Welcome,  


NAVIGATION
Introduction
Ninth Place
Eighth Place
Seventh Place
Sixth Place
Fifth Place
Third Place (Tie)
Third Place (Tie)
Second Place
First Place
Conclusion
Personal Picks and Recommendations
Evaluation: Drive
Evaluation: Ride
Evaluation: Design
Evaluation: Space
Top 10 Features
Dimensions
Engines and Transmissions
Performance Testing
Suspension
Warranty Information
Consumer Commentary
Final Rankings
Scoring Explanation

USEFUL TOOLS
E-mail this Page to a Friend


Comparison Tests

2001 Entry Level Luxury Sport Sedans Comparison Test
Evaluation - Drive
By Liz Kim
Date Posted 07-03-2001

Engine
Vehicle Score Ranking
BMW 330i 96 1
Lexus IS 300 91 2
Acura TL Type-S 89 3
Mercedes-Benz C320 88 4
Infiniti I30t 80 5 (t)
Lincoln LS V8 80 5 (t)
Volvo S60 77 7
Cadillac Catera Sport 74 8
Mazda Millenia S 68 9

Transmission
Vehicle Score Ranking
BMW 330i 93 1
Lexus IS 300 84 2
Acura TL Type-S 83 3
Mercedes-Benz C320 76 4
Cadillac Catera Sport 73 5
Infiniti I30t 71 6
Volvo S60 70 7
Mazda Millenia S 68 8
Lincoln LS V8 67 9

Braking
Vehicle Score Ranking
Lexus IS 300 91 1
BMW 330i 89 2
Mercedes-Benz C320 81 3
Acura TL Type-S 79 4
Volvo S60 78 5 (t)
Mazda Millenia S 78 5 (t)
Cadillac Catera Sport 77 7
Infiniti I30t 76 8
Lincoln LS V8 69 9

Suspension
Vehicle Score Ranking
BMW 330i 92 1
Lexus IS 300 89 2
Acura TL Type-S 79 3
Mercedes-Benz C320 78 4
Lincoln LS V8 77 5
Cadillac Catera Sport 75 6
Mazda Millenia S 72 7
Volvo S60 68 8
Infiniti I30t 58 9

Tire
Vehicle Score Ranking
BMW 330i 91 1 (t)
Lexus IS 300 91 1 (t)
Cadillac Catera Sport 85 3
Mercedes-Benz C320 81 4
Infiniti I30t 78 5
Acura TL Type-S 77 6 (t)
Lincoln LS V8 77 6 (t)
Mazda Millenia S 77 6 (t)
Volvo S60 76 9

Steering
Vehicle Score Ranking
Acura TL Type-S 95 1
Lexus IS 300 93 2
Cadillac Catera Sport 81 3
BMW 330i 77 4 (t)
Lincoln LS V8 77 4 (t)
Mercedes-Benz C320 77 4 (t)
Mazda Millenia S 72 7
Infiniti I30t 67 8
Volvo S60 56 9

Fun to Drive
Vehicle Score Ranking
Lexus IS 300 96 1
BMW 330i 93 2
Acura TL Type-S 79 3
Mercedes-Benz C320 74 4
Cadillac Catera Sport 71 5 (t)
Lincoln LS V8 71 5 (t)
Mazda Millenia S 67 7
Volvo S60 66 8
Infiniti I30t 54 9