2002 Chevrolet Camaro 2dr Convertible (3.8L 6cyl 5M)
Excellent reliability. I have had this car for almost five years and have spent $0 on repairs, outside of normal maintenance. Gas mileage is great, given the current price of gas. Unique enough that I typically do not see another like it going down the road. Handling is excellent. I drive the car year round and have driven in a foot of snow with no problem (My son's Mazda 626 got stuck!)
The convertible top, styling, and performance. It makes the daily commute fun. Easy to maintain. Tons of aftermarket parts available.
Hard to see out of the back. Getting out can be tricky in tight spaces due to large doors. Back seat is not much use.