2000 BMW Z3 2.8 2dr Coupe
I've owned alot of cars including a Porsche 944, but this has to be my favorite! This little coupe gets a consistant 30 MPG and is a hoot to drive. It handles like a go cart in the twisties and has plenty of power. Unlike the convertible, you can actually pack a weekends worth of gear in the back- or a weeks worth of groceries if that's what you need...did I mention that it's FUN TO DRIVE?!?!
Styling- you either love it or you hate it. It is a LOT more rare than the convertible, though- you won't see yourself passing by every few minutes.
My only complaint is that the interior is a bit cramped for those 6 ft. and over. My husband did survive a 2300 MI journey from Wis. to North Carolina though (in the passenger seat of course)!