This is my first Jeep. I have had it for almost a month now and have close to 1000 miles on it with no problems. I have taken it off road several times already and it has performed well on all counts. I have a stock Wrangler and it still overcomes mud and hills with ease. It is a relatively comfortable ride.
The exterior of course, absolutely classic.
The gas mileage is absolutely terrible! I knew this when I bought it so I'm not sure how valid a complaint it is, but it can get to be very expensive, especially in San Diego where I live.