Skip to main content

2027 Nissan Rogue Hybrid vs. Toyota RAV4 vs. Kia Sportage: The Rogue Can Finally Keep Up

The Rogue Hybrid is redesigned, electrified and finally competitive with the best small SUVs

Nissan Rogue Hybrid Toyota RAV4 Kia Sportage Hybrid group shot hero
  • What's new: The $35,490 Nissan Rogue Hybrid gets one of the biggest updates we've seen in a long time, with a transformative new powertrain and cabin upgrades.
  • Why it matters: Our small SUV rankings run over 20 vehicles deep, and any new contenders in this battle royale have their work cut out for them. 
  • Edmunds says: Does the new Nissan have what it takes? It performed much better than we expected, and can now officially hang with the big kids.

Let's be honest: If you're in the market for a family vehicle, the Nissan Rogue probably isn't top of mind. Sure, it's affordable, but the gas-powered Rogue lacks a compelling reason to consider it; competitors simply do the fundamentals better. That's why it sits way down near the bottom in our small SUV rankings. But with the arrival of a new 2027 Nissan Rogue Hybrid, things have changed.

To see if the restyled Rogue's new hybrid powertrain puts it at or near the top of its class, we put Nissan's small SUV up against two of our favorite competitors: the Kia Sportage and Toyota RAV4, both of which are hybrids. Spoiler alert: The Rogue's made a huge leap forward. (Be sure to read its full instrumented testing results here.)


3rd Place: Toyota RAV4

  • Edmunds rating: 8.1 (out of 10)
  • The good: Tons of storage for small items, excellent visibility
  • The bad: Uncomfortable backseat, noisy cabin, subpar materials

It's a surprising third-place finish for the RAV4 in this comparison. For this test, we did not use the RAV4 that's part of our One-Year Road Test fleet. We own the volume-trim XLE Premium; a top-of-the-line Limited better matched the other two SUVs in this comparison test based on price and features.

That bumps the RAV4's as-tested price up to $46,683 — the highest of these three by far. The RAV4's interior, practical as it is with its seemingly endless supply of cubbies, shelves and bins for all the stuff from your pockets, doesn't match the other two SUVs in material quality and design. We also find the Toyota's seats to be too firm in both rows, but particularly in the back seat, which isn't comfortable on longer drives.

2027 Toyota RAV4 backseat

Though the RAV4 drives well with its punchy hybrid powertrain and well-calibrated brakes, it's noticeably louder inside than the others (especially at highway speeds) and doesn't ride as smoothly. Simply put, the Nissan and the Kia are more refined. In a competitive trio, that's enough to drop the RAV4 down to third place. We would still recommend the Toyota for many people, and we like its standard dashcam, a feature that many consumers are looking for. We just like these other two SUVs a bit more.

2027 Nissan Rogue Hybrid front

2nd Place: Nissan Rogue Hybrid

  • Edmunds Rating: 8.2 (out of 10)
  • The Good: Smooth hybrid powertrain, great seats
  • The Bad: Small-ish cargo area and backseat, missing some features for the price

Beating the RAV4 means the Rogue's redesign is a huge success. A big part of the improvement is the Rogue's new E-Power system, where a turbocharged three-cylinder engine supplies power to a battery, and a pair of electric motors drives the wheels. This means the Rogue Hybrid has standard all-wheel drive. In our testing, it's much quicker than both the Toyota and the Kia, winning the 0-to-60-mph sprint.

2027 Nissan Rogue Hybrid OEM driving hero

But it's not the acceleration that we like best about driving the Rogue Hybrid — it's the quietness. The gas engine tries to stay shut off and out of the way as much as possible, and around the city in particular, that strategy keeps the Rogue's cabin serene. This is also the only one of these SUVs to offer a one-pedal driving mode, which makes it feel like an EV a lot of the time — in a good way. It also proves highly efficient; on our 170-mile test loop with the same city/highway split used by the EPA, we observed 42.2 mpg.

The cabin updates have also worked wonders. There's a much better infotainment experience with the larger 14.3-inch touchscreen, which now comes with Google Built-In apps. That natively integrates Google Maps and the Google Voice Assistant with Gemini (if you activate it), both of which are much better than what Nissan used to offer. And both the front and rear seats offer much more cushioning and support than those in the RAV4.

2027 Nissan Rogue Hybrid dashboard

There are only a few caveats. Like the Toyota, the Rogue is on the smaller side of for compact SUVs, so there isn't quite the back seat or cargo space you get with the Kia or even the Honda CR-V. But the Rogue's back doors do open almost 90 degrees, so it's still easy to hop in and install a car seat. Also, with an as-tested price of $44,535 for the SR with Technology package, it feels like it's missing a few features you'd expect, including a power passenger seat and an auto-dimming rearview mirror.

Those nitpicks aside, this is the first Rogue we've felt compelled to gush about since … well, ever. It's an unprecedented jump for the Nissan — now third place in our compact SUV rankings, up from 15th — and this is the best we've felt about one of the Japanese automaker's vehicles in years.

2027 Kia Sportage Hybrid front

1st Place: Kia Sportage Hybrid

  • Edmunds Rating: 8.6 (out of 10)
  • The Good: Incredible value, large back seat and cargo area
  • The Bad: Convoluted control scheme, less efficient than the others

The Sportage Hybrid takes top honors. The argument for the Kia often starts with value. It's got the longest warranty of the bunch by a wide margin (5 years/60,000 miles of basic coverage), and it offers the most features per dollar. With a price tag of just $41,985 for a loaded, top-trim Sportage Hybrid SX Prestige, it's the cheapest SUV in our test but comes with a higher-quality cabin and just as many features as the RAV4.

The Sportage also gives you more space for passengers and cargo, with an expansive back seat and nearly 40 cubic feet of trunk room. Though the Rogue Hybrid's rear seats are more comfortable, we'd still rather spend time in the back of the Sportage Hybrid on a long drive, since it offers a few extra recline settings. 

2027 Kia Sportage Hybrid dashboard

Our primary complaints about the Sportage Hybrid center on its controls. Below the main infotainment touchscreen is a second, short touchscreen that houses both climate and media controls. The problem is, there isn't room to display them all at the same time, so there's a button to toggle between showing one line of touch buttons that shows controls like temperature and fan speed, and another for skipping tracks and changing volume. You have to look down to see which is selected before doing anything, and even the knobs change function between volume/tuning and temperature. It's a poor solution that bothers us in other Kias, and continues to bug us here.

The final issue is efficiency. We think the Sportage Hybrid has the smoothest highway ride of the three, and it's got enough power to feel peppy around town and on the highway, but its fuel economy numbers don't match up to the other two. It's only rated for 35 mpg combined. However, since you're paying less on the sticker, it does kind of even out.

We think all three of these SUVs are very appealing; they all have overall ratings in the 8s, our benchmark for an "excellent" score. The Sportage is our favorite overall, but if space isn't your top consideration, we really encourage you to at least take the Rogue Hybrid for a test drive, because the way it feels behind the wheel is so unique. And if it doesn't win you over, hey, you've still got two outstanding alternatives.

Get More Edmunds Car News in Your Inbox