2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5i AWD 4dr Wagon (2.5L 4cyl 5M)
Hauls like a station wagon, runs like a sports sedan. I can take four kids to soccer, or leave BMWs in the dust. Comfortable, quiet. Nice interior. Lousy stereo. Lot of power, minimal turbo lag, great grip wet or dry. Tires are a weak spot, but easily replaced. I went from a Miata to this, and the Subie is so much fun to drive it was an easy transition.
Turbo engine (pulls like crazy). Dual auto climate control. Very nice leather seats. Huge sunroof. Safety features (front and side air bags, side curtains). 4-stage seat heaters.
Auto up driver's window (only auto down now). Better stereo. Two-touch sunroof open (requires three touches now). Only nits to pick, really.