Fuel-Sipper Smackdown 4: Which Car Gets the Best Fuel Economy?
The Chevy Volt Battles 4 Fuel-Efficient Cars
"I want a car with good fuel economy."
We hear that a lot, but what exactly constitutes good fuel economy? It would be easy to simply look at the EPA mpg ratings on a new car's window sticker, but what sort of mpg numbers can you expect in the real world? And what happens when you factor in the cost of fuel — gasoline, diesel and now electricity? This test seeks to answer those questions.
Thankfully, there are not only a lot more fuel-efficient cars these days but also more fuel-efficient cars you wouldn't mind driving. When we did the first Fuel-Sipper Smackdown four years ago, there were no diesel-powered cars on sale, the wretched Smart Fortwo was the only gas-powered car with hypermiling capability and the Prius was the only serious hybrid. Back then, it seemed as if the only vehicles capable of 40 mpg were more like science experiments than real cars.
Then we tested a variety of new, more desirable cars in Fuel-Sipper Smackdown 2, and after dabbling last year in SUVs, we're back for another installment with a new set of appealing fuel sippers, and this time 40 mpg seems to be promised by every carmaker.
Well, we'll see about that.
First up is the Chevrolet Volt. GM's well-hyped plug-in hybrid is a no-brainer for this fuel economy test, which includes three different test routes: rural highway, city and interstate. How far will the Volt's all-electric cruising range extend? What fuel economy will it get once its all-electric power is gone? And how will a car designed to excel in the city fare on a road trip?
Next is the Kia Optima Hybrid, which has a gasoline-electric powertrain similar in concept to the Toyota Prius, only with a more conventional (and less costly) transmission. This transmission is a key reason that the Optima and its mechanical twin, the Hyundai Sonata Hybrid, promise the best highway fuel economy of any hybrid sedan.
Now, whoever says you need to drive a hybrid to be fuel-efficient is just dead wrong, and we always bring along plain-old gasoline-powered fuel sippers on these comparisons to prove the point. One is the Hyundai Elantra, which boasts an EPA estimate of 40 mpg highway without the aid of special fuel-economy technology packages like those found on the Chevy Cruze Eco and Ford Fiesta SFE.
We actually had a Fiesta pegged for this test, but a series of accidents experienced within Ford's press fleet nixed chances of driving a Fiesta SFE or Focus SFE in this comparison. The loss of the Fiesta left a spot open for our long-term Fiat 500, although since it has the least impressive EPA mileage ratings of the group, our expectations aren't high.
Finally, no smackdown would be complete without a Volkswagen Jetta TDI and its free-revving turbodiesel engine. This is the all-new, redesigned sedan introduced for 2011, and the diesel helps it earn an EPA-estimated 42 mpg highway. This is tops here, but we'll see if it translates into a winning performance in the real world.
The Country Highway Route
|Ranking by MPG||Ranking by Money Spent|
|1) 2011 Volkswagen Jetta TDI with 39.5 mpg||1) 2012 Fiat 500 with $43.04 of 91 octane|
|2) 2012 Fiat 500 with 39.4 mpg||2) 2011 Hyundai Elantra with $43.64 of 87 octane|
|3) 2011 Chevy Volt with 37.8 mpg and 23.5 miles of electric range (35.7 mpg gasoline only)||3) 2011 Volkswagen Jetta TDI with $44.10 of diesel|
|4) 2011 Hyundai Elantra with 34.3 mpg||4) 2011 Kia Optima Hybrid with $45.04 of 87 octane|
|5) 2011 Kia Optima Hybrid with 33.2 mpg||5) 2011 Chevy Volt with $44.92 of 91 octane and approx. $1.85 of electricity for $46.77|
Our first leg took us the extra-long way from Fontana, California, to Las Vegas, through Death Valley. These were lonely and occasionally very weird rural highways, and we traveled state highways with speed limits of 50 and 60 mph. This has been the best-case scenario for highway fuel economy in the past. But not this time.
The route began with a steep climb up the Cajon Pass, which quickly drained the Chevy Volt's battery and shrank its electric-only cruising range to a paltry 23.5 miles. This grade likely cost the Volt about 1 mpg from its overall performance at the end of the test, which came to 37.8 mpg over 385 miles. Then again, every vehicle in all four Fuel-Sipper Smackdowns had to climb the same hill.
Regardless of its E range, the Volt achieved only 35.7 mpg while its gasoline engine was running (40 mpg is estimated) and its small gas tank required us to fill up the car (a first in a Fuel-Sipper comparison, in fact). Another downside for the Volt's engine was its requirement for 91 octane fuel, which meant the Chevy was the most expensive car to run despite getting the third-best fuel economy.
In fact, fuel cost played a bigger role on this leg of rural highway than the others. The Hyundai Elantra fell a disappointing 5.7 mpg under its 40-mpg EPA estimate, yet it was actually the second cheapest to run because it uses 87 octane. The advantage of using regular gas didn't prove enough for the Optima Hybrid, however, which delivered a very disappointing 33.2 mpg. Even the fuel economy winner on this leg — the Volkswagen Jetta TDI — fell below its EPA estimates for highway mpg.
Could this be a sign that this year's test somehow is different from previous smackdowns? That was our thought until we ran the numbers on our last-minute addition to the test fleet, the Fiat 500. The little Fiat managed 39.4 mpg, which is better than its 38-mpg estimate — the kind of result in keeping with our previous tests on this leg of the route. So even though the Fiat had been handicapped to be worst in mpg on this driving leg, it nearly tied for 1st and was indeed the cheapest car to run.
Perhaps these results indicate that manufacturers are learning to tune their cars to achieve higher numbers in the revised EPA testing enacted in 2008 — numbers that have even less to do with real-world driving than before. Or maybe the Fiat is just that good.
The City Route
|Ranking by MPG||Ranking by Money Spent|
|1) 2011 Chevy Volt with 44.8 mpg and 44.3 miles of electric range (33.7 mpg gasoline only)||1) 2011 Chevy Volt with $16.40 of 91 octane and $1.50 of electricity for $17.90|
|2) 2011 Kia Optima Hybrid with 32.7 mpg||2) 2011 Kia Optima Hybrid with $19.14 of 87 octane|
|3) 2012 Fiat 500 with 31.3 mpg||3) 2012 Fiat 500 with $21.32 of 91 octane|
|4) 2011 Volkswagen Jetta TDI with 29.8 mpg||4) 2011 Hyundai Elantra with $22.25 of 87 octane|
|5) 2011 Hyundai Elantra with 28.2 mpg||5) 2011 Volkswagen Jetta TDI with $23.44 of diesel|
So if you take a Chevy Volt on a road trip, where do you charge it? Well, our Volt got a full load of electrons thanks to the EV Charge America charger installed at the Flamingo Las Vegas. The Flamingo is one of only a few hotel properties in Vegas to offer such a service (the Mandalay Bay and Luxor being the others). The Flamingo is a pioneer to be sure, and its staff actually painted the green lines with an "EV CAR" label around our car in the designated charging spot the night before we left on our 180-mile city driving loop around the greater Las Vegas area.
As for the city drive itself, the Volt took the crown with a gasoline-only average of 33.7 mpg. This was the best mpg on this leg, even without the benefit of its 44.3 miles of electric-only cruising range on this loop (its mpg for this leg would have been 44.8 mpg with the electric running factored in). Of course, if you keep your daily city driving below 44.3 miles (a good possibility), you'll be paying less for electricity. How much, exactly? Well, it cost approximately $1.50 in electricity to travel 44.3 miles in the Volt, whereas it costs $3.89 in gasoline to go 33.7 miles. The cost savings for electricity would certainly add up.
The Kia Optima Hybrid disappointed once again, its fuel efficiency falling below its EPA estimate of 35 mpg, but 2nd place is nevertheless still 2nd place. The other three cars were essentially competing among themselves. While the Elantra fell short of its estimate of EPA city mpg by about 1 mpg and the Jetta pretty well nailed its number of 30 mpg, the Fiat 500 once again proved to be an overachieving fuel-sipper. With prudent shifting of its five-speed manual transmission, we found the 500 capable of achieving 31.3 mpg in the city without forcing us to drive like a total grandma.
The Interstate Highway Route
|Ranking by MPG||Ranking by Money Spent|
|1) 2011 Chevy Volt with 45.2 mpg and 31.7 miles of electric range (39 mpg gasoline only)||1) 2011 Chevy Volt with $20.31 of 91 octane and $1.50 of electricity for $21.81|
|2) 2011 Volkswagen Jetta TDI with 40.4 mpg||2) 2011 Volkswagen Jetta TDI with $23.34 of diesel|
|3) 2012 Fiat 500 with 37.6 mpg||3) 2011 Hyundai Elantra with $24.14 of 87 octane|
|4) 2011 Hyundai Elantra with 36.2 mpg||4) 2012 Fiat 500 with $24.42 of 91 octane|
|5) 2011 Kia Optima Hybrid with 35.0 mpg||5) 2011 Kia Optima Hybrid with $24.97 of 87 octane|
This final 210-mile leg from Las Vegas to Fontana along Interstate 15 was not only more straightforward from a logistics standpoint but also more straightforward when it came to mpg rankings. The results were ordered just like the city loop, except the Elantra and 500 flip-flopped.
But here's a question: What if we couldn't have recharged the Volt? Well, the Volt would have achieved only 39 mpg, so it would've ceded its crown to the Jetta TDI. Yet we did charge up the Volt at the Flamingo, and the car managed 31.7 miles before firing up the gasoline engine. Unlike the first leg up Cajon Pass, I-15 out of Las Vegas is largely flat, more indicative of a regular strip of American freeway. We expect the Volt to get this sort of range on the average highway.
Once again, however, every car here managed to miss its EPA highway mpg number with the exception of the Fiat 500 (at least when you round up, as the EPA does).
The Final Cost
|Ranking by MPG||Ranking by Money Spent|
|1) 2011 Chevy Volt with 41 mpg and 99.5 miles of electric range (36.1 mpg gasoline only)||1) 2011 Chevy Volt with $83.70 of 91 octane and $4.85 of electricity for a grand total of $88.55|
|2) 2011 Volkswagen Jetta TDI with 37.2 mpg||2) 2012 Fiat 500 with $88.77 of 91 octane|
|3) 2012 Fiat 500 with 36.9 mpg||3) 2011 Kia Optima Hybrid with $89.15 of 87 octane|
|4) 2011 Kia Optima Hybrid with 33.6 mpg||4) 2011 Hyundai Elantra with $90.03 of 87 octane|
|5) 2011 Hyundai Elantra with 33.2 mpg||5) 2011 Volkswagen Jetta TDI with $90.88 of diesel|
So who wins? Well, in terms of mpg, then the Chevrolet Volt takes the rest of the pack to school (as long as you're able to recharge its battery, of course). In terms of overall cost, the Chevy Volt still wins, but there's only a $2.33 difference between it and the last-place Jetta TDI.
The Volt would've been cheaper to run if its engine achieved better fuel economy or ran on regular gas; the use of 87-octane gasoline would've given it a victory of $7.66 instead of just 22 cents. Still, apart from its fuel sipping, the Volt is a nice car to drive. Even when its all-electric charge runs out, the gasoline engine is less noticeable than in a Prius, while the Chevy's sophisticated ride, comfortable seats and well-appointed cabin set it apart from the rest, especially during our lengthy rural route through the desert. Two of our editors picked it as their favorite car, even though they admitted that buying one didn't make financial sense.
The biggest surprise here is the 2012 Fiat 500. It is the only car here to have met or exceeded its EPA mpg estimates on every leg in the test, beating cars that should theoretically have been more efficient. With a simple combination of tiny size, tiny engine and manual transmission, the Fiat managed to prove only 22 cents more expensive to run than the ultra-complex Volt (not to mention about $20,000 cheaper to purchase). Of course, not everyone can live with such a tiny car, but the 500 feels like a real car to drive, even if it might not look like one.
The Kia Optima Hybrid is a significant disappointment given the disparity between its EPA mpg estimates and our real-world results. Still, the advantage the Optima has in running 87-octane gasoline lands it in 3rd place. Its good looks, practical sedan packaging, spacious interior and ample feature content led one of our editors to pick it as his favorite. Of course, the same attributes apply to the regular, more affordable Kia Optima, which nearly matches the Hybrid's fuel economy, so we'd buy one of those instead.
The Hyundai Elantra came close to its EPA estimate in the city, but fell far below its lofty 40-mpg target on both our highway legs. Yet, of all the cars here, the Elantra is the most "normal." It runs on regular gas, it has a spacious sedan interior and it doesn't rely on power-sapping Eco buttons (like the Optima) or overly conservative transmission programming (like countless other cars) to achieve its thriftiness. Perhaps if the Elantra used such fuel-saving tricks it would produce better EPA numbers, but then it would be worse to drive, and that would be a shame. The Elantra is one of the best compact sedans on the road, 40 mpg or no.
Finally, the trusty Volkswagen Jetta TDI brings up the rear because diesel fuel is a good 10 cents per gallon more expensive than premium at the moment. In a year, diesel could be cheaper or a buck pricier; you just never know. What we do know is that the diesel-powered VW Jetta is one of the simplest ways to save fuel, and the car has one of the lowest price tags. We're not especially keen on the Jetta sedan's recent redesign, but two of our editors still picked the TDI as the car they'd happily take home (even if they'd pay a few cents more to get there).
In the end, this test showed us three things. First, figuring out just how thrifty the 2012 Chevrolet Volt is requires a mathematician and a whole lot of perspective. Second, carmakers seem to be figuring out how to maximize results in the EPA test, so when you compare your car's real-world fuel economy with its EPA ratings, well, your mileage may vary, as the expression goes. And finally, this fourth Fuel-Sipper Smackdown has shown us that it's never been easier to find a car that will roll out of your driveway and get really great fuel economy.