2005 Subaru Forester - Consumer Discussions

Subaru Forester Air Conditioning Problems

• Re: A/C Problem on 2004 Forester [techmarcom]

  Written by: mithras on May 10, 2013 3:29:30 PM

  I have a 2005 Forester (89,000 miles) with the same problem. It is, apparently, not unusual. The A/C clutch is burned and slips when the engine and/or the clutch gets hot. A new compressor/clutch is required. The clutch cannot be repaired or replaced by itself). Price from local Subaru dealer: $649, plus $9 for a replacement bracket. That's without labor. Total price is "around $1,200." The best price from a trustworthy ... Read More

2007 Forester LL Bean with a blown head gasket

• Subura over rated!

  Written by: clayj on Apr 23, 2013 4:16:34 PM

  Spoken like a true subaru salesman, if you read my post the 2009 in leaking oil and YES the FB motors can still get external blown head gasket that will leak oil and even develop a internal leak causing Engine damage by leaning out the cylinder with air. The 2007 is a EJ25 and that just leaks everything at 90,000 miles. Subaru has not stood behind there products or the people ... Read More

• 2007 Forester LL Bean with a blown head gasket

  Written by: clayj on Apr 22, 2013 6:22:29 PM

  Just wanted to Share with anyone that looking at purchasing a Subaru. Please Do NOT without a warning. what was to be fixed in 2005 the Known Head gasket issue is still THERE! currently in my Family we own 3 Subarus 2007 forester, 2009 Outback and a 2011 legacy, The 2007 forester at 85,000 was noticed by dealer the head gasket was leaking oil and told me to monitor. Now at ... Read More

'06 Forester Heater/Mode Cables Deform

• Re: '06 Forester Heater/Mode Cables Deform [pulphook]

  Written by: saedave on Dec 6, 2012 7:18:14 AM

  Our non-dealer A.S.E. Subaru mechanic here recommended that we get an older set from used parts a.k.a. "junk yard". The cables in this set from an 04 or 03 Forester were thicker, durable, and exactly matched the OEM set on our 2006 except for the thicker cables. Conclusion ? The SOA beancounters decided to save a few $$$ on decreasing the quality and reliability of the heater set cables in the ... Read More

• Re: '06 Forester Heater/Mode Cables Deform [xwesx]

  Written by: pulphook on Dec 6, 2012 6:57:49 AM

  Here's my experience with this OEM heater cable ass'y problem. SOA CHANGED the spec and manufacture of all the heater cables starting with the 2005 Foresters. In our 2006 the broken/deformed cables were first replaced with the OEM set from a dealer......THEY ALSO DEFORMED/BENT/STOPPED FUNCTIONING. Our non-dealer A.S.E. Subaru mechanic here recommended that we get an older set from used parts a.k.a. "junk yard". The cables in this set from an ... Read More

oil leak 2005 forester

• oil leak 2005 forester

  Written by: kent30 on Dec 1, 2012 6:01:47 AM

  I've a 2005 subaru forester with 107k miles. It has suddenly started burning oil. It needed a quart of oil after only 300 miles. Is it a head gasket problem? If yes, how much would it cost to fix it? At 102K miles I had timing belts replaced by the dealer. Is there any connection to that and oil leak? I've owned the car for 7 years and never had to ... Read More

2012 Subaru Forester Transmission Problems

• 2012 Subaru Forester Transmission Problems

  Written by: missdev on Mar 19, 2012 9:34:57 AM

  I purchased a 2012 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium (automatic transmission) in November 2011 with 4 miles on it. Since the get-go it has had issues, but we thought that some of them might work themselves out as we broke the car in (which we were religious about). At the first oil change, we told the dealership about the issues we were experiencing and got the expected "the computer doesn't say anything ... Read More

Subaru AWD vs. Honda VTM-4

• Re: Subaru AWD vs. Honda VTM-4 [imaginary]

  Written by: hargin on Jan 22, 2012 10:35:34 PM

  I own a 2005 Forester and a2010 Pilot. Under adverse weather conditions like snow and ice the forester gets around far better than the pilot. The AWD system of the forester works great. The Pilot is like driving a big sled that cannot handle slick or snowy hills. Where as the forester handles the same conditions with ease. When the going gets tuff, get a Subaru.

Subaru Forester Prices Paid and Buying Experience

• Re: Subaru Forester 2011 [budhina]

  Written by: jogousa on Jun 19, 2011 4:06:25 AM

  Before I bought mine (2010 Forester XT) I also had Honda CRV and Toyota Rav-4 on my short list. But I could not compare apples with apples because local dealers did not have 4-wheel drive CRVs or Rav-4s - that is what I wanted for my frequent trips to the Rockies and Sierras in winter. This is my second Forester and I went with proven technology and past experience and retention ... Read More

Subaru Crew Problems & Solutions

• Re: Hitch Possibilities.... [paisan]

  Written by: aatherton on Mar 4, 2011 6:20:34 AM

  Pre-2008, the automatic transmission had an external spin-on filter as shown here: http://www.subaruoutback.org/forums/attachments/problems-maintenance/15283d12614- - 43974-2005-ob-oil-filter-imag0021.jpg and here: http://img65.imageshack.us/img65/9540/5064502498b0501f6cfus1.jpg For the 2008 MY the filter mount was plugged with a bolted cap: http://i49.photobucket.com/albums/f280/vintagefortytwo/Forester/IMG_0692.jpg And for 2009 the filter mount was closed with an integral casting: http://i49.photobucket.com/albums/f280/vintagefortytwo/Forester/2009ForesterATfi- - - - - - lterhole.jpg Those photos of the 2008 and 2009 Forester automatic transmissions are not misleading. They show where the external spin-on transmission ... Read More

2011 Subaru Forester

• Re: Temp indicator on 2011 non-turbo? [ateixeira]

  Written by: paisan on Jan 20, 2011 12:02:59 PM

  Yup, even the need is a dummy gauge. Cold, Normal, Hot. When I was discussing putting gauges in with the forester/impreza guru at Subaru, I told him for the STi I would like to see digital gauges similar to the ones I have in my CTSV, which is a small LCD panel embedded in the cluster where you can scroll through several gauges that show things in digital/analog format on a ... Read More

Subaru Forester Prices Paid and Buying Experience

• Re: Subaru Maintenance Plan Quote - Good Price? [morin2]

  Written by: jogousa on Aug 20, 2010 5:56:13 AM

  As far as I know, if your Subaru(s) is/are registered with Subaru North America they would send you an offer to get the extended warranty before your regular warranty (3 years/36 K) expires. It is also important that if you buy used Subaru that you notify Subaru North America as a new owner so that they put you in their database in case of recalls and such. I would think that ... Read More

All-New 2010 Legacy/Outback

• Re: 3.6R Limited 2010 Legacy [frenchguy007]

  Written by: ateixeira on Jun 24, 2010 9:56:41 AM

  Everyone calls themselves premium. Heck, Suzuki pitches the Kizashi as a luxury performance sedan. Seriously. It doesn't even offer a V6 or a turbo. Subaru's true upscale march came in 2005-2006 and failed miserably (look at Tribeca sales). Everyone balked at the prices. Sales really took off in 2009 when the Forester arrived with value pricing (and a little de-contenting to be honest).

Gold Plus Extended Warranty -- worth it?

• Re: Low Priced Genuine Subaru Extended Warranties [aatherton]

  Written by: jogousa on Jul 20, 2010 3:17:23 PM

  Well, I am having second thoughts about this warranty on my 2010 XT. My other Subaru Forester (2005) with about 50,000 miles on it (that I gave to my son) has major auto transmission problems. He took it to 3 different authorized Subaru dealers (in California) and all 3 of them gave him 3 different possible causes and estimates, what it would take to fix it (averaging $ 2000 price to ... Read More

All-New 2010 Legacy/Outback

• Re: Forester 2.5X Premium or Outback 2.5i Premium? [xwesx]

  Written by: saedave on Jun 7, 2010 12:39:02 PM

  That said, the lightness of steering is the one thing about my 2010 Forester that I do not love, but I do tolerate it. It stands in stark contrast to previous Subaru vehicles, which always had very well-balanced steering. Wes If you were my age, you'd appreciate the lighter touch. :) The return-to-center action when releasing the wheel is nice in city driving; neither my Legacy or 2005 Outback 3.0R had ... Read More

• Re: 3.6R Limited 2010 Legacy [ateixeira]

  Written by: saedave on Jun 24, 2010 12:32:54 PM

  Subaru's true upscale march came in 2005-2006 and failed miserably (look at Tribeca sales). Everyone balked at the prices. But some of us benefitted from the great discounts like the $5000 off of a 3.0R VDC that I got at that time. The up-market push brought me back from Audi/VW since I didn't have to sit on recycled burlap like in my 97 Legacy any more. :D And take a look ... Read More

Subaru Crew Problems & Solutions

• Forester- AT temp light will not go away!

  Written by: atticarj on Mar 1, 2010 9:12:53 AM

  Have a 2005 Subaru Forester XS, with 2.5L engine. Purchased new. Have replaced catalytic converter, O2 sensors, power steering pump, and the usual brakes and rotors and timing belt. Approx 5 weeks ago, I was driving at about 45 mph when I noticed that engine RPM started to fluctuate 400-500 rpm, back and forth. After that, the Automatic Transmission Temp light started to flash, and the check engine light came on ... Read More

All-New 2010 Legacy/Outback

• Re: Subaru Legacy, Honda CRV or Toyota Camry? [elena_l]

  Written by: ateixeira on Jan 26, 2010 10:56:36 AM

  The CR-V is more comparable to the Forester, right around the same size, as both are a bit shorter and more upright than the Outback. Forester actually beat the CR-V in residual value, and won "Best Compact Utility Vehicle" from Automotive Lease Guide, the company that sets actual residuals for leases. Outback won for "Best Midsize Utility Vehicle" as well. Subaru also won "Best Mainstream Brand", though I think Honda wasn't ... Read More

red fluid leak subaru forester 2005

• red fluid leak subaru forester 2003

  Written by: dordan71799 on Jan 30, 2010 12:26:36 PM

  This is a 2003 not 2005. I was told the fluid was coming from my rack. I had that replaced and it is still leaking. The power steering fuild levels do not drop even though I have leaked atleast 1/2 cup of red fuild.

2005 Subaru Forester Acid sulfur hose burning smell

• Re: 2005 Subaru Forester Acid sulfur hose burning smell [forestercare]

  Written by: ateixeira on Jan 25, 2010 7:55:02 AM

  I would call 800-SUBARU3 and get a regional manager involved in your case. Sounds like the dealers may have messed up your Subie. :(

• 2005 Subaru Forester Acid sulfur hose burning smell

  Written by: forestercare on Jan 23, 2010 10:54:51 AM

  Approx 3000 miles after the dealership had forgotten to put oil back into my car after its 25000mile service, I've had problems. The dealership claimed the oil leaked out - all within 20miles without a single drip/puddle anywhere. The car developed a burning smell - "acid, sulfur, brake pad, burning hose". Dealership said nothing was wrong. At 40,000 mile I took the vehicle to a different Subaru dealership when the check ... Read More

Mitsubishi Outlander vs. Subaru Forester

• Re: Part #s [fushigi]

  Written by: ateixeira on Dec 23, 2009 8:23:48 AM

  Hyundai has made HUGE strides with their engines. Their 2005 V6 Sonata made 170hp. Today their entry-level 4 banger makes more than that. Hyundai deserves the "Most Improved Player" award. Ford did wonders with EcoBoost, too. Twin turbos, impressive power, and you can run regular fuel. Who else? On paper, GM's Equinox is amazing - direct injection on both engines (i4 and V6), class leading power, class leading fuel economy. Sadly ... Read More

Forester - Headgasket Repair & Engine Rebuild

• Re: 2005 Subaru Forester Head Gasket problem [krispychick]

  Written by: goldengal on Dec 7, 2009 5:45:44 PM

  Hi CC Our symptoms for the HG issue was leaking coolant, a sweet smell like maple syrup, and some smoke from the hood after driving -Yikes! We went online to search for great reviews of the best independent Subaru mechanic in the Twin Cities and found a honest mechanic who did the oil/coolant test to confirm (along with other checks). I think he charged 40.00 to go over the entire car. ... Read More

• Re: 2005 Subaru Forester Head Gasket problem [goldengal]

  Written by: krispychick on Dec 7, 2009 5:22:25 PM

  Yes, apparently this is a design issue - a poor design -so it does extend beyond the 03 models. I will try getting in touch with Subaru of Ameica. I originally put the car in the dealer for a recall issue and they were the ones who told me I needed head gaskets. Do you think I should still have it confirmed somewhere else? I don't have any signs of a ... Read More

• Re: 2005 Subaru Forester Head Gasket problem [erikwi]

  Written by: krispychick on Dec 7, 2009 5:19:17 PM

  Thanks for your reply. Wow - 2006 at at 43K! Unfortunately I don't have any warranty left - I just hit 75,000 miles and I am sure that is over the warranty. Any suggestions? Do you think it would help to call the corporate office?

• Re: 2005 Subaru Forester Head Gasket problem [krispychick]

  Written by: goldengal on Dec 7, 2009 5:19:17 PM

  I did not realize that the HG problem extended past the 03 models. We replaced our HG's on our 03 Forester and it runs great. If you don't have any warranty left -get in touch with Subaru of America and get them to at least pay half of the cost. Make sure it is your HG by reading up on the signs and symptoms in the forums. As for tires make ... Read More

• Re: 2005 Subaru Forester Head Gasket problem [krispychick]

  Written by: erikwi on Dec 7, 2009 5:04:46 PM

  Had my 2006 done under warranty at 43k and now my mom's getting the head gaskets replaced on her car at 30k under warranty. Do you have any warranty left?

• 2005 Subaru Forester Head Gasket problem

  Written by: krispychick on Dec 7, 2009 3:13:14 PM

  Has any had a head gasket problem with the 2005 model? I brought my car in for a recall and was told I need new head gaskets, tires and brakes. My tires were two year old - annoying to say the least. But the head gasket issue is obviously a design flaw in subaru's. I was wondering if Subaru would give me half toward the HD repair. Anyone have any experience ... Read More

new tires for a 2005 subaru forester x

• Re: new tires for a 2005 subaru forester x [mr10]

  Written by: xwesx on Dec 3, 2009 1:45:51 PM

  What do you want from the tires? :D

• new tires for a 2005 subaru forester x

  Written by: mr10 on Dec 3, 2009 5:33:44 AM

  what type of tires do you recommend for our 2005 subaru forester x

Mitsubishi Outlander vs. Subaru Forester

• Re: Do It Yourself [chelentano]

  Written by: ateixeira on Nov 17, 2009 4:04:11 AM

  Yea, sure, I know Admit it, you did not know about Subaru's diesel engine. Otherwise why did you mention it on your list of things Subaru doesn't offer that Mitsubishi does? Have you ever thought why Lexus and Benz don’t use your “the real thing” in their luxury SUVs? Because those aren't the sportier manufacturers in that segment. BMW offers a true manual in the X3. RX350? Please...I own a Toyota, ... Read More

• Re: Do It Yourself [ateixeira]

  Written by: chelentano on Nov 16, 2009 4:42:05 PM

  >> The rest of your post waters things down by comparing Mitsu corporate to FHI. Subaru of America, where both of us live, is on a huge roll... 'Subaru of America' does not build cars. It’s just a marketing office and sales numbers by local market/season may be misleading for the company health. The fact is that worldwide Fuji / Subaru sales decline every year: from 597,000 cars in 2008 to ... Read More

• Re: Chase Freedom Rewards [chelentano]

  Written by: ateixeira on Nov 16, 2009 6:03:19 AM

  Dual-Clutch auto-manual True, but it's a shame the dual-clutch SST transmission didn't make it to the US-spec Outlander GT, though. Keep in mind that vehicle starts at $31 grand, and that's with cloth and no Navi. Plus - Mitsu said it was coming. may be it's not in the top 2 anymore, but top 3 or 5 Actually no, it did not make the top 6 in its class. The rest ... Read More

Subaru Reliability

• RE: Subaru Reliability

  Written by: bvf925 on Nov 14, 2009 7:14:44 AM

  I had the original 1998 Forester for 8 years and loved it however, the paint faded fast on the hood, I had to replace the right front brake caliper 3 times, the heat shield constantly loosened up & vibrated annoyingly, and I hated the ugly giraffe cloth seat pattern. BUT, it was fantastic in the snow which is why I mainly bought it. I live in New England with hilly, winding, ... Read More

Shudder at slow speed turns

• Shudder at slow speed turns

  Written by: jim701 on Oct 24, 2009 1:36:49 PM

  My 2005 Forester 2.5 with some 68k Kms recently started exhibiting a shudder when turning hard left or right at very slow speed such as when entering a driveway or exitting a parking spot. No vibration is evident during normal driving situations. Steering fluids, belt and steering rods were checked without result. A Subaru technician suggested changing fluid in both front and rear differentials which made no difference. Are there any ... Read More

Subaru Forester Lease Questions

• 2010 Forester 2.5 X Premium Lease deal

  Written by: conger14 on Aug 12, 2009 10:51:49 AM

  Hi, I have the following deal in place but I wanted to check on the money factor: 2010 2.5X Premium MSRP 25215 Sale Price 23400 MF .00270 Residual 62% 15k miles a year 36 months. With a trade of a 2005 subaru legacy GT wagon where they are giving me 9800 and wiping out 2900 in negative equity gives me a monthly payment of 429.17 a month with 1383 due to ... Read More

2009 Subaru Forester

• Re: forester vs crv [Hambros]

  Written by: xwesx on Sep 30, 2009 12:47:34 PM

  I have never found heated wipers to work very well, except for a very narrow band of temperatures around freezing. The AWP selling point for me is the heated mirrors - those are, as they have been for well over a decade, fantastic. I don't like that they are all tied together on a single defrost switch (not sure if that is the case on the '09s - I have a ... Read More

2006 BMW X3 vs. 2009 Subaru Forester

• Re: 2006 BMW X3 vs. 2009 Subaru Forester [smsoule]

  Written by: kenm6 on Sep 17, 2009 10:45:00 AM

  My wife has a 2006 X3, there was the blue tooth transmitter failure at the beginning of this year. Other than this, the X3 has been very reliable since Dec of 2005. She loves the X3 more than the Forester. I have a 2009 Forester Prem, so far there is no problem at all, it has 30K miles on it now. By the way this is my third Forester, I had ... Read More

All-New 2010 Legacy/Outback

• Re: Saw the new Legacy sedan at my dealer [ctjalsma]

  Written by: saedave on Aug 3, 2009 12:26:43 PM

  Well said. I was cleaning the inside of my 2005 Outback 3.0R VDC this morning and kept reminding myself to do it more often since it certainly won't be replaced by the ugly 2010 Subaru truck. The Forester's good looks aren't quite matched by interior materials quality...thin carpet, cheap headliner, but at least the interior styling is good. Now if it had a reasonably priced bluetooth accessory it would be even ... Read More

• Saw the new Legacy sedan at my dealer

  Written by: ctjalsma on Aug 3, 2009 10:38:35 AM

  Took my 98 Legacy GT wagon to my local dealer for some service last week. In the show room was a Forester and the new Legacy sedan (don't know what trim level). I was taken aback, stunned, actually, by the Legacy. I was tempted to offer my condolences to the staff, but kept my mouth shut. My first reaction was 'homely', followed quickly by 'hideous'. I felt like patting it's head ... Read More

• Re: First year Subaru experiences [nwbear]

  Written by: ateixeira on Jul 31, 2009 7:20:03 AM

  Any v1.0 is a risk, less so with Subaru, but that's always the case. I had a 1998 Forester, first year, and it was great over the 9 years I had it. So I did it again - and got a 2009, first year for gen 3. So far so good. The 2005 Legacy did have a not-so-great crash test score for side impacts, and then the 2006 was quickly revised ... Read More

• Re: Forester vs. Outback pricing/value [rsholland]

  Written by: saedave on Jul 26, 2009 8:13:10 AM

  The only Outback advantages that I find at all persuasive are quieter ride and bluetooth. The pushbutton parking brake is a negative. I think at time to buy I will even look at a VW R32...direct shift transmission plus quattro. It's great for city tight parking spaces and if only kept for the warranty period not costly to own. :D And my Subaru dealer with the good service department also sells ... Read More

• Re: To get a manual wagon w/moonroof under $30k Subaru wins out [seabrook7039]

  Written by: saedave on Jul 17, 2009 9:40:43 AM

  But the redesigned Outback cabin is the clincher, both with the larger front and back seats areas. And the greater width and length of the cargo area, though slightly smaller for 2010, still exceeds the Forester by a significant amount I believe the passenger space is almost identical. There is one other difference in favor of the Outback (presuming it is as quiet and jolt free as my 2005): The Forester ... Read More

2009 Subaru Forester

• Re: Thanks again for the handy info [debating]

  Written by: occking on May 21, 2009 6:35:29 PM

  Since 2005, during which time I have owned a 05 Outback, 06 Tribeca, 08 Nissan Altima Hybrid, and early March 09 Forester, I have "maxed out" three Subaru cards every year, entitling me to $1500 each year. I am not exaggerating here, I really have earned $6000 through end of 2008, and already $300 in bucks this year. In fact I applied for, and got a 4th Subaru card a few ... Read More

Subaru Forester

• Re: 2005 Forester [texases]

  Written by: bigfrank3 on Nov 4, 2008 8:24:23 AM

  I think if you follow the manual you will be in good shape. The oil and filter changes are the most important, as in any vehicle. I always use the Subaru filter as it is of high quality. I also use Mobil 1 in all my vehicles... as well as the tractor, tiller, and snowblower. Whatever oil you use choose a good one like Penzoil or Castrol. I change oil and ... Read More

Subaru Forester Lease Questions

• Car_man: Chase Lease - Buyout Negotiation??

  Written by: brookotter on Mar 29, 2009 9:54:23 AM

  Hi Car_man and friends... I have a 2005 Forester XT Premium (top of the trim level, leather, sunroof, etc.), 63K miles in good condition (just got an a-ok on the 60K service, minor front bumper ding, but otherwise excellent). I love the car, and am seriously over my 48K mi on my 4-year lease (Subaru/Chase), so have decided I'd rather do the buyout, which is listed $13,200, plus disposition fee. Question ... Read More

Subaru Forester

• Re: 2005 Forester [bigfrank3]

  Written by: texases on Nov 4, 2008 6:45:55 AM

  We've gone and bought a 2007 base Forester. It appears to be in good shape. What might you recommend (besides what's in the manual) to make sure it stays that way? It's our first Subaru.

• Re: 2005 Forester [holiver]

  Written by: bigfrank3 on Nov 3, 2008 8:11:30 AM

  I think it depends more on the individual vehicle, and the care it has received, but we have had 2 01s, an 02, and currently have an 05 Bean and an 06 Premium. The Bean is my wife's and she loves it. The only problem she had was with the moonroof track, and everything but the glass got replaced under warranty. We haven't had a bad Forester yet. My wife's cousin ... Read More

2010 Subaru Forester Changes

• 2009-10 Subaru manual transmission

  Written by: zec on Feb 20, 2009 10:51:51 AM

  Replying to oregonboy, I too want a manual trans. Some of the magazines don't like the manual shifter in Subies. One of the few gripes about the 2009 Forester, it seems. I recall one editor suggesting the short throw shifter option, but that wasn't for the Forester, maybe the WRX. I guess the expectation to match Honda manual shifters might be too much. I drive a 2005 Scion xB manual and ... Read More

• Re: [rengaw]

  Written by: veritasusa on Jan 28, 2009 11:21:51 AM

  You state: "An interesting note that we hear so many complaints about "only" a four speed in the 2009 Forester. But the 2009 RAV4, 2.5L, also has a reworked transmission that Toyota chose to leave a four speed. You don't hear much about that. " This transmission issue is one thing that has bugged me for a couple of years now. I consider it to be sheer bloody-minded thinking on the ... Read More

• Re: 2010 Subaru Forester Changes [DON__FLORIDA]

  Written by: xwesx on Jan 26, 2009 9:24:26 AM

  Not sure about the paint chipping, as I have not had any problems with that on any of my Subaru vehicles. Perhaps there was a formulation change? Something gov't mandated recently? Rattles are a perennial issue. I have yet to ride in a newer Subaru (2005+) that does not have them, yet most of the owners are completely unconcerned about the rattles, even when I point them out. Their response? Something ... Read More

Considering a non-Subaru car; talk me out of it!

• Considering a non-Subaru car; talk me out of it!

  Written by: brc2004 on Jan 1, 2009 2:39:44 PM

  I've had a Subaru Forester for the last 3 years and have been pleased with it. I'm a very short person and the Forester is one of the few cars that has a comfortable seating position for me, and great viewing angles. On the other hand I feel very guilty about owning an SUV, even a small one, because it does use a lot of gas and I am usually driving ... Read More

2009 Subaru Forester

• Re: Would you buy a Subaru Forester again?? [amiller1]

  Written by: saedave on Nov 8, 2008 9:34:25 AM

  I own a 2005 Outback six cylinder which is giving me superb service. But if I were buying today, I would choose the Forester which is shorter for parking yet has more interior room than my Outback...and also gets better fuel economy. The Forester also has about a 2" higher seating position for a better view of the road ahead. I believe the rear hatch opening is also higher which would ... Read More

• Re: Would you buy a Subaru Forester again?? [amiller1]

  Written by: bigfrank3 on Nov 8, 2008 9:31:44 AM

  We currently have 2 Foresters and since 2001 have had 5. These all have been the most reliable and trouble-free vehicles we have owned, and since we have each been driving more than 40 years have owned a lot of vehicles. My wife's first Forester (2001) is still in the family and has continued to be without any issues. My brother has a Forester (2008) as does one of my wife's ... Read More

• SOA sucks!

  Written by: veritasusa on Sep 23, 2008 1:03:17 PM

  I owned a 2005 Forester for a year. It was a pretty good car, except that the seats were rock-hard, the gold fabric interior was impossible to keep clean under any sort of hard use, and one had to go to the LL Bean edition to get self-leveling rear suspension and a hard surfaced load area.. I went back to a Chrysler minivan. I took some interest when the 2009 Forester ... Read More

Subaru Forester: Audio & Entertainment Systems

• 2005 Forester - Radio quit

  Written by: nanceannlvl on Jul 17, 2008 1:04:37 PM

  My DH drove my Subaru last week. He said when he got in, he just turned the radio off. Since then, I can't get it to come on. He tried changing out the fuse, no luck. It is just dead, like it's not getting electricity to it at all. Any recommendations? I generally drive 45 miles at least each way to work, so silence is a little deafening.

Subaru Crew Problems & Solutions

• 2 Foresters, 2 problems.

  Written by: tim3 on Jun 23, 2008 9:58:23 AM

  Greetings, Forester #1: 2004 X 5-speed ~80,000 miles The car lurches or bucks at almost any speed. Sometimes it’s minor and just feels like I abruptly took my foot off the gas pedal for a second. Other times, it feels like it’s going to stall, but it never does. It used to do this right after I filled the tank with gas. If I stopped the car and restarted it, the ... Read More

Subaru Forester: Audio & Entertainment Systems

• Would metallic tint hurt radio reception?

  Written by: georgiaman on Jun 1, 2008 3:43:49 PM

  Hi: I have a 2005 Subaru Forester 2.5X. Everything else on this car is great except that the AC cannot keep up with Georgia summers. So I am planning to get the Windows tinted. But I noticed that the factory-installed radio's antenna is embedded in the rear quarter window. If I use metallic film to tint that window, will it hurt the radio reception? I am looking at Scotchtint FX-HP 35 ... Read More

2009 Subaru Forester

• L.L. Bean Edition

  Written by: madisonsgame on Apr 19, 2008 8:36:07 AM

  I just bought the 2009 L.L. Bean Edition. :) I had a 2001 and 2005 Forester in the past and loved them. I finally decided to get the L.L. Bean edition. I did not get the nav. system (now I wished I had) but the radio sounds great but I would like to enhance it. I have read posts about subwoofers and tweeters. I am not sure how these work. Can ... Read More

Subaru Forester

• Re: Used Subaru Forester 2003 to 2005 - would you recommend it? [automan12]

  Written by: ateixeira on Apr 10, 2008 10:53:55 AM

  Wheel bearings were of a new design for 2003, and have been a lot better. The revised head gaskets arrived in 2002, IIRC. You should be fine there, too. Inspect the head and valve cover gaskets, plus the front and rear main seals for oil leaks, as you should for any used car you shop for, really. Drive in a figure 8 with the windows open and the radio off, listen ... Read More

• Used Subaru Forester 2003 to 2005 - would you recommend it?

  Written by: automan12 on Apr 10, 2008 8:42:27 AM

  Hi, your expert opinion needed. We are considering used Subaru Forester 2003 to 2005, how reliable it is? What are the common problems to expect? Head gasket? Bearings? - please be specific. Which one is better in terms of reliability turbo or non-turbo? Thank you for your help!

Article Comments - 2009 Subaru Forester XT First Drive and Full Test

• Re: New Forester [kdshapiro]

  Written by: tinycadon on Apr 6, 2008 7:05:08 PM

  You can find a lot of Subaru info from this guy's website: http://www.cars101.com/ 2005 Automatic: 1st 3.027, 2nd 1.619, 3rd 1,0, 4th 0.694, rev 2.272, final 4.444 Turbo: 1st 2.785, 2nd 1.545, 3rd 1.0, 4th 0.694, rev 2.272, final 4.444 2009 Automatic: 1st 2.785, 2nd 1.545, 3rd 1.0, 4th 0.694, rev 2.272, final 4.444 Turbo: 1st 2.785, 2nd 1.545, 3rd 1.0, 4th 0.694, rev 2.272, final 4.111

Changes You'd Like To See in the Subaru Forester

• My Two Wishes

  Written by: bayarea_s40 on Apr 1, 2008 4:03:57 PM

  I've had a Forester XT Sport (automatic, with VDC) for a little over a year now. Very reliable, but sometimes it's the little things that get to you: 1) This model has the "high-end" audio system (MP3-capable), but the two front door speakers are simply terrible. When the engine is on, and at normal volume, they vibrate with the panel with such distortion that it is impossible to listen to some ... Read More

2009 Subaru Forester

• Re: will the '10's 5-speed be true nirvana? [p0926]

  Written by: ateixeira on Apr 1, 2008 12:43:50 PM

  Fair enough, let's play... She uses it for Costco runs, so it's easier to load those 15 packs of paper towels and seemingly 1.7 million rolls of TP. Commuting in beltway traffic. Car pooling 2-3 kids. Easy ingress/egress is critical. Must be kid friendly. Leather seats so she can wipe up spills. Automatic for the heavy traffic she gets nowadays. She doesn't want anything too small. I have shown her smaller ... Read More

Subaru Forester Transmission Questions

• Re: Abrupt shifting 4EAT - 2005 Forester X [erics6]

  Written by: xwesx on Feb 11, 2008 11:47:59 AM

  Well, the car holds gears longer until the transmission fluid is up to temperature. It does this in order to warm up faster. This could result in a more abrupt shift, but it is hard to say whether the car has a problem or not without feeling the abruptness. I have never driven a Subaru that has a silky-smooth, imperceptible shift when the transmision is warm, but I would not call ... Read More

2009 Subaru Forester

• I like it ... I'll be buying

  Written by: gouldn on Jan 24, 2008 2:52:11 PM

  I'm a very occasional poster here ... I have an 01 S+ with 128K miles. Other than an unfortunate head gasket replacement at 107K, I have had nothing but good luck with the car. During my ownership, I also bought a 2005 Accord V6 Coupe, and much prefer the Forester ... yes it's slower, but two things really make it work for me: (1) turning radius (2) outstanding visibility. I strongly ... Read More

• Longtime Forester owner weighing in

  Written by: lark6 on Jan 19, 2008 5:25:28 PM

  Hello all, Former frequent poster here. I'm currently on my second Forester. First was a 2000 S with 4EAT; current is a 2005 XT with 4EAT. If my past two purchases are any indication I'd be looking at this car in 2011 (third year of cycle as were the first two). Right now I'm willing to reserve some judgment until I actually see the car in the metal and drive one. ... Read More

Subaru Forester Prices Paid and Buying Experience

• What is the difference between "customer cash" and "cash back" promos?

  Written by: dcdame on Jan 8, 2008 7:14:38 AM

  Can someone please explain the difference (in meaning) between alternative current Subaru promos? Subaru currently offers alternative promotions for Forester buyers - choose (1) "cash back" plus APR incentive or (2) "customer cash" - what's the difference? The "cash back" and "customer cash" amounts offered are the same. Is one for people who finance w/the dealer and one for those who don't or what? If the former, why not just say ... Read More

Subaru Reliability

• Subaru Reliability

  Written by: sibmx on Nov 24, 2007 8:56:33 PM

  I have been doing research for a few months already. Overall, everybody rates Foresters as reliable cars but after reading this forum and http://www.carsurvey.org/model_Subaru_Forester.html I have second thoughts. I am looking for a reliable car on the first place and after reading forums and numerous articles it appears that Subarus got a lot of issues: bearings, head gaskets, leaks, electrical problems..... I know that head gasket and bearing problems are fixed ... Read More

Subaru Forester Prices Paid and Buying Experience

• 2005 forester test drive problem

  Written by: mart2 on Oct 15, 2007 2:38:59 PM

  I am looking at a 2005 Subaru Forester with 7800 miles on it. One owner, appears to be in great condition & the price is right ($15k). However, when I went to test drive it, it didnt start. The salesman said someone might have left a particular switch in the "on" position; he jumped it and it drove great (and they replaced the battery). I would like to purchase it, but ... Read More

Subaru Crew Problems & Solutions

• Window Tinting for Forester

  Written by: georgiaman on Jul 14, 2007 3:43:20 PM

  The Air Conditioner on my 2005 Subaru Forester 2.5X seems to be very weak for the Georgia Sun. I am thinking of getting the windows tinted. I was told if I get a metallic window film, it will interfere with AM radio reception since the radio antenna is embedded in the rear quarter window. Is that true? What kind (Brand, Type) of window tinting film is recommended for this vehicle? Thanks ... Read More

• A/C Problem on Forester

  Written by: georgiaman on Jun 12, 2007 1:29:18 PM

  I have a 2005 Subaru Forester 2.5X. I feel that the air-conditioner on this car is very weak. I have taken it in to 2 dealers at various times. They changed parts, fixed leaks etc., but nothing seems to help. The last dealer finally said that it cools to about 52 deg. F in city driving, and about 49 deg F on the highway, and that is within specs. I find ... Read More

• 2003 Forester with a new Buzz

  Written by: scrappy44 on Feb 5, 2007 5:46:46 PM

  Hi All, My wife and I just bought a 2003 Forester with only 19K miles on it. Not having owned a Subaru before, we're slowly getting used to the quirks and noises. As for the "diesel truck" sound that another poster described when starting cold--we've had two dealers tell us it was "a normal operating condition" caused by changes to the engine from 2002 to 2005 or so. Sounded fishy to ... Read More

• Re: Subaru forester (2006) Catalytic Converters [gaucho1]

  Written by: bhalicks on Jan 4, 2007 4:52:36 PM

  I am the same problem. I have a 2005 legacy. The Check engine light came on two nights ago and the cruise light starting blinking. I am taking it to the Subaru dealer tomorrow for an oil change so I will have them look at it. I am guessing it is electrical. I bought the car in March of 2006. Recently I noticed two things: - Every once in while the ... Read More

Subaru Forester Prices Paid and Buying Experience

• Re: Buying a Forester in AK [daveit]

  Written by: jeffmc on Jan 10, 2007 4:36:29 PM

  Dave, You may want to post over in the 2005+ Legacy/Outback forum, where a fellow from the Fairbanks area just picked up a new Outback Basic. He could probably give you a very good idea how much over invoice is achievable at the Alaska dealerships, or whether it'd be worth it to try the L48. Here's a link to his post: xwesx, "Subaru Legacy/Outback 2005+" #9721, 5 Jan 2007 7:35 pm ... Read More

Subaru Forester

• Re: Sports X and Sports XT available on Subaru website [nowakj66]

  Written by: bayarea_s40 on Dec 24, 2006 8:59:54 PM

  Yeah, I know what you mean about MT and the turbo, but we also have a 2005 Volvo S40 T5 with 6-speed MT (hence my username), and I've enjoyed that thing on the freeway. I doubt the XT Sports with MT would be as nifty to weave thru traffic. Our '99 Forester is also AT, so we're used to it. The additional safety is what I wanted. Plus, I hope the ... Read More

• Re: High-pitched tone after engine shut off [timo43]

  Written by: jh_macdonald on Dec 23, 2006 9:10:49 AM

  I have a 2005 Subaru Forester and I also have a high-pitched whistle sound eminating from the front. I can hear it when the engine is running and it continues for several minutes after the engine is off. If I disconnect the battery the noise stops so I assume it is electrical. I also pulled the fuses one by one and was not able to narrow the noise down to any ... Read More

Subaru Forester Tire/Wheel Questions

• Falcon Ziex ZE512 long-term experience and recommendations

  Written by: eps105 on Dec 17, 2006 9:04:20 AM

  Hi folks. Back on the subject of tires.... It's been a long time since I've posted, and it seems the Subaru forums are much less active now that Edmunds has split everything up for the Forester group. But since I've gotten so much out of these forums, I'm still going to let everyone know my $.02. About 2 years ago, going on the high ratings of Consumer Reports and generally positive ... Read More

Subaru Forester Electrical/Lighting Issues

• Subaru Forester 2006 electrical short

  Written by: delucar on Nov 10, 2006 1:54:51 PM

  Hello I am brand new to this forum--sorry for the length of the post but it's an extremely odd occurrence. I bought a 2006 Subaru Forester X in July of 2005 (brand new, only owner). A couple of months ago we had a fuse short out which my husband replaced with the Subaru spare fuse (yes--it was the correct fuse). Two days ago, we drove the car to work in the ... Read More

Honda CR-V, Toyota RAV4 or Subaru Forester?

• Re: October Demand [varmint]

  Written by: terry92270 on Nov 1, 2006 3:25:04 PM

  Shocked If not for that stupid rear door side-swing arrangement, and the spare on it, I would have purchased the CR-V in 2005 instead of my Forester. CR and others have always given it good reliability ratings. The edge went to Subaru for the safety equipment and CR's top ratings of it. Now I am very pleased with my Subie, but I have to tell you guys, looking at the new ... Read More

Subaru Forester MPG-Real World Numbers

• Re: 2005 Forester X M/T MPG - 4 Month Perioed [kloson123]

  Written by: ateixeira on Oct 24, 2006 12:54:39 PM

  I have a similar chart...here's part of it ('98 Subaru Forester, 5MT): 13-Jan 248.4 10.075 24.65508685 19-Mar 330.4 14.136 23.3729485 27-Mar 229.1 9.214 24.86433688 10-Apr 334.9 13.389 25.01307043 6-May 323 12.744 25.34526051 8-May 217.6 8.299 26.22002651 20-May 207.8 8.657 24.00369643 20-May 282.2 9.999 28.22282228 30-May 270.2 10.161 26.59187088 31-May 280.2 10.1 27.74257426 12-Jun 316.4 12.688 24.9369483 19-Jun 375.2 13.607 27.57404277 26-Jun 293.8 10.96 26.80656934 10-Jul 330.1 13.32 24.78228228 18-Jul 331.1 13.878 ... Read More

• 2005 Forester X M/T MPG - 4 Month Perioed

  Written by: kloson123 on Oct 24, 2006 10:39:33 AM

  In case anyone is interested, here is what I got for my Subaru over a four-month period. The high mileage numbers were mostly highway and the low ones mostly city. Overall, pretty good mileage. Date.............Miles.....Gallons.....MPG....Cumulative MPG 5/15/2006......335.7....13.522......24.8 5/27/2006......268.4....11.954......22.5......23.7 6/17/2006......235.4....10.984......21.4......23.0 6/19/2006......274.3.....9.270......29.6......24.4 6/21/2006......318.2....10.688......29.8......25.4 6/30/2006......273.3....12.210......22.4......24.8 7/14/2006......330.9....13.817......23.9......24.7 7/16/2006......337.1....12.488......27.0......25.0 7/18/2006......299.8....11.662......25.7......25.1 7/18/2006......221.1.....7.571......29.2......25.4 7/18/2006......282.6.....8.656......32.6......25.9 7/20/2006......178.1.....8.394......21.2......25.6 7/21/2006......174.2.....4.883......35.7......25.9 7/21/2006......234.5.....8.479......27.7......26.0 7/21/2006......168.0.....7.449......22.6......25.9 7/21/2006......247.8....10.105......24.5......25.8 8/9/2006........368.7....11.794......31.3......26.1 8/9/2006........264.8.....9.893......26.8......26.2 8/10/2006......334.5....11.500......29.1......26.4 8/10/2006......402.9....12.979......31.0......26.6 8/11/2006......307.8....10.326......29.8......26.8 8/11/2006......187.0.....5.681......32.9......27.0 8/13/2006......342.4....10.546......32.5......27.2 8/13/2006......287.3.....9.832......29.2......27.3 8/17/2006......204.2.....8.365......24.4......27.2 8/18/2006......289.2.....9.820......29.5......27.4 8/21/2006......233.3.....8.516......27.4......27.4 9/17/2006......253.0....11.226......22.5......27.2

Subaru Forester (up to 2005)

• NHTSA complaints

  Written by: dstew1 on Aug 30, 2006 1:59:56 PM

  This was probably my favorite: ON MARCH 20, 2006, THE SYMMETRICAL ALL WHEEL DRIVE SYSTEM OF MY 2005 SUBARU FORRESTER XT FAILED, THE VEHICLE FISHTAILED AND DRIFTED, RESULTING IN A ROLLOVER, AND SEVERE BODILY INJURY. THE VEHICLE WAS SO FLIMSY, IT WAS DISGUSTING. EVERY DOOR AND WINDOW OPENING COLLAPSED, GLASS FLEW EVERYWHERE. THE CEILING COLLAPSED ON THE PASSENGERS' HEADS. THIS IS A DEATH CAR. *NM It's sad that the car was ... Read More

Forester roof racks/kayak carrier

• Re: Forrester roof racks/kayak carrier [saxy]

  Written by: lmn908 on Aug 12, 2006 6:43:33 PM

  I believe that the Subaru OEM kayak rack for 2005 is like the Yakima kayak stacker. (Thule makes a similar device). It is basically an upright pole one attaches to the cross bars to which one secures the kayaks. It is relatively inexpensive and you can use it to secure multiple kayaks, but isn't the easiest way to secure the kayaks, as they have to be balanced on their sides resting ... Read More

• Forrester roof racks/kayak carrier

  Written by: saxy on Aug 9, 2006 7:51:56 AM

  I'm trying to determine what kayak carrier will work satisfactorily with my 2005 Forester. The accessory rack OEM from Subaru is quite affordable but both the specs for the attachments and a good photo of the carrier are sadly lacking on the Subaru parts page. (photo larger than a postage stamp when printed woudl be good). Just wondering if a Subaru owner could comment on the using the carrier offered by ... Read More

Subaru Forester vs Toyota RAV4

• Re: VDC, VSC. Re: Rav 4 Forum [kdshapiro]

  Written by: andrelaplume on Jul 20, 2006 7:05:10 AM

  I keep getting the feeling I am offending folks here. Remember I almost bought the Foretser. For me it was a size and wife issue. After driving each within minutes of each other I realized the cars were now in separate classes and we wanted a larger vehicle. The B9 on the other hand....well I think its better compared with the 2006 RAV than a Lexus or Acura, perhaps not the ... Read More

Subaru Forester (up to 2005)

• 100K Report <>

  Written by: gouldn on Jul 10, 2006 4:32:58 PM

  Hi: I can't keep up with all the posts in the group, but occasionally stop by and report my ownership experience with my 01 Forester S Premium, purchased new in June of 2000. I now have 102,000 miles on the car, and I am very satisified overall with this car. > I have a found a dealer I like that doesn't charge as much as the other dealers around here (SF ... Read More

Subaru Forester vs Toyota RAV4

• crash test comparison

  Written by: luvmbooty on Jun 8, 2006 6:41:11 AM

  Gov. test show they are close except for front passenger for RAV4 scores 4 stars and Forester scores 5. IIHS scores Forester a GOOD rating all around and the 2006 RAV4 only was tested for Frontal test which scores a GOOD rating. 2005 model scored GOOD for side impact and MARGINAL for rear impact. One thing I don't understand is why the Forester doesn't have the side curtain airbags? I noticed ... Read More

• Re: Outback... [andrelaplume]

  Written by: ateixeira on May 12, 2006 7:57:52 AM

  Forester has side airbags for the front passengers, they even extend to protect the head. IIHS have them a Good score and NHTSA 5/5 stars. Legacy/Outback has side curtains, though. Ironically the 2005 model did not do as well. They tweaked the 2006s and now they're an IIHS Gold award winner, basically top 10 safest cars they've tested. OB has heated seats as standard, pretty cool. Heated mirrors, too. Even wiper ... Read More

Subaru Forester

• 2006 Throttle Response?

  Written by: jsr on May 10, 2006 9:26:10 AM

  I have a new (600 miles) Forester XT 5 speed, and I've noticed something that MAY be related to the electronic throttle. Trying to maintain a constant but low speed in 1st or 2nd -- say, in a parking lot, driving around in a shopping center with speed bumps and traffic, or approaching a red light from a ways back -- the car tends to buck a bit, as though the ... Read More

Subaru Crew Problems & Solutions

• Re: compact spare [joeb24]

  Written by: ateixeira on May 10, 2006 6:46:24 AM

  Generally, the rule is you want to keep the tire circumference within about 1/4" of each other. So you can have only minor differences in tread wear. If you need one new tire with 10k miles on the other 3, you're probably OK. But if you have 40k miles and slash one tire, you'll need to get 4 new ones. But by 40k, the rubber is drying out and starting to ... Read More

• Re: Forester Piston Slap [mb789]

  Written by: b10609 on Apr 14, 2006 12:45:41 PM

  Even though we've had the piston replacement done on our 2003 Forester I wouldn't hesitate to recommend one. The latest engines are revised and the current 2.5L is better and more powerful to boot. My daughter drives an 2005 2.5L Impreza and the motor is very quiet and smooth.The Forester AWD with automatic is excellent and if you drive on wet or/snowy roads there are few AWD's better at any price. ... Read More

Subaru Forester Prices Paid and Buying Experience

• Finally bought the XT Limited!

  Written by: kumari on Mar 24, 2006 10:22:11 PM

  Hi all, Well, I finally bit the bullet and bought the Forester XT Limited this evening. Here's the deal: $25,349.00 for an automatic with the only addition being the rear bumper cover. Got the steel grey metallic. Also, got free 3000 and 7500 service and the option to purchase the top of the line 7 year warranty for 50% off in three years when the 36 month warranty expires (by then ... Read More

Subaru Forester

• Re: A little help here!!!

  Written by: occking on Feb 24, 2006 6:17:19 PM

  I presently own a 2.5i ltd outback, have had it 14 months now, almost 37k & very pleased with it. Want to trade in my wife's 97 Isuzu (a Honda clone) & considering the Foresters. I can't believe how peppier the 173 hp 4 is compared to the 168 in my Outback. But I suspect the ride not as "car like" as Outback. I can get the Forester X Limited with ... Read More

Subaru Forester Prices Paid and Buying Experience

• Re: 2000 off MSRP for Premium Package? [kumari]

  Written by: raybear on Feb 8, 2006 4:20:33 AM

  No extras, we're talking XT Limited Automatic here, right? The invoice gets squished together but here it is: Subaru of New England Inc. Vehicle Detail Invoice 2/8/2006 739 AM Dealer Number: 010-000 Subaru xxxxxxxx xxx xxxxx xxx xxxxx xxxxxx xxxx Ship / Allocation: 260/1031 Load Number: 9732 Massachusetts\Connecticut - OK Delivery Date: 12/28/2005 Vehicle Description Vehicle Identification Number: JF1-SG696X 6H723229 Model Code: 6FL Model Description: 2006 Forester XT 4EAT 2.5 Turbo ... Read More

• 2005 Bean

  Written by: lumber1 on Feb 5, 2006 5:09:08 PM

  I am looking, searching the internet for a 2005 used Subaru Forester LL BEAN, hard to come by but what I want, the Premium Package would be cheaper but I just favor the beans looks! I did test drive a 2003 but waiting for a newer one with less miles, after months of researching and comparing, fitzmall's price (read on here to check there prices out)$22,995 (10500mi) & dealers around my ... Read More