I had spent a year test driving 20 cars over 1000mi to decide on the car that would last me the 20yrs my last car did, a VW Corrado.
Life's too short to keep driving VWs, but the final shootouts for months were between the '10 GTI and different flavors of 1 and 3 series BMW coupes.
I was not cross-shopping any of the Japanese "hot hatches".
>Short gearing+revvy engine=lots of shifting=driver involvement
>Even PZEV engines underrated at 210+hp at wheels =~240 crank hp&flat torque
>Huge back seat+hatch space when folded
>Fabulous stereo head unit+Dynaudio=best audio well above its class
>XDS works really well, steering nearly as direct as the better RWD cars, easily best for FWD
>Better ride-handling balance than 3-series sport pkg (no run-flats helps)
>Amazing amount of std equip for the base price for a euro car
>Smart styling walks fine line between aggressive&chill
>Great ergos for my build, but BMW sport pkg seats still best
>Clutch& gearbox action sublime
>Good summer tires really raise chassis performance
>HVAC controls are garbage in an otherwise quality interior, and it doesn't hold the interior temp very well
>There were a lot of cost-cutting measures to the MkV, and more to come between 2010 & 2011.
Bringing back the body-colored side mouldings for parking lot protection would be a good start
>A center channel speaker for the Dynaudio stereo upgrade
>ESP to allow more aggressive slip angles when the TCS is manually switched off
>Leave the 12V outlets on when ignition is off
>Dealer programming needed to disable DRLs, honk when locking
>Better brake pads, calipers & air ducting
>Less road noise thru chassis
>140mph speedo, 180mph is stupid
>oil temp display
>accurate mpg display
I wrote the above review and the 'value' category was labeled 'fuel economy'.
I may have given it 5* for overall value (wrt to my priorities vs BMWs), but for actual gas mileage it would have to be 3*, maybe even 2*.
Short trips around town in cold weather for a tank is <=20mpg w/o a lot of traffic snarls, and have barely broke 30mpg on a very easy interstate trip.
I know to stay out of the boost or the mpg plummets.
Dashboard mpg indicator consistently 2mpg optimistic -- why?
Do they think I'm too dumb to check its accuracy?
Also, I had meant to say "there are a lot of cost-cutting measures in the oddest places compared to the MkV (06-09)series on the 2010, and even more to the 2011".
I'd pay another grand on the base price to have a more-completely 'finished' car.
Seems VWAG plans to continue dumbing down their cars to a price point against the falling $, so 2010 may be the sweet spot between finish and functionality.
† Edmunds.com received the highest numerical score in the proprietary J.D. Power 2014 Third-Party Automotive Website Evaluation Study℠. Results based on responses from 3,381 responses, measuring 14 companies and measures third-party automotive website usefulness among new and used vehicle shoppers. Proprietary study results are based on experiences and perceptions of owners surveyed from January 2014. Your experiences may vary. Visit jdpower.com.