BEST CARS
Consumers' Top Rated Consumers' Top Rated
Consumers' Most Wanted Consumers' Most Wanted
Lowest True Cost to Own Lowest True Cost to Own
Used Car Best Bets Used Car Best Bets
Most Popular Vehicles
Top 10 Lists

MORE CAR REVIEWS
  Editors' Reviews
  Road Tests

USEFUL TOOLS
E-mail this Page to a Friend


Editors' Most Wanted
Editors' Most Wanted Vehicles for 2004

Most Wanted Convertible Over $45,000

Mercedes-Benz SL500 Winner: Mercedes-Benz SL-Class

Simply put, the SL is the best of all worlds — a sports car with tight handling when you feel so inspired and a luxurious and supple grand tourer when you're facing a 500-mile interstate trip. And then there's the graceful folding hardtop that lets the SL go from sleek coupe to sexy convertible in 16 seconds flat. And let's not forget the cooled seats, surprisingly spacious trunk and the veritable alphabet soup's worth of safety systems. If you can't get your jollies from 302 horsepower, then you've got a choice of two more speedsters in the SL family, each putting out nearly 500 horses — the SL55 AMG with its supercharged V8 or the SL600 that comes packing a twin-turbo V12 that likes to cruise at triple-digit speeds. A car with so few faults and such graceful styling is a winner in our book.


Honorable Mention: Cadillac XLR

A spiritual successor to Cadillac's Allante two-seat roadster of 1987-1993, the XLR proves that sometimes things really are better the second time around. Now with a retractable hardtop versus the Allante's fussy rag top, the XLR is something the Allante wasn't: a legitimate competitor to the Mercedes SL500. In terms of power, handling and cockpit accommodations, the two are virtually deadlocked. Only editorial dissention over the XLR's styling prevented it from grabbing the top spot in this category.


Advertisement

Advertisement