2007 Subaru Impreza 2.5 i 4dr Sedan AWD (2.5L 4cyl 5M)
I just sold my 99 Mustang GT and got an 07 Impreza. Great car. Plenty of pep considering it uses the same engine as the Impreza RS's used from 1999-2005 and it has pretty much the same 0-60 time as the Civic SI for less. The AWD is a blessing in adverse weather. This is my second Subaru and definitely won't be my last. I'll have to step up to a WRX next time though. I highly suggest adding the foglights and spoiler to the vehicle. They really complete the rally like look these cars are bred for.
Peppy 2.5 liter engine. AWD. Smooth shifter. Great headlights!
I would suggest that Subaru make the rear seats fold 60/40. And bring back the RS title, it's much classier than just "i."