
|
|
Comparison Tests
2000 Family Car Comparison Test
First Place - 2000 Volkswagen Passat
By Scott Mead
Date Posted 12-19-2000
Introduction
To say that the Volkswagen Passat impressed us would
be a gross understatement. In nearly every category,
the Passat finished in the win, place or show position.
Yeah, we were suckers for the crisp-edged styling,
communicative handling and incredible fit and finish.
In our performance trials, the Passat never fell below
third in any category. Adding to our enthusiasm was
the fact that the Passat comes with a standard five-speed
manual transmission, which would have cut $1,075 from
the price tag of our automatic-equipped test car.
Price didn't seem to affect the Passat in our standings.
As most expensive of the test at $29,295, our Passat
GLX was last in terms of price point and value, but
the VW proved that it was worth every penny ... and
more.
Background and Our Test Vehicle The Passat struggled after its introduction in
early 1989, taking over the place in VW's lineup formerly
held by the Quantum (previously the Dasher). But the
struggle turned to success with the unveiling of the
VR6 powered GLX model in 1994. The Passat easily handles
a full load of cargo and occupants in coddling comfort,
and unlike our other test cars, the Passat exuded
pure luxury. Throughout our week with the car, the
keys to the Passat were sought by all and became a
precious commodity.
Our car came with the optional Tiptronic five-speed
automatic transmission, which shifted as smooth as
silk when in "D" and changed gears smartly
when revved in Tiptronic manual mode. At night, our
editors were treated to a way-cool purple/red instrument
cluster, which minimized eye fatigue and looked great
to boot.
Exterior Design Make no bones about it; the styling of the Passat
is simple, stunning and very European. Many an editor
stated that the uncluttered design was clean and attractive,
proving that a vehicle doesn't need body cladding
to look good.
From the subtle wheel well arches to the wrap-around
body accents, the Passat has luxury written all over
it. Coupled with a chiseled stance and angular lines,
the Passat let's everyone know that this is not your
average family sedan.
One of the first things we noticed was the nearly
perfect fit and finish of the Passat's bodywork with
excellent attention to detail, even in the paint finish,
which looked as though it had been color-sanded and
buffed to a maximum sheen something none of
the other vehicles we tested exhibited.
Interior Features, Control, Materials and Design Perfect fit and finish didn't end on the outside.
It was carried in full to the Passat's interior with
perfectly stitched leather and highly polished walnut
accents. Try as we might, it was very difficult to
find anything wrong with the Passat's cabin.
Driver ergonomics were on par with BMW and Mercedes-Benz,
with a lot of thought given to placement of controls.
Unfortunately, in typical German fashion, nearly every
button was labeled with Euro-style hieroglyphics,
making it difficult to determine what the control
was for. We did like the typical authoritative Bosch
"tick" when a switch was depressed. Our
one major complaint was with the size of the Monsoon
stereo controls, which were on the small side and
hard to operate without taking your eyes off of the
road.
Within the Passat, driver and passenger are treated
to a pair of the best bucket seats in the industry.
Fitted with adjustable lumbar support and heaters,
we had little doubt that we'd feel refreshed after
emerging from a cross-country drive. Add in the tilt/telescoping
steering wheel, and there's no way anyone cannot find
a perfect driving position.
Rear passengers will enjoy a couch that offers excellent
lumbar support, a perfect rake angle and adjustable
headrests for all three passengers. Need room? Not
a problem. The rear of the Passat can easily swallow
six-foot-plus gents with ease while still providing
a ton of head-, leg- and foot room ... so long as
it's only two. Third passengers in the rear will have
to straddle the transmission tunnel and console that
protrudes into the rear cabin's floor area.
The Passat's interior is richly appointed: it looks
and feels more like a fine hotel than a family sedan.
Leather is everywhere, as well as genuine wood trim
and brushed aluminum accents. Amazingly, Volkswagen
has been able to fully duplicate the grain of the
leather seating surfaces into the soft-touch dash
a feat we wish all manufacturers could master.
Engine and Transmission Direct from the Autobahn, the Passat's 2.8-liter,
30-valve V6 is a smooth operator. The 190-horsepower
powerplant has absolutely no qualms pulling from idle
to redline with an eerily quiet, but never-ending
twist to the front wheels.
The Passat placed second in zero-to-60 times with
a 7.7-second run, and blasted the quarter mile in
16 seconds flat at 88.9 mph. Our team further praised
the mid-rpm torque curve and seamless power delivery,
but wished there was more low-end grunt to be had.
Backed by the optional electronically controlled,
five-speed Tiptronic automatic, shifts were clean
and crisp in "D," with only a light amount
of noticeable hesitation when downshifting. Slip the
shift lever to the Tiptronic mode and the world is
your oyster, with the tranny shifting on command at
the flick of a fingertip. The Tip's gear ratios are
perfectly matched to suit the powerplant's torque
band, shifting right at redline and bringing the engine
back to the base of the torque band for another trip
around the tach.
Dodge boys, check it out. This is how it's done.
As expected, the Passat's engine and transmission
came out on top during our editor's road test evaluations,
leaving us eager to enjoy another stint behind the
wheel.
Suspension, Ride and Handling Typical of German sedans, the Passat exhibits
sublime road manners with just the right amount of
compliance, while never jolting the cabin. But unlike
BMW, the Passat's suspension is a bit more supple
to handle the irregularities found in highway driving
and it lacks the progressive spring rates that make
driving a BMW so much fun.
On the open road, we felt as though we could drive
forever, the Passat's suspension informing us of every
ripple in the road. Not to the point that the ride
was uncomfortable, but rather to keep us informed
of what was happening under the Michelin tires. In
the canyons, we were disappointed to find that the
springs were not up to the task of properly transferring
weight when needed, relying instead on shock rebound
valving to do the work.
Steering response was excellent, communicating just
enough road feel to indicate what was happening underfoot,
without jolting the steering wheel when running over
potholes. With just the right amount of steering "heft,"
the Passat is a true point-and-shoot car stiff
enough to feel sporty, yet responsive enough to be
fun -- though we wished the steering response was
a little lighter and tossable like the Mitsubishi.
Conclusion Ahhh... the Passat. This is the car that stole
nearly every editor's heart, enough so that seven
of nine editors listed the Passat as their number
one personal pick.
Did the Passat have an advantage? Well, yes and no.
It was clearly the most expensive of the cars we tested,
which meant it failed miserably in the 20-percent
of the final tally relating to as-tested value. But
the Passat overcame in the performance, handling and
creature comfort arenas. This is truly an outstanding
vehicle.
Editors' Comments
No other car on this test came close to the driving
experience I had while strapped into the Passat. Its
engine had great power at all speeds, but especially
during mid-range freeway cruising. The exterior speaks
Volkswagen and nothing else, but since I've never
gotten into one, I was pleasantly surprised with the
interior ... and the seats are fantastically firm
and adjustable. Get me a lease agreement! Erin
Riches
I caught myself on more than one occasion calling
the Passat a Jetta by mistake. But then I realized
that my feelings about the Passat are very similar
to those I have for the Jetta. Both cars have fabulous
interiors for their class. Both cars have plenty of
useful features and nice touches. Both cars have ...
price tags that are thousands of dollars more than
the competition. Oops! My advice is this: If your
budget allows it, purchase a Passat you'll
dig it. But if you can only afford an Accord or Taurus,
then the Passat isn't worth the stretch. Brent
Romans
Stereo Evaluation - 2000 Volkswagen Passat
|
|