I have the SXT. I can't wipe the smile from my face when I'm driving. I'm getting used to people turning to watch the car go by. I have a hard time passing in traffic because of people riding beside my car to look it over. Gas mileage is averaging about 23mpg for a mix of city/highway driving and goes to about 27 on all highway. It exceeds what I got in my PT Cruiser.
The look is incredible. Gas mileage is better than expected. I feel like I'm in a tank. The ride is fantastic. Can't speak highly enough. So far it is the best car I've ever owned. Even my husband, a die-hard truck fanatic, likes to drive it.
Not so much plastic on the doors. It marks too easily. Make the cup holders a bit bigger/deeper as cups will fall over on sharp turns. Make rear cup holders standard on all models (it is a family car!) Make them bigger too.