If you want a car that has universally been loved for its handling prowess, especially for cars under $100k, and you want a unique vehicle (the only rotary engine available in a modern car, "freestyle" doors that offer easier rear stea access while avoiding ridiculously long coupe doors, 9000 rpm redline, non-vanilla looks, etc), then the RX-8 (now only available as used) is an excellent option. I got my R3 new for less than what Insideline paid for their FR-S, so the value factor is excellent too. I drive the R3 on a daily basis, except when there is salt/snow on the road. I swapped out the OEM summer tires, and the handling is still great. Mileage is not a problem for my 22-mi round trip.
Handling, surprising amounts of rear seat room (fits two carseats) ... did I mention handling?
If you are a true enthusiast, the RX-8 R3 is for you; I drove the usual suspects- 370Z, G37s, 335i, all are great cars
However, the way this car comes together, the hand-in-glove feel you get, the intoxicating sound, and the perfect steering and shifter, and firm yet comfortable suspension tuning make this car truly special.
You have to know how to drive to let this car's brilliance shine through-
there is nothing like it.
Drove it through the Tail of the Dragon (US 129) and the car is made for it; StIs couldn't keep up, it is sheer brilliance when driven hard.
perfect steering, impeccable handling.
intoxicating sound and smoothness of the rotary
unique engineering and design
also practical with reasonably roomy trunk and rear seats
well-built and unique interior
decent Bose sound
worldwide fanbase on-line
needs infotainment update- especially for the R3 version-
of course fuel economy isn't great, but this is to be expected, its a rotary sports car
throatier exhaust sound at idle
higher-quality plastics in some parts of interior