I decided to go with a Yaris after driving a Camaro for 13 years. I love this car! It is peppy enough and sticks to the curves just fine. I am also 6'2" and a large guy and I have plenty of room, in fact this car has more room than my Camaro. The back seat also has plenty of room for me to sit comfortably. I am also averaging 37 MPG and that is a mix of city and highway driving. I would highly recommend this car. Go out and get on the Yaris bandwagon!
The aux input, the large amount of cargo space, the gas mileage and the amount of room inside the car.
Only thing I wish I had is a tach, it didn't come with my car, but it really isn't needed.