
|
|
Comparison Tests
2000 Family Car Comparison Test
Second Place - 2000 Honda Accord
By Scott Mead
Date Posted 12-19-2000
Introduction
Throughout our evaluations, our test team continually
remarked on the quality of workmanship found within
this sixth-generation Accord. All exterior panel gaps
were uniform, the interior pieces were precision fit
and nary a squeak or rattle could be heard. But what
we did find and what has been common throughout
the Accord's existence is that the Accord doesn't
have a real "smoking gun," meaning that
there's not a single aspect of the vehicle that stands
out as fabulous. The interior: great, but not perfect.
Powertrain: great, but not perfect. Execution: great,
but not perfect ... and the list goes on and on.
Despite this, the Accord's strength is it's consistent
greatness, losing to the Passat by mere tenths of
a point. But while the Accord has spent its fair share
of time at the top of the family sedan mountain, it
has some serious competition again in 2000 from Ford
and Nissan. But enough about those other vehicles,
let's talk about the Honda.
Background and Our Test Vehicle
When Honda introduced the Accord in 1976 (selling
a mere 18,643 units), little did they realize that
in a mere 14 years they would have a bestseller on
their hands, with over 417,000 Accords leaving dealer
lots. The Accord has come a long way since then, vastly
improved in comfort, safety, design and ride quality.
But one aspect has remained paramount throughout the
Accord's life: quality.
That essence of quality was reflected in our editors'
opinions as the Accord ranked first in build quality
during evaluations of our 2000 tester. For 2000, the
Accord raises the safety bar with the EX's new standard
advanced side-airbag system, which is capable of deactivating
the passenger's side airbag if sensors determine that
the passenger is too small or out of position.
In our 1998 test, the LX version of the Accord came
out on top. For 2000, we invited Honda back, this
time with a well-equipped, top-of-the-line EX model.
Exterior Design
Vanilla. That's about the best way to sum up the
styling of the 2000 Accord. The Accord is one of the
cleanest designs on the road today, but there's nothing
really special about it. Last redesigned in 1998,
the 2000 model is left unchanged. But, like the timeless
design of the Porsche 356 Speedster and DeTomaso Pantera,
give the Accord five years to age and it'll look as
fresh as it does today.
So why did the Accord rank first in exterior design?
Because it is a dull and boring motif that is also
as beautiful and as refined as the rest of the vehicle.
As far as we're concerned, a family sedan shouldn't
be designed on the cutting edge, as it will see a
lifespan far greater that the average sports or performance
car. Ten years later, the Accord will have weathered
the winds of change something we could never
bring ourselves to say about the Impala.
Interior Features, Controls, Materials and Design
Like the five generations before it, the interior
of the 2000 Accord is a mix of straightforward styling
and excellent functionality. Ergonomically, the Accord
falls just shy of perfection with the lack of a telescoping
steering wheel. Aside from that very minor gripe,
the Accord is a vehicle we would have no qualms about
jumping into for a cross-country trip. Although it
was barely beaten out by the Passat for interior execution,
it was still praised as an excellent package.
Up front, dual leather-lined buckets provide adequate
lumbar, lateral and thigh support, but most of us
were disappointed with the driver's eight-way power
seat with adjustable lumbar the positioning
of the lumbar pad was fit to the mid-back area instead
of closer to the bottom of the spine where it's really
needed.
In typical Honda fashion, controls are slick black
plastic with a positive feel and located within easy
reach of the driver, with the exception of the fan
speed knob for the climate control you literally
have to stretch across the dash to reach it. We also
would like Honda to rethink the design for switching
the airflow, which is accomplished by repeatedly depressing
a single button. We found ourselves taking our eyes
off the road to look at the LCD display to be sure
we had activated the defroster and not the floor vents.
Rear passengers will find one of the most comfortable
couches in the industry, which has just the right
amount of rake, lumbar and thigh support. We wouldn't
hesitate to get in the back seat for 200-plus miles,
so long as there were only two passengers. Add a third
and quarters become uncomfortable.
Materials are first rate and, unlike in the Impala,
the leather looks and feels like real animal hide.
Try as we might, we couldn't find a seam out of place,
an exposed screw head or a rough edge on any plastic
trim.
Engine and Transmission
The Accord EX V6 doesn't fall into the vanilla
category with regard to the vehicle's powertrain.
Motivated by a 200-horsepower, 3.0-liter VTEC V6,
the Accord idles smooth as silk, yet provides seamless
power delivery throughout the rpm band. Though not
as torquey as the Passat or the Saturn, it does pull
hard, posting a zero to 60 time of 7.9 seconds
third best in our tests.
Transferring the power to the drive wheels is an electronically
controlled, four-speed automatic transmission that
seemed to be indecisive at times. Jab the throttle
at 45 mph and the tranny hesitates as it shifts to
third, then to second and then slams back into third.
Alas, we've found one item that Honda could still
refine.
Suspension, Ride and Handling
"Taut," "nimble" and "flaccid"
were the most-often heard comments when our editors
referred to the handling characteristics of the Accord.
With its double wishbone/multilink suspension, the
Accord was quite nimble in parking lots and around
town. On the highway, the EX's harsh shock valving
made the Accord a little too taut for our liking
especially on long drives.
Push the Accord in the twisties and the soft springs
become apparent with flaccid body lean and a skitterish
rear end so much so that the Accord finished
dead last in the slalom portion of our performance
evaluations. We were again reminded that this is Honda's
family car, meant to take you from point A to point
B in comfort, not to use on the racetrack on the weekends.
Conclusion
While the Accord isn't the spiciest vehicle in
our test, it is the most "user friendly."
Combine Honda's excellent reputation for reliability
and resale value, and it's no wonder the Accord has
been a bestseller. Our editors were just as impressed.
In fact, the Accord lost to the Passat by just four-tenths
of a point that's how close the competition
was. But while Germany's finest may have nudged the
Accord from our number-one spot, the Accord outsells
the Passat by a factor of nearly 17 to one.
Editors' Comments
Here's the thing about the Accord. The styling
will age well. People who buy them do so because they
want them they aren't settling for something
else. As such, the cars tend to be better maintained
by more conscientious owners. Thus, these well-engineered
Accords last a long time. They have great resale value.
Accord is a known entity. It's a comfort zone. You're
not gonna talk an Accord owner into an Impala on the
next time out, and the less time GM spends on refining
their vehicles, the more Accord owners there will
be. Christian Wardlaw.
If you can call your significant other the Accord
of boyfriends, you'd be pretty well off. This car
does everything well. No, it doesn't give you any
thrills in terms of driving experience, but neither
will it give you a shock with any unpredictability.
No, the design isn't avant garde, or anything you
might deem gorgeous, but it won't look too dated 12
years from now when you've got 200,000 miles on it
and it's still running strong. Liz Kim
Stereo Evaluation - 2000 Honda Accord
|
|