
|
|
Comparison Tests
2000 Family Car Comparison Test
Fifth Place - 2000 Dodge Intrepid ES
By Scott Mead
Date Posted 12-19-2000
Introduction
You can't deny it, the Intrepid is a big car. It looks
big, it seats five in relative comfort, yet surprisingly,
it doesn't drive like a large car. Dodge has packed
a host of standard features into the Intrepid, which
adds to the value of the vehicle, but also to the
$26,480 sticker. So how did this big boy do against
the rest of the family-sedan clan?
Background and Our Test Vehicle When Lee Iacocca introduced the LH series (the
Dodge Intrepid, Eagle Vision and Chrysler Concorde)
just before his retirement in 1992, the replacement
for the aging K-Car platform boasted a revolutionary
concept that would soon take America by storm
cab-forward design.
With its expansive interior, appreciable cargo-carrying
capacity and cutting-edge styling, the LH-series soon
brought about the second rebirth of Chrysler Corporation.
Unfortunately, the cars were plagued by poor quality
control and reliability problems, which resulted in
a rash of lemon-lawsuits and lousy resale values.
Eight years and one major makeover later, the Intrepid
still evokes a love/hate relationship. Seven of our
nine editors loved the shape of the Intrepid, the
other two wouldn't be caught driving it around town.
Nearly all said they enjoyed the low rpm torque from
the powertrain, and build issues have been solved
(our long-term Intrepid has one of the thinnest service
files we've ever seen), so the Intrepid ranked right
in the middle of the pack.
Our ES test vehicle came loaded to the gills with
automatic temperature control, HomeLink transmitter,
nine-speaker Infinity sound system with in-dash CD
changer, leather-trimmed upholstery, traction control
and a full-sized spare tire. And while the ES will
take a sizeable chunk out of your back pocket, our
fifth-place finisher delivers a lot of bang for the
buck.
Exterior Design To say that the Intrepid is unique would be a
gross understatement. With its cab-forward design
and gracefully sweeping lines, the Intrepid is a combination
of boldness and sexy good looks, an appearance which
is emphasized by the large greenhouse and expansive
windows. On the downside are the oversized B- and
C-pillars, which cut into the rearward view, although
the back window is huge compared to that of the Taurus
or Intrigue.
The Intrepid continues with the previous model's theme
of gently rounded bodylines, sloping front and high
tail, and it is freshened with standard 16-inch wheels
and five new colors for 2000.
Interior Features, Controls, Materials and Design The sporty theme of the Intrepid's exterior is
carried through to its interior with a clean cockpit-style
layout and sweeping dash. Driver and passenger seats
feature deep buckets with adjustable lumbar support
and eight power adjustments, which makes finding a
comfortable driving or riding position a breeze.
The seating surfaces were more like vinyl than leather,
and we were disappointed to see that Chrysler still
hasn't addressed the mismatched grain pattern on its
plastic parts an item on which our stripped
Taurus earned high scores.
Controls fall within fingertip reach, with good soft-touch
switchgear and decent labeling, although the cruise
controls on the steering wheel weren't illuminated
at night, making setting the cruise a difficult chore.
We were disappointed with the small size of the stereo
buttons and the climate controls, which forced us
to take our eyes from the road to change radio stations
or adjust HVAC venting.
Dual pop-out cup holders are housed in the shift console,
which when extended, interfere with the operation
of the AutoStick transmission and fully cover the
traction control switch, making activation/deactivation
impossible.
The cheapness flows into the back seat, with exposed
headliner glue by the rear window and fixed rather
than adjustable air vents in the rear console. The
back seat gives good thigh support and leg- and foot
room is abundant. Of the nine cars we tested, the
Intrepid was the most comfortable for three adults,
but we still wouldn't recommend putting that many
fishing buddies back there for an extended period
of time.
Two large cup holders are housed in the center pull-down
armrest, and parents will appreciate the child safety
seat anchor points.
Engine and Transmission With the standard 3.2-liter, 24-valve V6 putting
out 202 horsepower, but lugging 3489 pounds, the Intrepid
was eighth fastest from zero to 60 at a still respectable
8.4 seconds.
During cold starts, we were a little concerned by
the loud valve-knocking and excessive vibration, but
after a few minutes the engine smoothed out. At freeway
speeds, the engine was as slick as fine Persian silk.
Nail the throttle and the electronically controlled
four-speed transmission kicks down effortlessly, accompanied
with an intrusive roar of engine noise.
Dodge includes the AutoStick transaxle on the ES,
which we found to be a neat gimmick, but wholly lacking
the true responsiveness of a manual transmission.
In AutoStick mode, shifts were weak and subdued, with
a significant amount of time between driver input
and transmission reaction. During downshifts, the
tranny had a tendency to "lurch" into gear,
which threw occupants forward like rag dolls.
Suspension, Ride and Handling We were pleasantly surprised by the Intrepid's
four-wheel, independent suspension package, which
hunkered down in the twisties without breaking a sweat,
and cruised on the highway like an old Chrysler 300,
floating over every bump in the road. Even in wet
weather, the Intrepid was very confidence-inspiring
to drive, moving one editor to say, "The Intrepid's
suspension is firmer and more responsive to road conditions
than I would have expected for such a large car."
Caught on a tight canyon road during a deluge of rain,
the Intrepid remained a steady player on the slick
pavement, transmitting the proper amount of road feel
through the wheel and keeping the driver apprised
of what was happening underfoot.
On the test track, the Intrepid's size came into play
during slalom testing as our road test editor noted
"The Intrepid feels big, but it doesn't throw
its weight around like the Impala. As you progress
down the course, the car becomes loose, but it remains
very predictable."
Conclusion The Intrepid is a full-size vehicle with a full-size
interior and plenty of room to stretch out on a long
trip. And while Dodge has addressed a plethora of
quality control concerns over the years, overall execution
still leaves something to be desired. If space is
your primary concern, the Intrepid is the right car.
If quality of workmanship is a priority, you would
behoove yourself to look farther up the chain to the
Passat or Accord.
Editors' Comments The Intrepid is like L.A. Laker Shaquille O'Neal:
A big body that can move just as fast as everybody
else. The Taurus and Intrepid are similar in size,
but the Intrepid felt much smaller when driving it.
Visibility is poor, but I admire the way Dodge balanced
ride quality and handling ability. Nice back seat
too. Some people complained about the dark colored
interior, but I feel it actually adds to the car's
personality. Brent Romans
Never would I have thought that a car with the body
of a squished whale could be fun to drive. And the
Intrepid really is. You'll easily and smoothly keep
up with the Passats and Maximas. But the Intrepid
does not offer a bit of the refinement of the Passat.
Its engine is noisy, and its brakes work extremely
well, but they'll never let you know about it. Although
the Intrepid handles well and has relatively tight
steering, I felt more confident driving any of the
smaller, seemingly more maneuverable cars in the group.
Erin Riches
Stereo Evaluation - 2000 Dodge Intrepid ES
|
|