2002 Midsize SUV Comparison Test

(Enlarge photo)
Picturesque Sedona, Ariz., served as the backdrop for this year's SUV shootout. (Photo by Scott Jacobs)


NAVIGATION
Introduction
Fifth Place
Fourth Place
Third Place
Second Place
First Place
Conclusion
Editors' Evaluations
Specifications and Performance
Top 10 Features
Consumer Commentary
Final Rankings and Scoring Explanation

USEFUL TOOLS

Road Test: Comparison Test

2002 Midsize SUVs Comparison Test
Midsize Mudslingers

By Ed Hellwig, Lead Senior Editor
Date posted: 04-04-2002

Hard to believe, but it's been almost 20 years since the introduction of the SUV as we now know it (remember the S-10 Blazer?). But unlike the pint-size two-door that started it all, today's sport-utes boast V8 engines, room for seven, top-of-the-line safety systems — even DVD entertainment systems. Despite their much-maligned reputation as road hogs and gas guzzlers, they're as popular as ever, and they have the sales numbers to prove it.

Nearly every major manufacturer produces some form of sport-utility vehicle, from the smallest mini-utes right on up to the gargantuan Hummer, but the midsize four-doors remain the out-and-out sales leaders by a wide margin. Their blend of size, power and safety has turned them into the family vehicle of the 21st century, but with so many different models to choose from, it can be a nightmare trying to decide which vehicle is just the right one for your particular needs.

We conducted an extensive eight-vehicle comparison test just two years ago, with the Nissan Pathfinder coming out on top. But with several strong new challengers now available, we considered it high time for another sport-ute showdown to see just how well the newcomers compete. Despite the introduction of numerous new crossover sport-utility vehicles, we stuck with more traditional midsize SUVs that offer dual-range transfer cases and real off-road ability.

There would be only five competitors this time. The Nissan Pathfinder comes in virtually unchanged from the previous test, as it was a freshly updated model at that time. Ford's Explorer and Chevrolet's TrailBlazer are both all new for 2002, so they were obvious choices. Mitsubishi released its completely revamped Montero in 2001, so it got the nod as well. We rounded out our fivesome with the Dodge Durango. It hasn't undergone a full redesign since the last test, but numerous upgrades and a strong second place finish the last time around made it a logical choice.

To conduct our evaluations, we trekked out to scenic Sedona, Ariz., a trip that included long stretches of highway, snow-covered mountain trails and mud-caked fire roads. When it was all said and done, we tallied up the scores and declared a winner. So if you want to know what we think is the best midsize SUV currently on the market, just keep on clicking and we'll tell you everything you need to know.

Advertisement