxima in because it experienced sudden and unexpected electrical loss while driving. The car didn’t stall, didn’t lurch, didn’t slip out of gear—it simply lost power electrically. The dash lights flickered, the infotainment screen went black, and the car lost responsiveness. I didn’t pretend to be a mechanic—I simply described what happened in as much detail as possible, and I raised concern that this felt electrical, not mechanical. There were no signs of shifting issues. No jerking, slipping, rough idling, or grinding. No warning lights for the transmission. In fact, the car drove perfectly fine before and after the incident—except for the random electrical shutdown. After 9 1/2 hours, the dealership came back with their verdict: the CVT transmission needed to be replaced. Why? Because one diagnostic code pointed in that direction. Not because there was any credible evidence that would suggest it. Just a code. Thats it. The service advisor admitted it to me. No consideration for any other possible causes. $7k replacement because a diagnostic computer said so!?!? I don't fault them for not being able to reduplicate the problem during the test drive, but don’t opt for the easy way out because you’re a little stumped. So I would like to give A BIG sarcastic ‘Thank you’ to the technician for wasting my time by putting all of his “Talent” in a magic diagnostic machine that cost me $200. What a joke.

  • Recommend this dealer? No
  • Were you satisfied with the quality of work performed on your vehicle? No
  • Did the dealership complete the work within the timeframe promised? No
  • Did the dealership provide you with an accurate quote of the work to be performed? Yes
  • Do you feel the price paid for service(s) was fair and appropriate? Yes
  • Did the dealer honor all commitments made? No

Add a Comment

Only letters, numbers, and spaces will be accepted.

Character limit: 30
Character limit: 7500
Please review your comments carefully before submitting. Once submitted, they cannot be deleted or changed. All reviews and comments to Edmunds are subject to the terms of our Visitor Agreement.

Showing 1 comment
Sort by:
Germain Nissan on 07/14/2025
Dealer Response
It's concerning to hear about your experience with the electrical issue and subsequent diagnosis. We strive for thoroughness in our assessments, so it's disappointing that you felt we didn't explore all possibilities. Your feedback is invaluable, and we'd like to discuss this further to ensure a more satisfactory resolution. Please feel free to reach out at your convenience. Thank you, Chelsea Ratliff - Service Manager - 614-383-4321
Report