Traded an '04 Ultra Classic and haven't looked back.
The MX5 is a 2-dr/4wh replacement.
It has all of the thrill of driving with the wind without having to worry about the weather.
Top up/top down takes a few seconds.
I have the Gr Touring with 7-spkr Bose system.
Sound is great all the time.
Cloth brown top with 6-spd manual.
This car is by far the most fun vehicle i have driven.
Past vehicles include Audi A6 & A4 Cab.
I do wish there was some better answer for spare than Fix a Flat and run flat tires.
Mileage has been 28 MPG combined.
All in all it is hard to imagine a replacement for the HD but this car is IT.
Decide on the top up/down when you get in the car.
Ease of top operation;
Bose 7-spkr system;
Figure out something more than run flat or fix a flat for spare.